News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by xg15 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:16PM (#34716225)
I find it extremely jarring how many reputable western media outlets immediately jumped to the conclusion that Russia did it even though that made zero sense - but absolutely refused to even consider the possibility that the US or another western state could have done it.

But at this point, the article is basically "cool story, bro". The only independently verifyable bits are the public statements of Biden, Nuland, etc, which are already well-known. But those only show that the US really really really didn't like the pipelines - and that was never a secret. They do not give any evidence for a planned operation to destroy them.

The rest of the article is amazingly detailed but only based on an anonymous source. Even if we trust that the source existed, there is no way to know if that source itself is trustworthy.

So as of now, I don't the information in the article would convince anyone of the "US did it" hypothesis who wasn't already convinced.

I think the only thing that the article is useful for is as a future reference. It could be useful to remember the details and keep an eye if they match with any future developments.

Re: by alchemist1e9 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:23PM (#34716330)
> I find it extremely jarring how many reputable western media outlets immediately jumped to the conclusion that Russia did it even though that made zero sense - but absolutely refused to even consider the possibility that the US or another western state could have done it.

One simple hypothesis would be that it is only an illusion that western media outlets are independent from their governments.

Re: by chii on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:18PM (#34719696)
There's been many instances of western media outlets being hugely critical of the US gov't.
Re: by hackandthink on Thursday February 09, 2023 @07:42AM (#34723118)
A german book by Precht/Welzer argues it's the other way.

The media became a power by itsself and it's the media which influences the government.

And they analyze how the media synchronized itself on certain topics (especially Ukraine war).

https://www.fischerverlage.de/buch/richard-david-precht-hara...

Re: by xg15 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @02:59PM (#34730413)
That would match my impression in Germany on issues about involvement in the war. Usually, the government is divided, with FDP and Greens taking a hawkish position, arguing for strong support of Ukraine including weapons and not making any concessions to Russia; while SPD and the chancellor are cautious to the point of dragging their feet.

Meanwhile the press is not similarly divided but usually follows the hawkish position. So whatever opinion they are promoting, it's evidently not the government's.

Re: by 0xDEF on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:30PM (#34716443)
>I find it extremely jarring how many reputable western media outlets immediately jumped to the conclusion that Russia did it

Do you have proof to back up this claim? A more correct observation is that Western media didn't blame any single entity but has the attention span of a goldfish and forgot about this incident after a week or two.

Re: by xg15 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:52PM (#34716738)
I live in Germany and my proof is that a few days after the explosions, I could read/watch Spiegel, Tagesschau and other outlets quoting speculations about Russia as "expert opinions", while discussing speculations about the US only in context of "russian accusations".

A Spiegel article from september 28, two days after the incident: https://www.spiegel.de/ausland/nord-stream-spekulationen-ueb...

It links to a Times article allegedly saying the same (but behind a paywall unfortunately, so I can't check): https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/russia-probably-bombed-no...

Re: by hanspeter on Thursday February 09, 2023 @01:46AM (#34720524)
All mainstream media in Denmark has been reporting "No proof of Russian sabotage on Nordstream" this week.

They're simply going for views and readers. The exciting story back in September was that Russia had sabotaged the pipeline. It was then more or less established that they probably did, so now the exciting story is that they might not have!

Re: by xg15 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @01:50PM (#34729105)
Spiegel is now reporting about Hersh's article as well. They seem more interested in dismantling Hersh however than commenting on any of his claims in detail: https://www.spiegel.de/ausland/russland-duma-sprecher-wjatsc...

Other outlets seem to be commenting a bit more neutral: https://www.stern.de/politik/ausland/nord-stream-2--usa-soll...

Re: by vasergen on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:56PM (#34716790)
> that Russia did it even though that made zero sense

Can you explain then please how much sense did Russia had to start a war in Ukraine?

Re: by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:36PM (#34717339)
This is detail pretty well in an article I think I found here first.

If Russia ever wanted to take Ukraine “back”, it had to do it now. It would only get harder and less likely as time goes on. Now, as to why of take Ukraine back at all, IDK, beautiful women, I assume.

I’m not sure anyone can answer the why, really, but the why now seems to have reason.

Re: by pessimizer on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:48PM (#34717484)
This is not a good faith question. If you wanted to know the arguments that Russia made regarding the invasion of Ukraine, you would have googled them sometime within the past year. What you want is for somebody to type those reasons here so you can respond to them with invective.
Re: by jasmer on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @08:22PM (#34718430)
Putin thought he could roll into Kyiv like the USSR did in Hungary and Czech, and like he did in Crimea. Bloodless coup. Massive show of strength no rational person would try to fight.

The entire world thought Ukraine was going to collapse.

Diplomats from big countries were telling Zelensky to his face that he had '24 hours' before Russia took Kyiv.

The pipeline thing is a bit of a mystery.

Re: by xg15 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:39PM (#34733366)
Dude, I have no idea. There are absolutely a lot of illogical things in Russia's motivation for the war.

Also, I'm no strategist or whatever. I'm just saying that strategically, it doesn't make sense for me if it was russia:

The explosion happened close to the western end of the pipeline[1], deep within the territory of NATO countries. Why would you send troops there and risk being exposed - for a pipeline which originates in your own country? If russia wanted to stage a false-flag operation, it cold have done so close to its own waters with the same impact but a lot less risk.

(Of course you can argue going to unusual locations makes false-flag operations more convincing and we're just perpetuating the false-flag narrative with exactly those speculations. That's absolutely possible but smells a bit like 4D chess arguments to me. Usually "that's what they want you to think" is the realm of conspiracy theories)

Also: Around the time of the bombing, the general expectation was that Germany was at high risk of a gas/energy crunch in late winter. There were extensive discussions about gas reserves, expected black/brownouts, possible industry shutdowns, etc. Today, we know it didn't happen (or rather was sucessfully averted with the help of EU neighbors) but no one could know that back then. Add to that that there were still quite a number of people friendly to russia (or at least interested in a quick peace) in germany's political sphere.

If the energy crunch had really happened and if the Nordstream pipelines had been still theoretically available, I'm very sure there would have been immense pressure on the government to open up the pipelines and return to russian gas at least for the remainder of winter.

By blowing up the pipelines, russia was making that scenario impossible from the get-go, effectively doing the west a favor.

[1] https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2022/10/Nordstream...

Re: by hoffs on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:04PM (#34716898)
>I find it extremely jarring how many reputable western media outlets immediately jumped to the conclusion that Russia did it even though that made zero sense

Your ignorance is astounding

Re: by GartzenDeHaes on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:38PM (#34717357)
"reputable western media outlets" I think you mean Military Industrial Media Complex.
Re: by MasterYoda on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:41PM (#34717409)
It make sense. russia's agenda is to destabilize Europe. And they were the only ones who had anything directly to gain from it with certainty as they wanted to create an energy crisis in Europe. They knew that after the EU sanctions, Nord stream would be a dead project after their illegal invasion. By blowing up what now had no real long term economic value, they created uncertainty and it helped to get the energy prices to skyrocket in Europe and they succeeded in their goal of destabilizing Europe's energy market. All the Russians want is to create as much havoc for the West they can and create conflicts and make west weak, just of that reason it make totally sense to blow it up.
Re: by himinlomax on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:30AM (#34721600)
> jumped to the conclusion that Russia did it even though that made zero sense

It makes a lot of sense. The pipeline was rendered useless anyway, they get to blame the US and sowing division by planting stories such as these, and they also send a message that they can blow up stuff underwater anywhere; in particular, undersea cables, whose destruction would cause major economic problems.