Re:We are ‘greening’ ourselves to extinction
by quantified on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @03:37PM
(#34617302)
Thinking only about the humans is pretty selfish and sad. If Asian hornets go extinct, or gonorrhea bacilli, I won't shed many tears. Whales, elephants, apes laugh and love also, let them live.
Re:We are ‘greening’ ourselves to extinction
by kerkeslager on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @04:04PM
(#34617714)
I wouldn't say I'm thinking only about the humans. It's a matter of prioritization, not exclusion.
This is mostly a straw man argument. It's always a mistake to represent diverse groups like "environmentalists" as holding a homogeneous belief. There are certainly some environmentalists who believe what you just said, but as an environmentalist, I don't believe that, and I think the environmentalists who do believe that are the minority of environmentalists.
On the contrary, for me, environmentalism isn't about saving the planet, it's about saving humans. The planet doesn't need saving: if we turn the planet into a barren wasteland it will uncaringly continue hurtling through space without us, but we'll be dead. The environment is a necessary component to human survival and thriving. I don't believe that means we should have no impact on the environment--that's not possible--but that we need to be careful about when we change our impact on the environment, because we risk breaking the fragile ecosystems that have supported our existence.