But most of us don't want to extend the courtesy to petty criminals.
Given Apple's staggering pile of cash, I think that we'll have decades of warning if they're going to stop existing.
Even though at any point said device can be unlocked, transferred, sold etc.
It is to stop devices being stolen, wiped and re-sold. It is an attempt to allow the legal owner of the device the ability to control who can use it, rather than the possessor of the device having full control who can use it.
Its only purpose is to protect the use of the device by people removing all the software (erasing back to factory defaults) and taking control of the physical device that way.
Assuming you know your Apple ID password, disabling Activation Lock takes less than 30 seconds. You can even do it remotely via Find My on the web.
It hasn't exactly curtailed the legitimate iPhone resale market in the ~seven years that it's been on by default, either, though it did produce a dramatic drop in people getting their phone snatched from their pocket[1].
1. https://techcrunch.com/2015/02/11/apples-activation-lock-lea...
I think that overrides any user set firmware password, so might allow you to recover it,
Just a thought maybe a little searching can validate it before you might try?
I don’t know how many people manually set firmware passwords on their Mac anymore (i.e. don’t have it set as the result of MDM) but I’d guess the number is vanishingly small.
This kind of security should be tied to something like removable storage device where the users data is stored, not the main device itself. That way when the owner dies or loses acess then said owner only loses acess to the data and not the entire device.
IMHO this is Apple trying to force people to purchase new devices and prevent reuse. It doesn't matter what is intended on the surface, but what the actual outcome is. This causes more waste and it's not helpful to the environment. If you are serious about protecting user data tie it to hardware security that can be decoupled from the device itself.
I'm in the business of repairing computers.Apple is setting bad precedence on multiple fronts, More than any other company in existence.