Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by loceng on Sunday January 15, 2012 @01:23PM
(#3467787)
Have you made a final decision on no-nested comments/replying? There are some comments related to adding nesting as a feature, as you can even see with your own comment reply here- it's useful and pretty much a necessity these days to make sense of conversation.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by asomiv on Sunday January 15, 2012 @02:02PM
(#3467900)
No it's not a final decision, but I'm not going to write support for it so feel free to contribute. That said I did add a 'Reply to comment' button a few minutes ago by popular demand.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by iusable on Sunday January 15, 2012 @01:30PM
(#3467808)
I agree with loceng. Nested comments are really valuable with any sort of active conversation. If you are only thinking of 2 people in a conversation as your test case, then it's fine as it is.
Btw, really good work with Juvia so far. Been going through your github source and might even play with it next weekend.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by alexknowshtml on Sunday January 15, 2012 @03:19PM
(#3468111)
Did you successfully use this for per-section commenting somewhere? Can that be viewed? I've been looking for a good way to do this for a long time.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by asomiv on Sunday January 15, 2012 @03:35PM
(#3468152)
Yes. Still working on it though: https://github.com/FooBarWidget/mizuho
It's not finished yet. The Juvia site key and URL are currently hardcoded in the source.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by kemayo on Sunday January 15, 2012 @04:23PM
(#3468296)
I do seem to recall there being some way to override the thread identifier for Disqus, though I'll admit that I never bothered to try it.
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by asomiv on Sunday January 15, 2012 @04:26PM
(#3468306)
The thread identifier is not the problem. I'm only displaying one comment topic at a time by using a lightbox. However once I have loaded a Disqus comment topic, switching to another one seems to fail randomly even if I call their documented DISQUS.reset API.
Perhaps you could give each section/paragraph it's own URL and link the 'per-page/resource' comments to that?
Re:Juvia: Free software Disqus comment server
by asomiv on Sunday January 15, 2012 @04:27PM
(#3468311)
The sections are really short. Giving each section its own URL will make the reading experience horrible. Most of my users told me that they actually prefer a one-page manual because it makes searching easier.
IntenseDebate was the almost exactly same. I gave up after two days.
I finished the most important parts of Juvia today. I got Juvia commenting in the manual working in about 15 minutes.