News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by JeffL on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @07:15PM (#3454398)
Sounds a little more lonely when you read "it's likely there are a minimum of 1,500 planets within just 50 light-years of Earth." 1,500 isn't that many, and 50 light-years is a really long distance.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by celoyd on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @07:48PM (#3454520)
We don’t really know how many 1,500 is, because we’re missing a lot of the variables we need to have even an order-of-magnitude estimate of how common intelligent life is. It could be practically inevitable on planets with liquid water; it could be one in a million even given “animal” life. Qualified experts disagree.

And 50 light years is a long distance to travel even at a tremendous speed like 0.01c, but it isn’t that long to send postcards. If we’d sent out a bunch of reasonably good questions in 1912, we would still be interested in the answers today. (More interesting, I think, is what they would ask us.)

In retrospect, I’m assuming we’re taking a finding-intelligent-life perspective here. But if you’re thinking in terms of human expansion – terraforming and so on – then I agree.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by prawn on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @08:40PM (#3454685)
More interesting again is what they could tell us. I think with the time scales involved, chances are that anyone communicating with us would be significantly more advanced.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by ars on Thursday January 12, 2012 @01:36AM (#3455289)
Not really.

Otherwise it works exactly the same the other way: The chance is that we would be significantly more advanced than them.

In actually chances are we have zero data on the matter and can not calculate chances at all.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by dexy on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:20AM (#3455908)
Not quite.

The actual reason is that we have invented radio technology only very recently. Because we are so new to the technology, odds are that our communication partner has had radio for much longer than we have (millions of years probably, given the age of the universe), and thus is far more advanced.

This logical step requires a few assumptions. First is that societies don't destroy themselves soon after the advent of nuclear weapons, which would limit them to a very short window of radio capability (measured in hundreds or thousands of years).

The second assumption is that other forms of intelligence progress their technology at a similar rate to that at which we progress ours.

If the former assumption is wrong, it's extremely unlikely that we will ever talk to any intelligence, even with relatively plentiful life in the universe, because it will kill itself too fast. The latter assumption could still be wrong though, particularly if the method used for interstellar radio communication was in any way evolutionarily derived.

This is my understanding of the topic at least.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by ars on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:59AM (#3456005)
You missed my point - why do you assume they will talk to us before we talk to them?

We have zero data on any kinds of odds for how long anyone else might exist, or if the amount of time we have had radio is considered short or long.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by dexy on Thursday January 12, 2012 @04:32PM (#3458036)
This falls exactly into the scenarios I talked about...

Given how much randomness was involved in our creation as a species, let alone our technological ascendance, it is highly unlikely that other intelligence would develop in exactly the same amount of time elsewhere. It's astronomically unlikely. If they didn't develop at the same time as us, they're either still incapable of radio or have had radio for a long time. A long time in the life of the universe certainly doesn't mean 100 years, it means much longer. Even if it's only 1000 years, if they progress at anything like the rate we do, they'll be massively more advanced than we are.

If a species only has radio for a short period of time (like 200 years) and then disappears or loses it, the odds of overlapping with them are virtually nil (if they die out after getting this far, it says we're much more likely to die out soon too).

And I don't know if they would talk to us before we'd talk to them. Stephen Hawking has a lot to say about why trying to communicate with other civilizations is a bad idea, and they might be smart enough not to try.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by prawn on Thursday January 12, 2012 @01:52AM (#3455323)
If we are significantly more advanced than them, I don't think they'll be contacting us - get me? Thus, if we're being contacted, chances are it's from something ahead of us in development.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by ars on Thursday January 12, 2012 @02:36AM (#3455413)
Yah, I guess that makes sense - although it's not what you said before.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by prawn on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:28AM (#3455931)
Sorry, how so? Here's what I said:

"I think with the time scales involved, chances are that anyone communicating with us would be significantly more advanced."

In both my original comment and my clarification I was clearly talking about only aliens who were communicating with us.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by ars on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:57AM (#3456001)
"communicating with us" != "contacted us"

The initial poster was talking about a hypothetical question we sent in 1912, meaning we contacted them, and they are communicating with us (they replied). You replied without changing the order of who contacted who.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by felipemnoa on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @08:49PM (#3454710)
We are pretty isolated. Had we belonged to a cluster of stars our chances of finding life would have been greater.

From Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_cluster

Globular clusters, or GC, are roughly spherical groupings of from 10,000 to several million stars packed into regions of from 10 to 30 light years across.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by martey on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @11:07PM (#3454997)
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Globular_cluster :

"However, they are not thought to be favorable locations for the survival of planetary systems. Planetary orbits are dynamically unstable within the cores of dense clusters because of the perturbations of passing stars."

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by malbs on Thursday January 12, 2012 @12:13AM (#3455132)
Some have theorized that the reason we are even talking about this is because we are _not_ in a cluster. We are pretty isolated, life ending events are pretty rare, every 60 million years?
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by michaelfeathers on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @10:55PM (#3454974)
I'm just troubled by the fact that alien TV signals appear to look like static.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by CamperBob on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:21AM (#3455910)
This is unfortunately no joke. Only a fairly primitive technological culture will waste energy and S/N ratio by using coherent signals for communications. Modern radio and TV signals look more or less exactly like static to a receiver that doesn't know what it's listening to, for the same reason that a .jpg or .zip file looks like random data to a program that doesn't know how to decompress it.

So it seems clear that SETI-like efforts will be unlikely to detect any transmissions from civilizations who aren't deliberately trying to talk to us. Only civilizations that occupy the narrow time slice caught between the invention of radio and the widespread adoption of digital computers would be detectable, otherwise.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by michaelcampbell on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @07:43PM (#3454504)
> 50 light-years is a really long distance.

Compared to what we can wrap our brains around generally, sure, but in the scheme of the universe, not so much.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by meepmorp on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @11:19PM (#3455016)
What about in comparison to a distance we'd be likely to reach before we annihilate ourselves?
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by alexkcd on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @11:57PM (#3455109)
I keep hearing this argument. But physically traveling there is pretty stupid if you think about it. It's much simpler to set up a communication channel.

Sure it'll have a 50 year latency, but we could easily stream all of youtube (or the entire internet really) to them, and so could they. Assuming they're more advanced and their cameras capture the environment in spherical 3D, we could recreate what it's like to stand on their soil pretty accurately from home.

Besides just browsing their extranet would be amazing in itself.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by sien on Thursday January 12, 2012 @01:31AM (#3455280)
So we discover another civilization and send them 4chan?

Mind you, seeing another species' civilization's sense of humor would be pretty amazing.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by dolbz on Thursday January 12, 2012 @06:44AM (#3455970)
> Sure it'll have a 50 year latency, but we could easily stream all of youtube (or the entire internet really) to them

Well Eric Schmidt who's probably in a better position to estimate than most, said that Google estimates the internet is made up of 5 million terabytes.

5 million terabytes / 10gbps = 126.8 years

and I very much doubt 10gbps is even remotely achievable over interstellar distances. I don't what kind of data rates are achievable but I would expect it to be extremely slow relative to Gigabit speeds.

Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by michaelcampbell on Thursday January 12, 2012 @07:45AM (#3456116)
I imagine by the time we find extra terrestrial intelligence, 10gbps will be childs play. I HOPE we find some way to use entanglement as a communications mechanism by then, although I don't know if that's even possible.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by MPSimmons on Thursday January 12, 2012 @10:49AM (#3456695)
Or we could, you know, use more than one channel.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by JeffL on Thursday January 12, 2012 @11:12PM (#3459165)
I wonder if the singularity happens like they say, and we can upload our minds into the computer, if we can send a slow probe to another star with a receiving dish and by the time it gets there, we can just beam our consciousnesses there, with maybe enough know-how to roll up an entirely new world with minimal resources.
Re:Our Galaxy Has at Least 100 Billion Planets, Study Shows by michaelcampbell on Thursday January 12, 2012 @07:50AM (#3456130)
Irrelevant to the fact being stated.