News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by danuker on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:07PM (#34695452)
I wonder how the WGA will change its tune when language models will write episodes of indistinguishable quality from human writers.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by camillomiller on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:11PM (#34695517)
The Level of cringe of this comment is off the charts
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by luckydata on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:08PM (#34695471)
wow it took only one comment to make the article right, and it's not only the elite, it's even the "little people" doing a lot of the hating.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by danuker on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:41PM (#34696003)
Taking feedback is a sign of maturity and adaptability.

Genuinely, what will happen with writers when scripts will be a dime a dozen, because people are going to use these new technologies?

Thinking about these scenarios is the POINT of a union, making sure writers stay relevant for the long-term future. Failing to address them makes for a lot of broken dreams and missed opportunities.

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @01:06PM (#34696455)
> what will happen with writers when scripts will be a dime a dozen

Being nowhere close to this, it’s difficult to say. Maybe the creative field gets reduced to the guy who can put the right prompt into a script, voice-acting and moving-image combined model?

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by thebradbain on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @01:13PM (#34696587)
Scripts are already a dime a dozen! The stereotype you see in tv shows of unemployed writers writing screenplays in coffee shops is because writers of those tv shows are making fun of themselves.

An experienced writer could (and does) make an entire first draft of a script for a tv show in less than a day. Before your first job out of college you likely have 10+ scripts for movies or shows written for a portfolio. 99% of scripts written already will never see the light of day— and that includes the ones that get bought!

Hollywood does have genuine shortcomings, but I can guarantee you one is not the lack of scripts, nor even the lack of good scripts.

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by mrzimmerman on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @09:27PM (#34703317)
It is a fair point (I think your tone is what has set people off, and for the record I didn’t enjoy it either). The real question, in my opinion, is what does humanity do in general with our fellow humans whose labor is displaced by some form of automation? And that fully includes all of us here on Hacker News.

Do we prevent the lose of income to people by forming a collective bargaining group (guild, union, co-op—whatever you’d like) to prevent the job loss and maintain income? Do we tax the owners of businesses who are using large amounts of automation so that the profits are shared with larger society? Do we let the market figure out it out?

It’s an incredibly difficult and complicated question and I don’t have a good answer. But I do personally believe that the people who will be hit hardest will be average people: ourselves and our neighbors and we should consider how we want to react to that fact sooner rather than later.

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by danuker on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:25AM (#34705565)
I think one way to stay safe is to buy shares in competitors or disruptors. If, say, pension funds include automation companies, you get a much more resilient future.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by vkou on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:12PM (#34695522)
I wonder when SWEs will change their tune when the same thing will happen to them.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by marssaxman on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:41PM (#34695999)
We're in the business of making the same thing happen to ourselves.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by bdcravens on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @12:26PM (#34695751)
The same way SWEs should have changed their tune when faced with outsourcing: Expand your skillset to ensure you're more than just an expensive commodity.
Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by vkou on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @02:00PM (#34697405)
1. Why do you think the writers won't be able to do the same? They are writers, they aren't idiots.

2. That's great advice for buggy horses who want to win the game of musical chairs, but when the number of jobs for SWEs will drop to ~200,000 in the country, what are the other million going to be doing?

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by bdcravens on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @03:12PM (#34698745)
> Why do you think the writers won't be able to do the same? They are writers, they aren't idiots.

Didn't say they were. Was only addressing the comment about SWEs.

> when the number of jobs for SWEs will drop to ~200,000 in the country, what are the other million going to be doing

What they did after the dotcom crash - become the upper 15-20%, shift to another job in tech (project management, devops, etc) or switch entirely to another job like car sales, accounting, or greeting customers at Walmart.

Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor by gamblor956 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @02:18PM (#34697752)
About the same as programmers will feel when language models churn out better software than human programmers are capable of. Based on some blog posts from this morning, it seems ChatpGPT already conquered coding WordPress plugins despite it's notoriously difficult and nonsensical codebase, and at this rate ChapGPT should be able to replace most programmers by Independence Day. It should gain sentience on or by August 29th.

Sarcasm aside, the volume of scripts has never been the problem in Hollywood. Everybody and their mother has a screenplay. 99% of screenplays that are actually purchased aren't worth making. There are plenty of people who make a good living, outearning the average SV FAANG programmer, just churning out 1 or 2 C-movie scripts a year that they might spend a week or two writing.

And even the screenplays that get made aren't very good. One of my former clients made his fortune making D-movie action films, some of which you may have seen on cable or streaming. The entire portion of the screenplay dedicated to the gunfight at the end of one of his recent films was: "They have an epic fucking gunfight. Explosions everywhere. It's FUCKING AWESOME." (If you look up the screenplay for the movie adaptation of SWAT, the minutes-long fight at the beginning of the film is similarly scripted. By the way, that movie made $200m+.)