News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges by ErrantX on Saturday January 14, 2012 @06:29PM (#3465688)
This sounds like a clever point, but really isn't. Extradition requires that the crime is also a crime under the local laws.

The argument is being made (quite rightly I think) is that what he did was not illegal under British law.

So perhaps it is a good comparison :)

Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges by jcampbell1 on Saturday January 14, 2012 @06:42PM (#3465727)
If he committed no crime under British laws, I guarantee he would not have been eligible for extradition. The article is so thin on substance that it is hard to formulate an intelligent opinion on the matter.

Edit:

I just skimmed the PDF, and the kid argued that he shouldn't be extradited for three reasons: 1) Not illegal in both countries 2) US copyright punishment is "unjust or oppressive" 3) An extradition would be "disproportionate" relative to the crime.

I agree with points #2 and #3, but not #1. I think #3 is the strongest argument. Copyright infringement is not a severe enough impediment to other's natural freedoms to merit sending a citizen to a foreign country to face charges.

Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges by ErrantX on Saturday January 14, 2012 @07:50PM (#3465890)
Absolutely. In this case I think it is possible to argue (rather than it being cut and dried) about the legality in the UK - at least to a reasonable degree.

If the judge decides it is then, fine, that's what he rules :)

I agree; #3 is the most compelling. If anything it's the same reason the CPS declined a UK prosecution (because to do so would be disproportionate).

Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges by jcampbell1 on Saturday January 14, 2012 @10:36PM (#3466255)
This whole thing is nuts. A case where there are proportionally as many UK victims as US victims, but the UK declines to prosecute should not be eligible for extradition. It does't pass a stink test, nor a "disproportionate" test.
Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges by arethuza on Sunday January 15, 2012 @05:55AM (#3466896)
"Extradition requires that the crime is also a crime under the local laws."

We should perhaps also require that the likely punishment be comparable.