News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by abakker on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:14PM (#34538075)
Just a reminder that a .org does not mean "trustworthy".

https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Foundation_for_Individ...

In this case, the discussion and the tenor of the conversation is almost certainly cherry picked to serve a particular agenda.

On its face, the actions by Stanford in this article seem...not good. But I also suspect that this is making a mountain out of a molehill for political gain.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by sudobash1 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:20PM (#34538172)
Some other sources:

There is more information in the a "Stanford Daily" article:

https://stanforddaily.com/2023/01/22/protected-identity-harm...

And an opinion article in the "Standford Review":

https://stanfordreview.org/nazis-banned-books-we-shouldnt/

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by zozbot234 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:29PM (#34538313)
The Stanford Review article claims that the photo of the student reading that particular book may have been staged, as a "joke". If so, it does not seem surprising that such a stunt may potentially fall foul of Stanford's policies about protecting minority groups from harm or intimidation. There might not be an actual "book burning" concern of any sort here.
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by notahacker on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:50PM (#34538623)
And it's also entirely possible that the staged reading was, in fact, just a joke between friends at the ridiculousness of the Nazis that was massively overreacted to by an uninvolved party and that the university will end the investigation it's been asked to undertake by getting the participants to shake hands, move on with their lives and maybe think before acting next time.

It's odd to watch what is a fairly consistent pattern of Americans being more concerned about the free speech implications of students being students than a likely next presidential nominee banning entire university courses and introducing the felony offence of having unvetted books in school classrooms as part of his culture war against "wokeness" though...

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by minsc_and_boo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:26PM (#34538269)
But to GP's point, that appears to be the only news about the event:

https://news.google.com/search?q=mein%20kampf%20stanford

It seems like this really is a molehill.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by wahern on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:40PM (#34538478)
FIRE is a relatively new free speech advocacy organization started after the ACLU abandoned its very principled stance on free speech rights, which it had adopted in the 1970s, mostly famously in the Skokie Case where it supported a neo-Nazi organization.

Now, many of the organizers and funders of FIRE clearly have conservative leanings. But as far as I can tell, so far FIRE's advocacy has been just as principled and non-partisan as the ACLU once was. See, for example, FIRE pushing back against de Santis' retaliation against Disney: https://www.thefire.org/news/blogs/ronald-kl-collins-first-a... Or this recent case opposing a school board's overly broad censorship of sexually explicit material in its libraries: https://www.thefire.org/cases/penncrest-school-district-bans...

But, yes, by appearances many of their high-profile cases involve liberal colleges, but that's because of the strain of pro-censorship ideology which has become prevalent in liberal circles, causing a dramatic swing in the left's attitudes regarding free speech. Today, advocacy for expansive free speech rights has largely fallen into the hands of a mishmash of cross-partisan people and organizations, more so than in the past, where support on the left had once been more prevalent. And funding, specifically, now seems to be coming more from the right. But if once upon a time the ACLU, whose membership and funding predominately came from the left--even decades ago, not to mention today--could do it, then there's no reason why FIRE can't.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by commandlinefan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:52PM (#34538664)
> organizers and funders of FIRE clearly have conservative leanings

Freedom of speech as a concept has become (in a very bizarre plot twist to anybody who's old enough to remember even the 1980's) a conservative standpoint, so it's safe to assume anybody who's defending it in the 21st century has at least conservative leanings.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by rgbrenner on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:26PM (#34538273)
I read the sourcewatch link and see lots of conservative funding. So I went through FIREs articles and found lots of conservative-learning articles, but also:

https://www.thefire.org/news/florida-school-district-removes...

https://www.thefire.org/news/fire-warns-office-missouri-secr...

https://www.thefire.org/news/texas-bill-targeting-diversity-...

https://www.thefire.org/news/florida-school-district-removes...

So there's at least some bipartisan criticism. This article seems to match with the stanford article... so do you have any criticism of the contents of this article?

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by abakker on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:33PM (#34538378)
my personal criticism is that that the article's premise is that Stanford "May" ask someone to do something. The outlet has published a letter to stanford seeking corrective action in line with their politics.

In general, I am in favor of free speech and do not under any circumstances want to police what people read. (especially as reading Mein Kampf at a college would seem to suggest a certain course of study, rather than just recreation). But, I am not in favor of cherry picking incidents to drum up support for "holding people accountable" and making this into some kind of broader trend instead of isolated miscommunication.

I also acknowledge that Stanford has to address this and get it right. But, fire.org appears to be paid to generate this kind of content and that makes me mistrust their motives even if their content is fine.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by minsc_and_boo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:23PM (#34538217)
FIRE is a known sponsor of Turning Point USA.

This is absolutely a molehill mountain propped up to generate outrage, which you can see manifest in these comments.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by woooooo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:33PM (#34538369)
If academia is overwhelmingly biased in one direction, and a free speech org is documenting cases of suppression.. then of course most of the cases they document will exhibit that bias.

It doesn't necessarily follow that they're playing for a team or using "free speech" in a bad faith manner. Academia created the discrepancy, FIRE is just documenting it.

Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by Fomite on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:21PM (#34538188)
Given my experience with this organization when I was an undergrad, and reading their accounting of events that were going on on campus, I'd take this with more than just a grain of salt.
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by mc32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:18PM (#34538142)
How is keeping track of what people read a "molehill"? Do we now presume libraries will not keep your reading habits and history private?
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by kube-system on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:23PM (#34538231)
This article is about a picture posted on a snapchat story.
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by wilg on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:16PM (#34538118)
But now you’ve posted a .org! Is that one trustworthy?
Re:Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for readi... by abakker on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:26PM (#34538266)
lol, you are of course correct. It seems they are owned by the Center for Media and Democracy, which looks pretty neutral, but it is of course hard to tell.