News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by videoappeal on Monday January 16, 2012 @09:55AM (#3470803)
Can you clarify non-profit, non-profit nowadays means very little, ICANN is non-profit and is about to fuck up top-top level domains so their CEO can buy a helicopter. Do you draw a salary and how much?
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by corin_ on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:02AM (#3470827)
You're not wrong that this is sometimes the case, but definitely worth noting that plenty of the best charities in the world are non-profits with some salaried employees, it doesn't automatically make them evil.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by videoappeal on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:19AM (#3470891)
For sure, I hope you dont object I've just registered adsbycappuccino, my idea is to make it a non-profit ad agency that does work for benefit of charities, in my business plan Ive decided to pay myself $120k pa (is yours the same? we can share a coffee and talk) presuming we get that via donations and running some commercial ads in the roration. It should take off as those stupid HN readers will see non-profit and put some rockets behind my startup. Sweet.. :D
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by corin_ on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:23AM (#3470907)
Yeah, that's an example of it being bad, what I'm saying is that a charitee with paid staff isn't automatically evil, it's not so black and white.

For example, let's say this charity has a range of options for getting free advert spots on sites for charities. Option A is to have people who care but don't have the experience, and they get X monthly impressions. Option B is to pay someone a low full-time wage, say $30k, and they get Y monthly impressions. Option C is to pay a fantastic salesman $120k/year and he can pull in Z monthly impressions. Until you know the numbers, is option C guaranteed to be bad for the charity?

And of course that's just an example of a high salary - my first comment, that you replied to, was talking more about charities like Oxfam, where without any paid staff they just couldn't operate, they're far too big to be run on a 100% volunteer basis. But people they do employ are paid lower-than-typical salaries for their positions, and a large number of their work force are indeed volunteers.

Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by videoappeal on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:30AM (#3470935)
Agreed. But with no transparency it pays to be cynical. In addition, bootstrapping it by asking HN to commit their time and web space whilst drawing a salary is a bit of a slap in the face from day 1. Im sure a consortium of true HN readers could get this off the ground without salary employees, maybe in six months then it would make sense to appoint salary positions such as a treasurer and top-notch biz dev person.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by wtvanhest on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:09AM (#3470854)
Yes, both of you are right, but it would still be nice to understand exactly how much of a non-profit they are.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by nodata on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:11AM (#3470860)
Red flag: you avoided answering the question.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by corin_ on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:13AM (#3470871)
Well that's because I have nothing to do with this charity and I work at a completely unrelated for-profit company...
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by hluska on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:19AM (#3470892)
I'd go so far as to argue that I have trouble trusting non-profits that do not pay their staff. If a not for profit wants to compete for good people, they need to pay them a living wage.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by brudgers on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:21AM (#3470901)
U.S. Nonprofit != charity
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by videoappeal on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:26AM (#3470921)
Indeed, but perception is a powerful thing, a non-profit for charities especially. Microsoft and [insert-evil-company-of-choice] could be non-profit if you soak up any remaining revenue by salary/bonuses. I mean ICANN is non-profit and the CEO already has put a down payment on a learjet from his new $185,000 tld registrar. My point is that they are soliciting free work from HN readers on some illusion of acting like a charity (it might turn out legit and verifiable, who knows) whilst being as transparent as a SOPA.
Re:Hacker News: Our Tiny Charity Desperately Needs Your Help by brudgers on Monday January 16, 2012 @12:17PM (#3471487)
I was simply giving the short form version.