Also, it seems naive to think that a ban on blocklists in the spec will keep real free humans from doing exactly as they’ve done on email, Mastodon etc and share block lists.
You're probably right about shared blacklists eventually becoming a thing though.
The "XMPP camp" is doing well and very busy: https://xmpp.org/newsletter/
We're lacking a nostr bridge if anyone wants to work on that...
That has no bearing on an attacker.
I don't get it. What's the point then?
You can mirror one relay to another easily:
echo '["REQ", "mirror" ,{}]' | websocat wss://source | jq -del '.[1]' | websocat wss://dest
No protocol can prevent a piece of software from doing whatever they want.
The "shall not" is not absolute: the spec assumes and expects relays not to talk to each other. Nothing prevents you from creating a relay that connects to another relay, of course, but that would not be in the spirit of what Nostr is trying to achieve.
Relays can be authenticated. If you don't want your relay to accept data from anyone, don't leave it open. Same with any other Internet protocol.
Also, per the spec or convention, relays SHALL NOT talk to each other. Each relay is a separate island, but the protocol permits and recommends clients to publish on multiple relays. This is the basis of their censorship-resistance.
See also my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34530876