News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by jodrellblank on Monday February 06, 2023 @11:35AM (#34679922)
> "All of this, to dabble in code"

I'm not a professional programmer, and when my laptop takes 10 minutes to start moving the mouse cursor smoothly after waking from a weekend suspend (today!), I'm pointing fingers at you all, the professional "dabblers" who don't understand computers, don't understand firewalls, don't understand databases, don't understand algorithms, don't understand garbage collectors, don't understand or care about any kind of security or legal compliance regulations, don't optimise anything, don't want any constraints, any meetings, any plans, any accountability, just want to 'optimise developer productivity' where you play with the most fun framework of the day and millions of users suffer the consequences of it.

"Developers" have only "developers" to blame for how software takes down a 1,000,000 IOPS SSD to the point of complete machine unresponsiveness. It's not 'Jira' or 'stories' or 'weaponised Agile' or 'Indian outsourcers' or 'management' doing that.

Maybe instead of seeing it as red tape garrotting you or an abusive guardian at the front door with a shotgun, see it as end users with scowls their hired heavies at the door, end users wanting their computers back from your code, wanting their data back from your clutches, wanting their time back from your advertising, wanting their lives back from your industry's overreach. People who've had enough of the priority always being your comfort and convenience. People who've had to bring in the security heavies with their legal and compliance regulation to try and herd you because left to yourselves you leave SQL injection and plain text secrets and cross site scripting and logging libraries that can talk to the internet and execute arbitrary code and when told to get your act together, throw your toys out of the pram and want dynamic languages and moving fast and breaking things because anything else is too boring.

Hobbyists can be dabblers, end users can be dabblers, people who get their job done in VBA and Excel or a Perl script copied from the web, or IFTTT, you aren't "here to help", you're here to laugh at them for using VBA and Windows and offer them a worthless meta-interpreter in LISP or a workflow from the 1970s. People are crying out for help and all they get from professional developers is scorn of business apps and CRUD software and yet another text editor and whining that it doesn't work on Linux. End users are not interested in whether Java has type erasure in its generics, or whether the BEAM VM is outdated or whether TypeScript is an improvement on JavaScript, they're interested in how to share a spreadsheet with a supplier in another company and why search never returns what they typed in, and why their phone can't respond to the 'answer call' button before the caller hangs up.

As 'Uncle' Bob Martin said in a talk in some recent year, if the software development industry can't sort this out itself, if it can't fix the Boeing 747 Max and the cars on the road being exploitable over their cellular connections through the infotainment system to disable the brakes and cut the engine, if it can't fix the senator's private emails being leaked, or the shareholders being hit by a company taken out for a week by ransomware, it can expect governments to implement laws regulating software development, and those laws will be overreaching, uninformed, out of touch, hard work, no-fun, and mandatory.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by twh270 on Monday February 06, 2023 @11:48AM (#34680164)
Very reactionary take here. Blaming developers for everything that's wrong is just as bad-wrong as blaming everything on management, the C-suite, capitalism, or anything else.

I've worked with some very ignorant, lazy, incompetent, individuals. Some had 'programmer' or 'developer' in their title, others were managers or product owners or QA, etc. etc.

I do agree with your last point. I expect the real-world consequences of Bad Software to become more serious and common, and that will result in more regulation of the industry.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by scottLobster on Monday February 06, 2023 @12:26PM (#34680790)
I think he's focusing on the word "dabble", and how unprofessional it sounds. I'd be inclined to agree. I'm a developer and would never say I "dabble" in code. It just sounds light, playful and uncommitted. If your goal at work is to "dabble" in code because you're "passionate" about it, you have an unprofessional mindset. You're putting your passion above the mission. Maybe reading too much into a couple of words, particularly since this is the internet, but in general I'd recommend avoiding words like "passion" and "dabble" in professional contexts.
Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by digitalsushi on Monday February 06, 2023 @01:32PM (#34681897)
As the commenter above who used those words, I stand by them: my influence over code these days is, indeed, light, playful, and uncommitted. I'm the art teacher who draws a single line on the canvas of the student whom is stuck, and then walk away. That's my role, to exist on my team and help them navigate this red tape by dabbling with their code. If this costs me the Next Big Thing, so be it.

This modern mindset, that we're always interviewing for the next job, even between HN comments, is exhausting and just funnels us further into exhaustion.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by jodrellblank on Monday February 06, 2023 @01:07PM (#34681510)
There is nobody else who could have written good code, except developers. There is nobody else who kept rewriting X-Screensaver clones insecurely for 17 years[1] except developers. Nobody else who has knowledge or experience to standardise on tools for the greater good. There is nobody else who wrote Jira but developers. There is nobody else who only wants to do Electron, or who refuses things like UAC because security is fine on their OpenBSD ThinkPad.

Reddit blames capitalism, HN blames managmenent, 4chan blames 'Pajeet' Indian stereotype, Slashdot blames Microsoft, very few developers take a look in the mirror and say things like "we need less powerful languages"[2] or "ignore the firehose of new technologies"[3] or "If I want to ship my software, as opposed to just write it, I need to use tech that's a couple of clicks back from "bleeding edge," and spend a lot of time, "polishing the fenders. B O R I N G [but I do it]"[4].

Civil engineers have legal duties and responsibilities to make sure the things they build are fit for purpose and sign off on them before they get deployed, and can be personally fined or imprisoned or lose licenses if they weren't fit for purpose.

Want to make a text editor at home? Knock yourself out, pick any language you want, dabble all you like. Want to make something that handles millions of people's data, sign your name to it and put your professional reputation on the line before every release. And it may well make salaries go up for the people willing and able to do that. The world runs on a lot more code than buildings these days and professional developers with bleeding edge MacBooks Pro and six figure salaries complaining that all the software we all suffer under is shitty, is like civil engineers complaining that buildings fall down and it's all management's fault for demanding blueprints before construction and inspections during construction to try and stop the company buildings falling down so often, ugh all that red tape, can't we still use wattle and daub it works fine on my garden shed.

[1] https://www.jwz.org/blog/2021/01/i-told-you-so-2021-edition/

[2] https://lukeplant.me.uk/blog/posts/less-powerful-languages/

[3] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/01/06/fire-and-motion/

[4] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by jimbokun on Monday February 06, 2023 @12:01PM (#34680370)
It's the red tape blocking developers from actually working on fixing the problems you describe.
Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by boring_twenties on Monday February 06, 2023 @01:55PM (#34682256)
Yet curiously, there doesn't seem to be any red tape blocking them (us) from pushing out broken changes that no one wanted in the first place?

This seems to be an increasingly common theme these days. Some harebrained thing is released seemingly with no review or testing whatsoever, just because some dev (or worse, a "UI/UX expert") decided they wanted to. It breaks some existing use case and suddenly we need a 2, 5 even 10 year discussion about how difficult it would be to fix -- nevermind if no one wants or uses the new thing even after all that time.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by MrTortoise on Monday February 06, 2023 @05:01PM (#34685081)
exactly because delivery experts put in PR processes and QA processes in different teams to do this

complete abdication of responsibility

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by renonce on Monday February 06, 2023 @01:09PM (#34681526)
> when my laptop takes 10 minutes to start moving the mouse cursor smoothly after waking from a weekend suspend

Apologies for not reading your comment fully, but in this specific instance it's because a weekend suspend causes hibernation, which means all your RAM is saved to the disk. The file can be pretty large (same as your RAM, say 32GB) but reading it fully takes much longer (at 200MB/s it's three minutes). In order to wake up your computer quicker (a few seconds), instead of reading it fully to RAM, the memory is read on demand, i.e. when a process needs it. This comes at the cost of keeping your computer lagging for the next few minutes. This is just one of many many small engineering quirks that makes up an operating system. However considerate the developers work, tradeoffs have to be made here or there. You can't power off the computer and expect to restore its state fully within 5 seconds.

> the professional "dabblers" who don't understand computers, don't understand firewalls, don't understand databases, don't understand algorithms, don't understand garbage collectors, don't understand or care about any kind of security or legal compliance regulations

A single code base consists of many parts independently written by developers of all fields. There are CPU people, networking people, disk people, kernel people, compiler people, cryptography people, etc. And there are things that are simply not possible even if they work their best. There are developers that focus on making the operating system as safe and stable as possible, but they build aircrafts, cars, rockets and household applicances, which (from a software development perspective) are far less powerful than regular computers.

That said, the community of developers is indeed very bloated and there is no need for so many of them. We just haven't found a way to distribute money to that small set of necessary developers without compensating everyone else and bloating the company to keep talents away from competitors.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by trumbitta2 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:17AM (#34690904)
Takes 2 seconds on my Mac, just like on any regular Tuesday.
Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by gamblor956 on Monday February 06, 2023 @01:12PM (#34681580)
This.

For most of the past decade, the true cost of "developer productivity" was borne by the users of their software in wasted time, wasted electricity, and money thrown after buggy or nonfunctional features.

At this point in the aviation industry's lifecycle, we had gone from learning that flying was possible to landing on the moon. If software had followed the same trajectory, we'd have AI servants right now. But programmers insist on re-creating the wheel every few years, so instead we just get new frameworks and languages that do what the existing frameworks and languages do, and a whole lot of new bugs as programmers race to adopt the hot new thing.

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by MrTortoise on Monday February 06, 2023 @05:00PM (#34685071)
most of what developers have to ship is not in their control - very often teams are not responsible for defining what they do or how they do it now.

I wish you were right because it can be fixed by looking at developers but its the entire snake oil industry of deciding what to do that is the problem

Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by trumbitta2 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:17AM (#34690911)
I'm quite positive ChatGPT wrote this to troll us.
Re:Ask HN: I’m falling out of love with coding by jodrellblank on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:57AM (#34709855)
r/confidentlyincorrect