https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0OQxbMvo80
At min 29:30 it's shown test results, and the performance seems better with Noctua NH-D15. Less noise (less rpm) for the same temperature dissipation.
Noctua's performance with low noise is among the main reasons why I own one since several years ago ( And also why I choose air-cooling over water-cooling). It would be interesting to know if someone has beaten them (At same performance, less weight would be something for to take in account).
Any judgment on thermosiphon technology (where noise is largely not a factor) should not be conflated with a judgment on the quality of attached fans. Sold together as a product, though, I suppose it remains relevant.
Remember to compare any noise savings against the total noise. e.g. I have 8 other fans in the box. If memory serves when I built it, tech websites were reporting that the temperature under load with an IceGiant was lower.
If I were building a system I’d just slap one of those in, buy some Noctuas for quieter fan operation and ignore it, and let the CPU turbo to its hearts content.
Edit: link https://www.icegiantcooling.com/