News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What everyone in the SOPA debate is missing: IP is not a ... by icebraining on Friday January 13, 2012 @09:59PM (#3463345)
(But I wonder, if you come up with an invention but don't tell anybody, isn't that a natural property right? I mean, to say that you don't' have a right to it, would be to say that others have the right to forcibly take it from you, wouldn't it?)

Irrelevant. If you haven't told anybody, they have to violate your rights to your property (stealing the plans of the invention) or to your liberty (coercing you in some way to tell them your plans) to obtain your invention.

The whole point of copyright and patents¹ is not to protect your right to the invention, but to give you the right to prevent others from using their legally obtained copies of your invention as they see fit.

¹ I don't like the term IP; see https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.html

Re:What everyone in the SOPA debate is missing: IP is not a ... by kbutler on Saturday January 14, 2012 @12:11AM (#3463523)
Yes. In the absence of copyright/patent/trademark, everyone can use every bit of knowledge they come across.

The "natural right" is the right to use information. Copyrights, patents, and trademark are constitutional limitations of this natural right, hoping to encourage more creation and sharing of knowledge to increase the total amount available to all.

Re:What everyone in the SOPA debate is missing: IP is not a ... by Joakal on Saturday January 14, 2012 @12:15AM (#3463533)
What's hypocritical about that is that restricting the Internet will discourage creation and sharing of knowledge.
Re:What everyone in the SOPA debate is missing: IP is not a ... by icebraining on Saturday January 14, 2012 @07:11AM (#3464089)
Trademarks don't really affect that, that's why I don't like the term IP. Trademarks simply say you can't present yourself as others, not that you can't use any kind of information.