News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:43PM (#34651606)
I never got the hype about the Beatles. So many people have told me, "well, you had to be there". Ok. So? What does that have to do with my listening choices now? I want to hear an enjoyable song, not "I wanna hold your hand" repeated 15 million times (and that's just one listening!)

EDIT: this is hilarious, and not unexpected. As soon as you say something against the Beatles, all the self-described "experts" come out to tell you "you're entitled to your opinion, but your opinion is wrong".

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by relyks on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:42AM (#34651881)
I don't think your opinion is wrong, but if you like rock music and you have a favorite band/artist, they were likely influenced by another band/artist that listened to or studied the Beatles or they have the Beatles as part of their ancestry tree of influences. There have been a lot of great artists/bands that weren't very popular (at least initially) but ended up having a major influence on music over time (e.g. the Velvet Underground). The Beatles have been one of the biggest influencers on music.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:02AM (#34651971)
What does that have to do with listening to goofy, Jim Henson-esque stuff like "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" and "Octopuses Garden" and having people try to gaslight you into believing there aren't a dozen better ways to spend your time?
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by ahoho on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:33AM (#34652155)
It seems odd to pick on one of universally reviled Beatle's songs to make your point. I don't even think the two dozen fans of Maxwell's Silver Hammer would argue it's high art
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by zeroonetwothree on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:22AM (#34652091)
No musician has ever produced 100% masterpieces. I can cherry pick bad songs from any artist you care to choose. Also FWIW some people actually like those two you mention.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by relyks on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:10AM (#34652014)
Lol, it doesn't. The Beatles are one of my favorite bands and I really dislike some of their songs too. I was just trying to say that a big portion of their hype is because of their influence. You don't have to like them, but they deserve respect
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by JohnBooty on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:16AM (#34651769)
If you don't like them that's okay.

A fairly huge percentage of the people who really rock music and/or make rock music think the Beatles were great.

I guess I can identify with people who feel like they've had them shoved down their throat. I feel that way about a lot of Dylan and the Stones and a few other darlings.

Funny, though. I've never heard "you had to be there" about these acts. I certainly love the Beatles and was not there.

I do think that your experience with the Beatles, as with nearly all art, will be greatly enhanced by some contextual awareness on your behalf. If that's not your cup of tea that's completely OK though. There is no reason you need to like or care about any particular art. I'm sure you have other things in life that you enjoy.

I might think it's a bit of a shame, but I also think it's a shame that I don't like cauliflower.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:57AM (#34651948)
It's not a shame to hate cauliflower.

I also hate cauliflower. What is a shame is how others will try to sneak cauliflower into your meals, despite your assertions that you have already explored the full breadth of cauliflower and still find nothing there for your liking.

"Oh, but you've never had it as a pizza crust!"

I assure you, I have. I still hated it. Stop trying to assume you know more about my lived experience than me.

So it is with The Beatles. I have listened to it. I do understand the cultural context. I still don't like it. So kindly please get off my front porch.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by JohnBooty on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:40AM (#34652199)
What a terrible analogy. For it to be apt we'd need to be sneaking snippets of Beatles songs into things you're already listening to, and even then that's not as egregious as tricking you into putting things into your body.

It certainly says something about your experiences, though. People must have been attempting to cram the Beatles into your life in some extremely obnoxious ways if you feel like this.

I'm sorry you dealt with that.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by petodo on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:16AM (#34652048)
> I might think it's a bit of a shame, but I also think it's a shame that I don't like cauliflower.

Have you tried it breaded (broken to smaller pieces) and deep fried, then after cutting, sprinkle salt on each piece? It's pretty good and popular here in Czechia, only other way I ate cauliflower I think it's boiled in vegetable soup.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by yCombLinks on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:54PM (#34651666)
I've never had anyone tell me that. I love the Beatles, and I certainly wasn't there. Nor did I grow up listening to them. That being said their early stuff, like "I want to hold your hand" is pretty basic 60's pop. Everything from Rubber Soul on is the work of well refined musical masters. My favorite is Revolver.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:03AM (#34651979)
Lucky you, then. It has happened at least three times in this thread alone.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by rgmerk on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:05AM (#34652656)
To appreciate the early stuff (and I agree there’s a lot of filler on the early albums) it’s interesting to listen to what else was around at the time. Any vitality of the early rock and roll artists was long gone and the charts were filled with schmaltz like Bobby Vee. In that context, “Please Please Me” would have sounded something like “Smells Like Teen Spirit” did in 1991 when it arrived in a world of hair metal.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by bitcurious on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:05AM (#34651716)
The Beatles are like Tolkien. They had to happen for us to land where we did. Without Tolkien we don't get modern fantasy. Without the Beatles we don't get metal, punk, glam rock, etc. I think rap is probably the only modern genre that doesn't trace its lineage to the Beatles.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by JohnBooty on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:21AM (#34651791)
Yeah. I don't think that anybody needs to like a particular piece of art, but nearly all art is enhanced by some contextual awareness on the audience's behalf.

When I see people dunking on the Beatles or Tolkien, I think wow, there is a person who's really dedicated to not giving a crap about those forms of art.

Which is... fine, but what a loss.

You can stroll around a museum and treat strictly as a picture gallery, devoid of all context, or you can really get into things on a whole other level. So many famous works really come to life that way.

Either choice is okay.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by monkpit on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:40AM (#34651878)
> wow, there is a person who's really dedicated to not giving a crap about those forms of art

“You’re entitled to your opinion, but if you don’t agree with me you must not be capable of enjoying music”

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by JohnBooty on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:28AM (#34652124)
I'm specifically referring to people dunking on the Beatles, not the much much larger group of people who just don't like them or don't care.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:50AM (#34651918)
I don't care for your assertion of only two sides: "Beatles fans" and "those who don't put effort into understanding art."

In point of fact, all I really said was that "I don't get it". I specifically stayed completely away from making any kind of direct, critical judgement of the Beatles themselves.

Maybe you might be able to see how one might see such replies as overly-defensive.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by JohnBooty on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:30AM (#34652144)

    I don't care for your assertion of only two sides: 
    "Beatles fans" and "those who don't put effort into 
    understanding art."
Well, that's an obnoxious assertion and I don't like it either so I suppose we agree on something.

However, that's not the assertion I made. Not even close.

I specifically said "those forms of art", not "art" in totality. I'm sure there's a lot of art you enjoy.

I also referred specifically to those who feel the need to dunk on the Beatles, not merely people who don't care for them. It's absolutely incomprehensible to me when people go out of their way to click on an article about artist XYZ simply so they can tell the world how they don't understand or don't like that artist. What an odd impulse.

Anything about the Beatles seems to draw out this sort of person.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by adastra22 on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:25AM (#34652434)
Is their music good (enjoyable) and Is their music influential are two totally different and unrelated questions. It is entirely possible that their music was downright terrible and unenjoyable, yet nevertheless influential for unrelated reasons. This is my opinion too, fwiw.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by mixmastamyk on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:55PM (#34651675)
It's just consistently good stuff, that's all. To a degree no one else reached. You don't have to like it, but shouldn't be determined not to either. Forget the hype, it's over.

Also, the first album is basically enthusiastic teens manipulated by a record company. So try the more mature albums, starting at Rubber Soul as others said.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by AnimalMuppet on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:04AM (#34651710)
Great music does at least one of two things - it sounds amazing, and/or it really says something that resonates with the people in a particular time. "Well, you had to be there" says that it fits into the second category, but not the first.

Another example is "The times they are a-changing". The lyrics were amazing and really resonated with a huge segment of the young. But if you just listen to it as music, you realize that Dylan can't sing, and it's not a very good composition.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by zeroonetwothree on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:24AM (#34652102)
I relistened to it just now and I actually really like his singing style on this song. I think the bare and minimalist style fits so well with the meaning of the lyrics that it adds a whole layer of complexity.

Of course a lot of people prefer the Byrds cover, which is great in its own way.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by petodo on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:12AM (#34652030)
As for you had to be there argument, that wouldn't explain why I consider Rolling stones or Beach boys from same era better than overhyped Beatles. And honestly I was not really there even during Queen and Abba fame and find these two vastly superior to Beatles, which is almost unlistenable for me besides few great songs like Imagine (which I guess ain't even Beatles), Yesterday, So this is Christmas (is it Beatles?) or All you need is love.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by moron4hire on Saturday February 04, 2023 @08:46AM (#34654443)
I think a lot of people forget that pop-music is a business. Pop bands are essentially corporations in competition with each other.

I think the true legacy of The Beatles is that they were the first band to understand that about themselves.

But to then assign unique artistic genius to that output--that's completely ignoring that competition existed at all. Like how some fanboys seem to think Apple invented the smartphone.

Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by petodo on Saturday February 04, 2023 @09:04AM (#34654559)
Yeah as someone using Symbian years before iphone I always find it funny they kept calling it first smartphone. Heck even in my previous dumb Java phones I was already many years before running email client, IM, games, browser, calendar and was doing almost everything I'm doing with smartphone, just the experience was not that pleasant, I was fan of Siemens phones which allowed root access to file system unlike other locked brands where you could not even share your resources with others.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews? by bsder on Sunday February 05, 2023 @12:03AM (#34662088)
> I want to hear an enjoyable song, not "I wanna hold your hand" repeated 15 million times (and that's just one listening!)

Well, at one point Dylan told Lennon that his lyrics were shit ... so you're not wrong ...

People forget that the Beatles rode a technology wave, as well. TV uptake meant that the they were in the right place and right time to be a cute Boy Band. Audio recording technology underwent a vast shift and improvement in less than 10 years. The Beatles also happened to actually have talent and be very good musicians. And managed to have a band that didn't implode until after they generated a solid catalog.

Maybe they weren't first at everything they did, but they were close enough to first and had a reach due to their Boy Band years that nobody else could possibly match. So, The Beatles doing something novel was invariably how anybody not directly in the "scene" would find out about it.

People also forget that The Hollies were arguably more popular than The Beatles back in the UK. However, America was the music market at that point.