Secondly, another comment gives examples of similar tape that isn't white. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34554613
How is common home repair supplies count as "domain-specific"? You don't have some teflon tape in a storage drawer somewhere in your house? Have you never replaced a faucet aerator or shower head?
As to the other tape, that's apparently for gas connections (I've never of it personally) when the original poster specifically specified plumbing tape.
So, I'd file this under "one persons experience is not necessarily a guarantee of universal experience."
Probably, I'd have to look. But like I said "the last one that I saw was white" is one thing, "it's always white" is another very different thing. Is this a standard that it _has to be white_? I you can't answer that, then you have no case at all that it's not "domain specific knowledge".