Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by ergonaught on Sunday February 05, 2023 @09:39AM
(#34665235)
It is in fact that simple. There are dozens, hundreds, perhaps thousands of legitimate, genuine, serious, real reasons to be concerned and "want something to be done". This isn't it.
"Learning is unfair" is not an argument you want to win.
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by wiseowise on Sunday February 05, 2023 @09:41AM
(#34665251)
Love how you’ve conveniently ignored
> The scale and totality of the scraping is out of reach for a human.
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by thrill on Sunday February 05, 2023 @10:34AM
(#34665680)
Because it's conveniently irrelevant.
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by wiseowise on Monday February 06, 2023 @02:14AM
(#34674301)
Why?
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by nohuck13 on Sunday February 05, 2023 @09:46AM
(#34665296)
> It is in fact that simple.
Why?
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by rom-antics on Sunday February 05, 2023 @09:47AM
(#34665306)
If I woke up tomorrow and breathed all the oxygen, nobody else could breathe. But If I woke up tomorrow and read all the websites on the internet, it wouldn't stop other people from reading them too.
Air is zero-sum. Knowledge is not.
Re:Isn't ChatGPT unfair to the sources it scraped data from?
by anonymouskimmer on Sunday February 05, 2023 @12:15PM
(#34666604)
> But If I woke up tomorrow and read all the websites on the internet, it wouldn't stop other people from reading them too.
If you became the first line, go-to source for the information of those websites, those websites would stop getting click-throughs. Eventually it would become less and less worthwhile (economically or emotionally) for the people keeping those sites running to keep them running. It would become more and more difficult for people to find those sites even if they are running, or even the archives of those sites.
So yes, eventually you'd stop people from reading them too.
If you previously interacted with people on this issue, you must know that.
It is fair for a single human to breathe, but not for a machine to use all oxygen on this planet at once, killing everyone else in the process.