Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by hussong on Saturday January 14, 2012 @08:21AM
(#3464175)
Someone should make a short film about this scene, it would go pretty viral.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by realo on Saturday January 14, 2012 @08:28AM
(#3464185)
That would be cool, as long as the 10,000$ license fee for "Happy Birthday" is paid to Warner...
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by draggnar on Saturday January 14, 2012 @10:03AM
(#3464347)
What?! I was reading these comments thinking -- oh that would be funny if everything was under copywrite. I feel violated. The video, if you make it, should end with the fact that it actually is owned by Warner.
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by fossuser on Saturday January 14, 2012 @11:46AM
(#3464550)
The perhaps even stranger part is that there exists a public domain variant of the happy birthday song. The song was modified and it is this version that Warner owns the copyright to (and the one that we sing).
The modification? -- One Note.
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by droithomme on Saturday January 14, 2012 @01:15PM
(#3464819)
Yes, given that the song was written in 1893 and has been published with the current melody and lyrics since 1912 it's amazing to think it is still really under copyright, especially given that there is not a single other thing in the world from 1893 or 1912 whose copyright hasn't long since expired.
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by draggnar on Saturday January 14, 2012 @05:49PM
(#3465560)
the really amazing thing is that nobody has invented a new happy birthday song. did we reach perfection and that's it? no creativity for birthday melodies? orwellian or utopian? i can't tell anymore. "It's not utopian to want to build better stuff. It might be utopian to claim the stuff we've got is the best we're capable of."
Re:US Authorities Silence NinjaVideo Founder, Rush Her to Pr...
by droithomme on Saturday January 14, 2012 @09:08PM
(#3466055)
Thanks, you bring up an excellent ancillary point in the discussion. The momentum of tradition is quite powerful. As a point of comparison, I use a Dvorak keyboard layout which allows me to touch type faster and has reduced my carpal tunnel syndrome effects considerably. I personally know several others that use Dvorak. However, I also realize that most of the world will not be switching from QWERTY because that is just how it is.