Re:ThinkPad as a Server: The Follow-Up
by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday January 28, 2023 @07:33PM
(#34563578)
NUCs I can see, but are thin clients good value for anything but low-power always-on workloads? I would naively expect them to be cheap but have weak CPUs and insufficient memory for running anything that uses significant compute (either fewer large things, which is painfully common, or many smaller services).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Given the level of compute power in a thin client now a days, are they much different from a NUC?
What my work (financial services) calls a thin client is really just a super small form factor PC.
Re:ThinkPad as a Server: The Follow-Up
by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday January 28, 2023 @07:40PM
(#34563631)
Ah, perhaps I'm out of date then; when I say thin client I'm still thinking of the old Wyse box in my junk box with a Celeron, but that thing is ancient so maybe technology has advanced enough to blur the lines?
Re:ThinkPad as a Server: The Follow-Up
by fragmede on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:11PM
(#34563862)
If your alternative is an unavailable raspberry pi, a Wyse with a Celeron for $30 is comparable.
Re:ThinkPad as a Server: The Follow-Up
by doubled112 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:22PM
(#34563917)
Not only comparable right now, but a great deal in comparison.
There exists a small army of SBCs not named "Raspberry Pi" worth considering over them for many use cases.
The off-brand options usually have serious compatibility issues compared to x86.
This does not match my experience unless you buy them day-and-date of release from a manufacturer who's slow to upstream system definitions. In my house I've got Rock64s, Orange Pi 3 LTSes, and just got an Orange Pi 5 (which stretches the definition of "SBC" in a lot of ways), along with a couple RPi3's and RPi4's. All have excellent Armbian support and, once you have Armbian installed, it's a bog-standard system.
They're also smaller, use less power, and tend to be less noisy. You trade off PCIe for most of them, granted, but more and more stuff is just "and I need a USB host over here" and for that they're excellent.
I wouldn’t go all the way down to “thin-client” like the Wyse stuff. NUCs and SFF/micro PCs are the next step up and usually have i3/i5/i7 CPUs… but depending on your needs, a thin-client isn’t out of the question.