The first one is indeed much closer for me. Still doesn't have my current phone number and while the broad strokes are there the dates are wildly inaccurate. Looking at my immediate family though, I actually seem to have the worst hygiene! It's 0/5 in providing an accurate phone number for any of us.

It's cause this info is consolidated from so many different databases, but it's out there. Some of the paid ones are scarily accurate.