Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by lusr on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:16AM
(#3460100)
It's difficult to take this article seriously given the terrible grammar and obvious technical errors, often in the same sentence, e.g. "The researchers then combined 96 bits make [sic] one byte of data..."; presumably "bits" should be "atoms". Such errors make me question whether anything in the article is accurate or being interpreted correctly.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by archangel_one on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:28AM
(#3460129)
My understanding was that Moore's law states that the number of transistors that you get for a given cost doubles every 18 months. Hence I don't think any result shown by researchers in a lab can be said to "smash" it until a similar technique is used in production for chips you can actually buy.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by vilda on Friday January 13, 2012 @08:47AM
(#3460486)
Moore's law is one of the most misinterpreted laws :)
It states that the number of transistors per INGOT SLICE will double each 18 months.
Ingot (in semiconductor manufacturing) is a slice of silicon monocrystalline suitable for photolithographic and chemical processing. The main point is that while transistors are getting smaller, ingot slices are getting bigger.
Edit: I mean misquoted (misinterpretation is a result).
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by archangel_one on Friday January 13, 2012 @01:46PM
(#3461785)
Yes, I agree it's often misquoted. I don't see where it says anything about ingot slices in his original statement (see eg. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore%27s_law#History) though; I was thinking of the statement "The complexity for minimum component costs has increased at a rate of roughly a factor of two per year", etc.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by Anderkent on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:36AM
(#3460007)
From what I remember from physics lessons, going with more elementary particles might be possible eventually, but not in any foreseeable future - (most/some) atoms are fairly stable by themselves, while keeping a hadron-based structure stable will probably be very difficult.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by cot6mur3 on Friday January 13, 2012 @11:24AM
(#3461157)
Nice response. As for ultimate limits, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekenstein_bound. Of course, this bound doesn't really give bits per quark/particle limits - just an overall limit based on the spherical radius of the information-storing system.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by michaelcampbell on Friday January 13, 2012 @07:41AM
(#3460289)
This seems an outlier at best; Moore's Law is an approximation, and this falls outside it (as have many). I would say "smashing" the law would be to find some way of manufacturing that would affect the rate of change the 18 months figure to ... 3 months, or something radically different, in perpetuity.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by buff-a on Friday January 13, 2012 @07:58AM
(#3460343)
FTA: The experiment was performed at low temperature: about 1 degree Kelvin, which corresponds to about -272 °C (-458 °F). The byte starts switching randomly about once a minute due to thermal energy (heat) at about 5 degrees Kelvin.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 13, 2012 @09:20AM
(#3460579)
They proved such bits may exist, but have definitely not brought anything to market, nor even demonstrated a process to do so. They used a scanning electron microscope to fiddle atoms around, creating one bit. A science experiment, nothing more.
Re:IBM smashes Moore's Law, cuts bit size to 12 atoms
by AndrewDucker on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:29AM
(#3460133)
Moore's Law says we should be able to fit transistors into a certain amount of space at a certain time. Getting well ahead of the curve would count as breaking Moor's Law, I'd have thought.
It states that the number of transistors per INGOT SLICE will double each 18 months.
Ingot (in semiconductor manufacturing) is a slice of silicon monocrystalline suitable for photolithographic and chemical processing. The main point is that while transistors are getting smaller, ingot slices are getting bigger.
Edit: I mean misquoted (misinterpretation is a result).
That's a bit depressing. Why a single atom, and not some smaller particle?
"low" indeed.