Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by Dig1t on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:29PM
(#34634840)
By many objective measures we are doing well, we are living longer than ever, women and minorities have more opportunities than ever, the standard of living is higher than ever in history. Even poor people live better (and longer) than kings used to not that many generations ago.
There are many measures by which we can judge our positive success. Of course there a ton of problems, but it still seems that we only like talking about problems and not any of the positives.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by voakbasda on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:40PM
(#34634948)
I would happily trade many of the increases in standard of living to regain our freedom. It's not enough to have a good standard of living, if you must live in constant oppressive fear of the abject tyranny imposed upon us. And make no mistake, that's where we are in this country. It might be subjectively considered better than most others, but that's just a way of saying our shit stinks less.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by Dig1t on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:01PM
(#34635167)
Personally, I agree with you about freedoms. I value personal freedoms very highly and would be happy to trade comfort and safety for more of them. Obviously the majority of people, especially on this site, are not going to share that same value. Most people just value a comfy life and don't mind trading their (and others) individual freedoms for it.
>that's where we are in this country
Unfortunately it seems to be where everyone ends up in all developed societies. The US is an aberration because it is so young.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by anm89 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:51PM
(#34635061)
This Steven Pinker stuff is absolute hogwash. There are more people living in extreme poverty today than existed 250 years ago. So what that as a percentage and when you are very careful with the definitions that they are a smaller proportion.
And what, I can get an extra 5 years in a nursing home where there's a decent chance I'll suffer physical and psychological abuse but will be forcefully kept alive in a stupor on a cocktail of drugs.
It's just unabashed justification for the interests of the top couple percent. They do in fact have it better right now by far than any other cohort in history.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by mech765 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:53PM
(#34635080)
Would you figure that if the population increases by 10x that the number of people living in extreme poverty increases by 10x? That's what I would assume if the world was not getting any better or worse.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by anm89 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:13PM
(#34635283)
No I would assume that at the margin, increases in population are drastically skewed towards more poverty.
So if we we went from 8B to 80B I'd argue we'd go from 1B -> >50B in poverty. Maybe a lot worse than that.
This is obviously dependent on where you are born but especially true once you consider that the places left with high fertility have nearly perfect overlap with the places with high volumes of extreme poverty.
And this is only in the short term. Those people are generating plastic waste, consuming fuel, and many other things that are net negatives to the planet over time. So over the long term this problem just gets worse.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by s1artibartfast on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:25PM
(#34635406)
but isnt that the exact point.
you might expect poverty to go up by a factor of 50x when the population goes up by 10x, but what we see is the opposite, poverty has grown more slowly than the overall population.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by mort96 on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:04AM
(#34638509)
Inequality is record high and growing, there's an ongoing political attack on LGBT people's (and especially trans people's) right to even exist, one of the US's two parties is straight-up fascist and has already attempted a coup, and not very much is being done about the growing climate disaster.
On many objective measures, we are doing well. On many others, things are getting dramatically worse, fast.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by bediger4000 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:36PM
(#34634913)
So half of one party is enough? Wonderful that the press gives that one party so much power to decide about the country's direction. I wonder if the press gives that party a lot more attention and importance, and why that's so?
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by taeric on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:29PM
(#34635448)
I think it is more that a large part of one party is being told things have never been worse by a very loud megaphone. That they believe it is not that surprising, all told.
If there were objective measures that folks were basing any of this on, it would be one thing. But the news isn't that 71% of Americans believe things are bad. The story is a bit more that "the two parties in America are increasingly polarized on their view of how the country is doing."
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by jfengel on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:18AM
(#34643155)
If one party has decided to answer "wrong track" simply because they're not in power, then it's not going to be a very informative question one way or the other.
It's useful to know that they're unhappy. But the metric is not the target; the goal is not to get them to say "right track". The goal is to figure out how to find a political system in which we can all work together.
I believe that those answering "wrong track" automatically have not done a good job of finding ways to work together. But that hasn't really changed in a long time, so the poll doesn't really mean much, either.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by hunglee2 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:25PM
(#34634810)
do these commentators know what the right track is? The reason why everyone feels that it's all going wrong is because the informational environment has descended into partisan alarmism, which each 'side' simply triggering its base in order to get clicks and views. US more or less invented the idea of physical fitness, it now needs to do the same with mental fitness, starting with the inputs
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by chatterhead on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:34PM
(#34634887)
Was that before or after their children started eating Tide Pods and pretending to be foxes? We deserve everything we're going to get and I'd highly recommend you get out of any major city in the next week.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by tootie on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:43PM
(#34634981)
Exhibit A. People who think these are real problems destroying the country and all the other people who think people who believe these things are destroying the country.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by tootie on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:22PM
(#34636372)
It's not ideological. It's empirical. People who can't accept reality. The ones who tried to overthrow democracy. And the millions of voters who declined to punish them. Strong overlap with people who fear vaccines, clean energy and drag queens. The ones who think the entire universe is a giant conspiracy. The ones who make threats and carry out attacks.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by chatterhead on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:10PM
(#34636676)
You mean like the Weather Underground and Susan Rosenberg who helps manage BLMs funding? Perhaps you should step outside your confirmation bias bubble and live in the real world. Your sheltered life is showing.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by tootie on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:07AM
(#34640526)
That's a pretty obscure reference. The people behind the Jan 6 violence were working directly with Congress, the president, Roger Stone and conservative media. And even after the fact sitting Republicans refused to condemn the attack. The same people who refused to hold that president accountable for gross misdeeds in office.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by dang on Sunday February 05, 2023 @04:59PM
(#34670001)
Please stop using HN for political flamewar. You did it repeatedly in this thread; that's not cool.
We've asked you more than once before, and eventually we have to ban accounts that do this. Regardless of how right you are or feel you are, it's not what this site is for and destroys what it is for.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by kashunstva on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:04PM
(#34635191)
> politics aside ... with bad ideas
Isn't _bad_ in this case a political judgement; so how are we to put politics aside in assessing this claim?
> ...entering dementia
I have no opinion about the U.S. president, favourable or unfavourable, but are there objective data in the public domain indicating a diagnosis of dementia in his case, e.g. neurocognitive test results? Even a Folstein mini-mental status test? The diagnosis of dementia and age-related cognitive decline is thrown around casually but requires more rigorous evaluation that "seems 'off'."
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by spdustin on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:04PM
(#34635194)
I’d be more interested in the percentage of Americans, broken down by party affiliation and other demographics, that can elucidate even a modestly tenable solution to get the country on the “right track.” So much sturm und drang invades even the simplest of our human relationships…especially between two people of differing parties who might, in isolation from their base emotions, otherwise get along famously.
I wish I had even the faintest whisper of a solution. So many people can’t even talk to each other about anything sincere before devolving into derisible rhetoric.
Re:Poll finds 71% of Americans believe country is on wrong t...
by torstenvl on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:24PM
(#34635399)
Deradicalization.
There's an ever-increasing trend in all corners of society to upset the status quo in radical and sudden ways, leaving people panicked and reeling.
The Supreme Court did it to the left with Dodd and not even staying their abortion ruling long enough for an election cycle to achieve what they claimed their aim was.
The Biden Admin did it to the right with the ATF reversing course on pistol braces after years of saying they were fine, making millions of Americans felons overnight (oh but we won't enforce it for 120 days, so it's cool...)
There are enough situations where "the right thing" is genuinely open to debate. It's completely unnecessary, the frequency with which people do what they know is wrong to other people, and just shrugging it off with "Oh well, sue me" or "Oh well, pass a referendum" or "Oh well, you should have seen this coming." It's like there's a total lack of empathy.
So how do we fix it? I think we start with harsh, dogged, across-the-board corruption prosecutions. This is my "broken windows" theory of public policy-making. People see the likes of Nancy Pelosi or Donald Trump engaging in indisputably corrupt behavior and getting away with it, so why not push what they can get away with, too?
There are many measures by which we can judge our positive success. Of course there a ton of problems, but it still seems that we only like talking about problems and not any of the positives.
>that's where we are in this country
Unfortunately it seems to be where everyone ends up in all developed societies. The US is an aberration because it is so young.
I thought that had recently reversed.
And what, I can get an extra 5 years in a nursing home where there's a decent chance I'll suffer physical and psychological abuse but will be forcefully kept alive in a stupor on a cocktail of drugs.
It's just unabashed justification for the interests of the top couple percent. They do in fact have it better right now by far than any other cohort in history.
So if we we went from 8B to 80B I'd argue we'd go from 1B -> >50B in poverty. Maybe a lot worse than that.
This is obviously dependent on where you are born but especially true once you consider that the places left with high fertility have nearly perfect overlap with the places with high volumes of extreme poverty.
And this is only in the short term. Those people are generating plastic waste, consuming fuel, and many other things that are net negatives to the planet over time. So over the long term this problem just gets worse.
you might expect poverty to go up by a factor of 50x when the population goes up by 10x, but what we see is the opposite, poverty has grown more slowly than the overall population.
On many objective measures, we are doing well. On many others, things are getting dramatically worse, fast.
Half of one party thinks we’re doing “good”. All of the other party says we’re not.
My point was just that it wasn’t like 80% of one party and 60% of the other. It was WAY more lopsided.
If there were objective measures that folks were basing any of this on, it would be one thing. But the news isn't that 71% of Americans believe things are bad. The story is a bit more that "the two parties in America are increasingly polarized on their view of how the country is doing."
It's useful to know that they're unhappy. But the metric is not the target; the goal is not to get them to say "right track". The goal is to figure out how to find a political system in which we can all work together.
I believe that those answering "wrong track" automatically have not done a good job of finding ways to work together. But that hasn't really changed in a long time, so the poll doesn't really mean much, either.
It's going to be a long winter.
If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
We've asked you more than once before, and eventually we have to ban accounts that do this. Regardless of how right you are or feel you are, it's not what this site is for and destroys what it is for.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Isn't _bad_ in this case a political judgement; so how are we to put politics aside in assessing this claim?
> ...entering dementia
I have no opinion about the U.S. president, favourable or unfavourable, but are there objective data in the public domain indicating a diagnosis of dementia in his case, e.g. neurocognitive test results? Even a Folstein mini-mental status test? The diagnosis of dementia and age-related cognitive decline is thrown around casually but requires more rigorous evaluation that "seems 'off'."
There's an ever-increasing trend in all corners of society to upset the status quo in radical and sudden ways, leaving people panicked and reeling.
The Supreme Court did it to the left with Dodd and not even staying their abortion ruling long enough for an election cycle to achieve what they claimed their aim was.
The Biden Admin did it to the right with the ATF reversing course on pistol braces after years of saying they were fine, making millions of Americans felons overnight (oh but we won't enforce it for 120 days, so it's cool...)
There are enough situations where "the right thing" is genuinely open to debate. It's completely unnecessary, the frequency with which people do what they know is wrong to other people, and just shrugging it off with "Oh well, sue me" or "Oh well, pass a referendum" or "Oh well, you should have seen this coming." It's like there's a total lack of empathy.
So how do we fix it? I think we start with harsh, dogged, across-the-board corruption prosecutions. This is my "broken windows" theory of public policy-making. People see the likes of Nancy Pelosi or Donald Trump engaging in indisputably corrupt behavior and getting away with it, so why not push what they can get away with, too?