Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by ChicagoBoy11 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:38AM
(#34532081)
This was... utterly predictable? Companies have incredibly strong incentives to maintain this information asymmetry, and it's a fool's endeavor to think we can legislate it away. I suspect the next chapter in this, if we try to further clamp down on this from a regulatory standpoint, is that you'll see more and more creativity in terms of what defines compensation, or perhaps even clever re-engineering of titles.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by shortrounddev on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:44AM
(#34532174)
You can get a more accurate number if you require companies to post salaries publicly, but anonymously. Just a list of job titles and their salaries
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:49AM
(#34532262)
That can depend on company size and the number of positions. Many "anonymous" data points aren't really that anonymous at smaller companies or with a smaller number of specific roles.
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by asoneth on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:16AM
(#34532655)
That is true. Many kinds of reporting requirements are only triggered for companies larger than a certain size, so perhaps that would be beneficial here as well to maintain anonymity.
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:21AM
(#34532750)
That covers half of it. Even in a fairly large company you can still have niche roles that could allow someone to de-anonymize the data. The group size wouldn't be 10k employees, just the 5 people you have in, for example, your legal department.
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by kris_wayton on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:48AM
(#34532238)
Doesn't it still have value though? Having to show the bottom means people near the bottom now know where they are.
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by ChicagoBoy11 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @01:56PM
(#34536808)
Who's to say the bottom is the actual bottom though? Suppose I pay all my engineer's 170, 170, 190, and 210. What prevents me from listing the salary range at 100-210?
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by sgerenser on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:37PM
(#34537538)
And this is exactly what Netflix is doing, because they don’t pay any of their senior engineers (these listings were for senior positions) only $90K. I’d be surprised if any (in the U.S. at least, and this is a U.S. job posting) make under $200K.
Re:$90k to $900k: Pay transparency laws usher in baffling pa...
by kris_wayton on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:01PM
(#34536929)
You're right, though the article is talking about pay transparency laws in several different US states, so perhaps some have this loophole and others don't.