News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:37PM (#34702231)
Anyone taking this at face value is misinterpreting the current Montana political situation. There's a Republican majority in both houses and also the governor and most of the executive positions are red as well. In all likelihood, this won't pass, and was never designed to pass.

What is happening is that the Montana University System Board of Regents serve a 7 year term. The previous governor had two terms in office, and so he appointed the entire board of regents. He was "purple" in so far that "purple" means he lied to the populace to try and pretend he wasn't as left leaning as he actually is. One place this lie wore thin was with the MUS Board of Regents, which are not revocable and wield near-absolute power in the University system, as defined by the Montana constitution. His regent picks were as hard left as possible. In addition to that, Bozeman and Missoula, the homes of the two major campuses in the state, have attracted a huge influx of Californians/Coloradans, drastically driving up the cost of living, meaning both U of M and MSU have astronomical cost of attendance, despite being subsidized state schools.

The end result of all this is that the current political climate is that Missoula and Bozeman are not at all representative of the rest of the state, as evidenced by the overwhelming Republican victories in the last couple elections, but the newly elected state legislature and governor are unable to change the University policies quickly enough for their liking.

There are currently multiple thrusts in the state legislature to reign in the universities, with challenges over guns on campus, challenges against the public union (mostly made up by teachers and graduate students) and challenges over budget. All of these are designed simply to wield power over the Board.

By my estimation, the MUS Board of Regents are effectively unelected tyrants who are doing the state a great disservice. And their behavior begets crap like this. (Which is also stupid and awful). These are the types of stupid games we get to play when there's no direct accountability. Anyways, until the Board of Regents is more in-touch with the average Montanan (who are not from Missoula or Bozeman) and trying to solve problems relevant to Montana, this unfortunate lose-lose war will continue.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by dd36 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:42PM (#34702290)
What’s an example of something tyrannical they’ve done such that science is now a target?
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:51PM (#34702421)
Evolution is a tyranny to small minded people.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @10:57PM (#34703942)
Science is not the target (maybe to this one freshman congressman, but not the greater legislative agenda).

The row precipitated over a ballot initiative that gave Montanans the right to carry firearms on public property, including college campuses. The ballot initiative instructed the legislature to craft law outlining this. The legislature worked with the colleges for months coming up with a number of compromises in exchange for the university system not fighting the bill. After the bill was passed (remember, it was mandated by a direct public ballot initiative), the unelected Board of Regents sued to stop it on the grounds that they have complete authority over all policy on state campuses. The legislate argues that state law (and the state constitution gaurantees a right to bear arms) supercedes it. There have since been a number of minor skirmishes, while that main case is tied up in court. This is an attempt by the legislature to further erode the constitutional clause governing public education being seperately governed.

Had the Board of Regents respected the ballot initiative, this likely would not be getting introduced, because the House leaders would have stopped it.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by dd36 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:28AM (#34710433)
Seems like they must sue if that’s the law? Otherwise they’re not independent as the law requires?

Tyrannical seems like a stretch?

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by duxup on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:43PM (#34702312)
I’m confused about how this all works together. There are a lot of gaps in this story and it sounds like a hysterical “outside people are moving into town” narrative.

How are these regents “hard left”?

How did the regents somehow attract “ a huge influx of Californians/Coloradans”?

Aren’t cost of living issues a local issue around these campuses, at least as far as housing goes? Montana can’t be short on space…

And what does any of that have to do with the bill in question? The bill is about k-12 education.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by twelve40 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:26PM (#34702815)
it sounds plausible, I lived there and visit every once in a while.

there is an influx of people for sure (just go check Wikipedia population numbers, esp. for towns mentioned) and it has nothing to do with the regents (and I don't think the parent said that)

habitable space, at least in bozeman, is very tight because you're bounded by the Gallatin Valley, everything outside has little to none infrastructure to accommodate any meaningful incoming number of people, same situation as the SFBA - there is plenty of cheap space in central valley but people pay 1.5m+ to live right in sf.

don't have enough info to vouch for the whole story, but sounds believable

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by duxup on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:39PM (#34702945)
I’m not sure any population increase really means any of the other post’s story is true.

Rural populations have been moving to suburban size towns for a long time now.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by twelve40 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:51PM (#34703039)
you can look up some links to back up your claim that this Bozeman movement is from rural places, but I really doubt that's the case for this one.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by duxup on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:55PM (#34703091)
I’m not claiming anything. Another person seemed to claim they were from CA and CO…. somehow due to the action of some regents… without anything to backup the whole story.

I’m saying that any population increase doesn’t support any given theory. There can be all sorts of reasons for population changes.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @10:46PM (#34703869)
I never claim it's due to the Regents, although school policies have probably contributed. But if you go back and read my comment, you will see I don't credit the regents with increasing the population of the college towns, but rather paint the picture that the college towns are growing less accessible to Montanans, and that there's some resentment over that which is being expressed by the legislature.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by duxup on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @11:20PM (#34704087)
> although school policies have probably contributed

Like what?

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:12AM (#34704388)
Increasing enrollment, and the fraction of students from out of state. Both have increased quite a bit.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by reducesuffering on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:40PM (#34702953)
Have you looked at the area surrounding Bozeman on a map? https://www.google.com/maps/@45.7139136,-111.2522263,97391m/...

It's nothing like SFBA, there are miles and miles of open land to the west of Bozeman, all around Belgrade, Four Corners, and Manhattan.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by twelve40 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @08:52PM (#34703058)
sure. a Manteca property is still less desirable than SF or a peninsula one, even though sfba is not dense by any means. That's not my fault.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:47PM (#34702361)
And if "a huge influx of Californians/Coloradans" has been attracted isn't that likely changing the political climate since MT is a low population state?
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by heyoni on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:51PM (#34702418)
I’m not familiar with Montana specifically but gerrymandering could buffer the effects of that influx.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @10:40PM (#34703823)
> How are these regents “hard left”?

All Dem donors, all enacting policies at the schools that are widely considered "left" policies.

> How did the regents somehow attract “ a huge influx of Californians/Coloradans”?

By catering strongly to out-of-state students (presumably because the schools make more of them). Both U of M and MSU are at all time high out-of-state enrollment.

> Aren’t cost of living issues a local issue around these campuses, at least as far as housing goes? Montana can’t be short on space…

Yes. What you aren't considering is that Montana is big enough that if you don't live in the local valleys, you can't go to the school. The commutes are too long and too treacherous from outside the valleys. By taking both record freshman classes for the last few years, and record out of state students, plus the pandemic meaning Californians fleeing California anyways, cost of living in Bozeman and Missoula has skyrocketed, and campus housing is impossible to get.

> And what does any of that have to do with the bill in question? The bill is about k-12 education.

It's aimed specifically at the Montana Federation of Public Employees, and the Board, as described in the article:

>A legal note from legislative staff says the bill could overstep the Board of Public Education’s constitutional authority to oversee schools in the state.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by themitigating on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @11:15PM (#34704057)
"All Dem donors, all enacting policies at the schools that are widely considered "left" policies."

What policies?

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:12AM (#34704384)
I have comment further down the thread discussing it. Biggest one is suing to stop a ballot initiative over guns.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by themitigating on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @08:24AM (#34707632)
Doesn't blocking scientific theory affect a large amount of people and not the head of this regents board?

Should the government be used to punish people you disagree with? Even if its just for show?

You're an engineer, I assume this because you're on Hackernews, but you wrote paragraph after paragraph defending this obscenely stupid bill. I know it hasn't gone anywhere and probably won't but the mere existence of this is shocking

Telling us that this internal state dispute is a justification for something like this is just too much. You also speak about Representatives Emrich having no choice as if he some animal. This is a person who people voted for in your state.

What's wrong with you

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:06AM (#34710012)
> Doesn't blocking scientific theory affect a large amount of people and not the head of this regents board?

Yes. The goal of the legislature is to erode authority of that section of the state constitution.

>Should the government be used to punish people you disagree with? Even if its just for show?

Absolutely not. That includes actions taken by the Board of Regents in direct opposition to public ballot initiatives.

>You're an engineer, I assume this because you're on Hackernews, but you wrote paragraph after paragraph defending this obscenely stupid bill. I know it hasn't gone anywhere and probably won't but the mere existence of this is shocking

I'm a PhD research scientist at one of the big public institutions in Montana.

>Telling us that this internal state dispute is a justification for something like this is just too much. You also speak about Representatives Emrich having no choice as if he some animal. This is a person who people voted for in your state.

I never say it's justified, just predictable. The Board acted unilaterally and in opposition to public ballot measures. The legislature is responding exactly how it was predicted. Everyone loses. Emrich having no choice I'm not sure what you mean. I'm saying this bill would not have been submitted if the legislature didn't have an axe to grind against the Board. Perhaps you misunderstood the terminology "lose-lose"?

>What's wrong with you

Not sure why this is phrased as a question, since you apparently just explained to me in ample detail what is wrong with me.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by themitigating on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:41PM (#34719827)
"Absolutely not. That includes actions taken by the Board of Regents in direct opposition to public ballot initiatives"

Example

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by themitigating on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:26PM (#34748541)
I'm still waiting for that example
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by dang on Saturday February 11, 2023 @10:43AM (#34753315)
Crossing into personal attack is not ok and will get you banned here, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are.

If someone is wrong, the thing to do is to patiently and respectfully explain how they are wrong, without swipes, name-calling, or cheap shots. Your posts in this thread were much too aggressive. We've had to ask you not to do this more than once in the past.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by allturtles on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:45PM (#34702327)
Whatever the merits of what you're saying, the bill in question is about K-12 education, so I don't see how it relates to any effort to rein in the universities.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @10:48PM (#34703888)
All of public education in Montana falls under the same clause in the state constitution. This is an attack on that clause.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by nsajko on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:46PM (#34702342)
Your comment provides some interesting context, but your perspective is twisted. You're basically saying that the current Republican state government should be allowed to make a putsch on the Uni Goverment, so that's why they're justified in attacking science.

There's obviously multiple deficiencies of logic there.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @10:47PM (#34703886)
All I'm saying is that this is the current climate. I'm not saying either side is right, just that when the Regents started exercising unilateral authority and ignoring the legislature, that this outcome was predictable.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:51PM (#34702413)
> Anyways, until the Board of Regents is more in-touch with the average Montanan (who are not from Missoula or Bozeman)

Montana is a low population state (1.1 Million in 2021). If Missoula and Bozeman are growing as much as you say they are (" a huge influx of Californians/Coloradans") won't that have some effect on who the "average Montanan" is?

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @11:10PM (#34704020)
Probably eventually, but perhaps not quite yet. Montana is clearly in a transition phase.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by qbrass on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:45AM (#34705309)
The average Montanan is a cow, there are twice as many of them living there than people.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by toss1 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:56PM (#34702495)
Ummm... sounds great.

Except that scientific facts are not democratic; they exist as they are, regardless of your or my opinion, I've never seen scientific theory presented as anything but "this is the current most effective explanation of the facts", and academic freedom is a subset of protected free speech.

Politicians should not be even in the same continent as setting curricula.

This is a general assertion that "regent picks were as hard left as possible", without the slightest bit of context as to the actual meaning of that statement. What "hard left" policies are they pursuing? Or is it just as "hard left as possible" in the context of an entirely anti-science right-wing caucus, meaning that they still have a slight tether to reality? (and sorry, but the entire basis of right wing rhetoric has been entirely anti-science and anti-education for the past decade; there is zero credibility there.)

Let us be clear: In a democracy, all of the institutions of a society are independent, starting with the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of govt, and also the societal components of the press, academy, industry, religion, charity, etc.

In an autocracy, all of these societal institutions are coerced and restructured to bend to the will of the executive or religious leaders.

This is nothing less than a key component of a broad attempt to destroy democracy.

Stop trying to justify it; it makes you look like an autocrat.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @11:05PM (#34703989)
I am a PhD research scientist at one of these Montana universities. I am merely commenting on how the situation has played politically. But thank you for explaining to me what "scientific fact" is.
Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by toss1 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @09:16AM (#34708298)
Congratulations — an impressive achievement!

Yet how is it that you are here publicly writing and posting multiple paragraphs defending the existence and authors of a bill that would ban teaching scientific theories?

There is little that is more anti-scientific than attempting to ban science.

Whatever local politics may have lead to this, the larger and most relevant context is that the right wing in this country and internationally is making a major anti-science push, against every part of science from evolution to vaccines, in the interest of installing quasi- or actual Christo-fascist governments.

This bill is part and parcel of that push, and no local politics, however heinous, can excuse that; yet here you are attempting to excuse it.

Failing to recognize the borader anti-science context and not wholly objecting to it (despite some perceived positives regarding your resented board of regents) quite obscures and contradicts your scientific background and achievements. The appearance is that your local political outlook is more core to your being than all your laudable scientific work, to the point that it is not even evident that you did any.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by COGlory on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:09AM (#34710072)
>Yet how is it that you are here publicly writing and posting multiple paragraphs defending the existence and authors of a bill that would ban teaching scientific theories?

I must be missing the part where I'm defending it. Perhaps a reading comprehension issue on my side? I'm pointing out that with the Board's actions, this type of reaction from the legislature was predictable. And all the Board had to do was act differently and they could have avoided it. How is that a defense of this bill? In my very first comment, I end with the term "lose-lose". The way the Board acted was bad - they overturned a public ballot initiative and claimed they have no public recourse. Obviously the way legislature reacted is also bad. Hence the term "lose-lose".

>This bill is part and parcel of that push, and no local politics, however heinous, can excuse that; yet here you are attempting to excuse it.

You've provided no evidence for this claim. I've provided substantial evidence to the contrary.

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by toss1 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:16PM (#34715290)
>>missing the part where I'm defending it.

OK, 1) pointing out that both houses, the Gov, and Exec suite are all Repubs does not lead to the conclusion that it cannot pass, but increases it's liklihood (unless something unspecified and unusual is going on). 2) "MUS Board of Regents ... are doing the state a great disservice. And their behavior begets crap like this. That sounds an awful lot like "what skirt was she wearing"?

To your credit, you do also say "Which is also stupid and awful". But the whole thing is effectively excusing the existence of this bill, as if it were a trivial annoying response to some local/state issue, when it in fact is part o a global movement to install Christofascism and destroy science for all time.

Maybe you're not intending to defend it, but the result is that you certainly are at best, framing it as trivial rather than the serious issue that it is. and that amounts to at least a weak defense of a voice permitting it to continue to exist, rather than directly opposing it.

Evidence? I've been following this for years. Just type "antiscience aggression movement" into DDG and start scrolling. Here's a few of the first results [0,1,2,3].

We are already effectively in a hot war with global authoritarian movements, not only in Ukraine, but also in locally and foreign-pushed attempts to undermine the democracy at home.

A key component of democracy is the independence of all key institutions, the govt executive, legislative, and judicial branches, but also the academy, industry, religion, commerce, localities, charities, etc.

Under Authoritarianism, all of these institutions are coerced and/or corrupted to serve the will of the ruling executive or religion.

Ending science (which requires independent thought) and reigning in the Academy under the rule of the state are two of these components.

You may see this as just a local tempest in a teapot, just as people might see local gerrymandering as just a local issue.

But, make no mistake: both the anti-science bill and the corralling the university leadership moves are just part of this much larger goal of implementing and consolidating authoritarian power.

Your Regents are not playing offense, but defense, and your hot tempest is just one ember in the global fire.

[0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-antiscience-m...

[1] https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/10/what-caused-t...

[2] https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jou...

[3] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antiscience-belie...

Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon... by molotovh on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:13AM (#34706631)
Thank you for providing some local perspective. These things don't just happen in a vacuum but it can be hard to discern the threads that got us here without eyewitness accounts.