News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by AnimalMuppet on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:04AM (#34651710)
Great music does at least one of two things - it sounds amazing, and/or it really says something that resonates with the people in a particular time. "Well, you had to be there" says that it fits into the second category, but not the first.

Another example is "The times they are a-changing". The lyrics were amazing and really resonated with a huge segment of the young. But if you just listen to it as music, you realize that Dylan can't sing, and it's not a very good composition.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by zeroonetwothree on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:24AM (#34652102)
I relistened to it just now and I actually really like his singing style on this song. I think the bare and minimalist style fits so well with the meaning of the lyrics that it adds a whole layer of complexity.

Of course a lot of people prefer the Byrds cover, which is great in its own way.