News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:10PM (#34506555)
> Police departments are often the same.

I don't know understand why some people online seem to so often want to steer discussions towards how the police are so awful.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by BigRedDog1669 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:11PM (#34506581)
It seems pretty relevant here. Both prisons and the police are part of the government monopoly on violence.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#34506675)
The article is about prison mail. It has nothing to do with police officers and does not mention the "government monopoly on violence."
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by indymike on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:29PM (#34506880)
The OP is talking about why these kinds of things exist.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:37PM (#34507009)
> The OP is talking about why these kinds of things exist.

No they are not:

>jails are powerful in all the wrong ways. . . . This is what corrupted power looks like. . . . Police departments are often the same.

The article talks about prisons scanning mail. The OP then says that prisons are corrupt, then throws in that by the way, police departments are too.

OP's opinion about police department corruption has nothing to do with the article about prison mail.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by indymike on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:03PM (#34507387)
In the US a large number of incarceration facilities are ran by the county police (otherwise known as the Sheriff's department).
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by generj on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:41PM (#34508002)
Even worse, in some jurisdictions the incoming pipeline for hires routes through running the jail or prisons.

The mindset behind being a good cop and a good prison guard are totally different. Exposing hires to the corruption and violence inside prisons right before sending them to police the streets creates a very adversarial mindset against the public.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:32PM (#34507846)
WellYesButActuallyNo.jpeg

The majority of jails in the US are run by county sheriffs or local law enforcement. The majority of prisons are run by the states.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by indymike on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @10:11PM (#34513924)
That's like saying software is written in C vs Java. It's still software.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:54AM (#34516837)
Jails are for very short sentences and short term pre-trial incarceration. This can lead to some really dumb "X% of people in jail Y" type states that sound outrageous until you realize that X is drawn from a very specific subset of the incarcerated population.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by indymike on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @03:17PM (#34523567)
I wish it was as clear as string vs float, but it isn't. People get stuck in jails for 3-Undefined years all the time, all over the US. The only difference is "big state owned" and "many sizes incorporated area owned". Some states have laws that define this clearly, some don't. In many cases, even though it might be against the law, a prison is over-filled, so they outsource to county jails, and in others, the jail is over-filled so they outsource to another incarceration facility. It's a shit show, and I feel really bad for people that are caught in it.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by ipaddr on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:18PM (#34507612)
They are part of the same system where if one is happening it is more likely the idea will happen
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by danuker on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:55PM (#34507275)
Digitized mail is one more straw on the camel's back. It is an example of the deeper issue: the prison-industrial complex going backwards on rehabilitation, because it is following the bad incentives written into law.

Meanwhile, in Norway, the incarceration rate is 10x lower, while the 2-year recidivism is about 20% instead of the US's 50-60% [1].

[1] - https://web.archive.org/web/20100509171347/http://www.time.c...

Here's an idea: pay prisons a meaningful amount when people coming out of them stay out and/or get jobs. For example, a bonus each year for five years.

Another idea: penalize them for every death or recidivism.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by nobody9999 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:27PM (#34507765)
>Here's an idea: pay prisons a meaningful amount when people coming out of them stay out and/or get jobs. For example, a bonus each year for five years.

I get that you see financial incentives to prisons as the solution. However, that doesn't really solve the problem. Because it's not the prison or its administrators who deny housing and employment to those released from prison.

Which is why many folks (myself included) support "Ban the box"[0] laws.

Unless and until the societal stigma of incarceration (or even just an arrest -- both are public records) is satisfactorily addressed, this issue can't be solved. And certainly not with incentives to prison administrators.

[0] https://www.paycor.com/resource-center/articles/ban-the-box-...

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by Buttons840 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:20PM (#34507645)
Yes. To connect this with my point. The prisons stop inmates from receiving mail, but fail to stop drugs inside the prison or rival gangs from fighting. Aren't those more important than controlling the mail?

Although, now that I think about it, perhaps controlling the mail will help with drugs? I think there are easier solutions though.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:01PM (#34507354)
I agree with all of that (except maybe the "another idea" that was added via your edit). The U.S. prison system is in need of deep reform and this article is another great example of why. It's a completely misguided proposal that puts yet another private and profit-driven entity in a position of power over prisoners, extracting money from them and providing little if any value to the system.

The article still has nothing to do with police departments, though.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by nobody9999 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:21PM (#34507674)
>The article is about prison mail. It has nothing to do with police officers and does not mention the "government monopoly on violence."

No. The article is about jail mail. While "prison" and "jail" are often used interchangeably, they are not (at least in the US) the same thing.

Jails are for folks being detained before trial (i.e., they are innocent as they haven't been proven/pled guilty) or incarcerated for minor crimes (with a sentence of less than 1-2 years).

Prisons are for people who have been convicted of serious crimes (with sentences longer than a year or two).

That's not to say that those in prison should be exploited/abused, but this policy change affects those who haven't even been convicted of a crime.

As a rule, I'm usually disgusted by the US "justice" system. I'm even more disgusted now.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:31PM (#34507826)
It's about both prisons and jails. From the article:

> The proposed changes follow a nationwide trend of prisons and jails moving to stop incarcerated people from receiving physical mail. Prisons in Pennsylvania stopped physical mail in 2018, and prisons in Massachusetts started sending incarcerated people photocopies of original letters. Last year, prisons in New Mexico and Florida adopted similar changes, and Texas has also limited in-person mail.

Obviously it's a bit more relevant to prisons where prisoners tend to stay longer and are more likely to receive mail.

Also, none of this shows that the article has anything to do with police department corruption.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by nobody9999 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @03:39PM (#34509973)
Yeah, but WRT this horrendously egregious policy, I didn't (and won't) address facilities other than NYC jails, as that's most relevant to me.

This article isn't about front line police, yet you keep bringing them up. Why is that?

In fact, I didn't mention the police at all (although, as others have noted, corrections officers generally are sworn LEOs), so I don't know why you have such a hard on for cops[0].

No, not all cops are sadistic, power-drunk scumbags. But one is too many. cf. Daniel Pantaleo[1], Derek Chauvin[2] or Joseph Franco[3]. There are hundreds more that we know about. Which leaves many, many more we don't know about.

Why don't you invite some of these folks over for dinner so you can tell them how much you love and respect them? Well not Chauvin, as he's in jail, but you better hurry because Mr. Franco will be soon too.

[0]When I was a kid, it was clear that the police were just the biggest and best armed gang -- with qualified immunity == in NYC. And since I saw and experienced that dynamic a bunch of times over the years, the police themselves proved that to be true. Over and over again. There have been a few positive changes over the last decade or so, but not nearly enough. Certainly not enough to change my view of the police.

[1] https://abcnews.go.com/US/nypd-officer-put-eric-garner-letha...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derek_Chauvin

[3] https://abc7ny.com/joseph-franco-nypd-detective-convictions-...

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @04:06PM (#34510382)
> This article isn't about front line police, yet you keep bringing them up. Why is that?

This is literally my point in this thread. The article is not about the police and I don't understand why people are steering the discussion that way.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by nobody9999 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @04:40PM (#34510857)
>This is literally my point in this thread. The article is not about the police and I don't understand why people are steering the discussion that way.

I didn't even mention police. You did.

So who is it that's steering the discussion in that direction?

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by tinalumfoil on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @04:07PM (#34510395)
“Government monopoly on violence” is a phrase that I see constantly see on the internet that makes less and less sense the more you think about. Of all the news I read of killings near where I live none are the government doing it, and certainly it’s a minority of homicides nationally done by active government employees. And outside the world of crime there’s plenty of violent sports, plenty of violent non-criminal activity happens. I’d bet most people I know have experienced non government violence.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by i80and on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:12PM (#34506596)
This is pretty directly relevant to the article.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#34506678)
How so? The article is about prison mail. It doesn't even mention police officers and police officers have nothing to do with prison mail.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by alistairSH on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:25PM (#34506816)
The article stated most contraband in the jail is passed via the guards, not through the mail. Prison guards are LEOs, just part of a different agency than the police most of us see in town.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:47PM (#34507143)
> Prison guards are LEOs, just part of a different agency than the police most of us see in town.

So what? You might as well say the article is about dogs eating mail, dogs are mammals, so I'm going to talk about how much I hate elephants even though they don't eat mail.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by smcl on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:32PM (#34506936)
What's the big deal? People on HN explore adjacent topics quite frequently, and the idea that both police and prisons exist to exert power over (and frequently choose to exercise violence upon) the population is a very common and uncontroversial feeling.

Not trying to "out" you here, just trying to understand why you're fighting so hard on their behalf, but do you maybe have a friend or relative that works in the police? Nothing wrong with it, but I have seen that this causes people to be more willing to turn a blind eye towards (or even to outright forgive and excuse) some of the darker things they do. Often viewing them as victims to be defended, while many of the rest of us tend to want the police to be more accountable and generally less violent.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:45PM (#34507130)
> What's the big deal? People on HN explore adjacent topics quite frequently, and the idea that both police and prisons exist to exert power over (and frequently choose to exercise violence upon) the population is a very common and uncontroversial feeling.

It's popular right now to bash the police as corrupt and as not having people's best interest at heart. But the fact is that those are only some of the police. And when we start throwing out our respect for the institution as a whole, that's when we'll start seeing real corruption.

The big deal to me is that not everything has to be about police officers. The article raises a real issue about prisons scanning mail and refusing to deliver paper copies. That's horrible, and there is a ton of interesting stuff to discuss there. Why do we need to steer it towards yet another uninteresting and rote "police are all corrupt" "hell yeah suck it bootlickers" discussion?

> Not trying to "out" you here, just trying to understand why you're fighting so hard on their behalf, but do you maybe have a friend or relative that works in the police? Nothing wrong with it, but I have seen that this causes people to be more willing to turn a blind eye towards (or even to outright forgive and excuse) some of the darker things they do. Often viewing them as victims to be defended, while many of the rest of us tend to want the police to be more accountable and generally less violent.

I have zero relatives in law enforcement and I don't work in law enforcement. But I really think the rote "police suck" attitude and the current popularity of completely thoughtless police bashing is really going to hurt us all in the long run.

The flaw in your reasoning is that because some police officers have done bad things all police officers are bad. That's not true and it's not supported by the evidence.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by smcl on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:53PM (#34507254)
> some police officers have done bad things all police officers are bad

The flaw here is that there are countless examples of one police officer doing something terrible, and an entire department rallying around them in support. Or the opposite - like Adrian Schoolcraft attempting to blow the whistle, and being terrorized by the NYPD as a result.

The police generally do suck, and in the US at least they cost a lot of money and do little good while also doing some pretty shitty things and getting away with it. That's going to lead a lot of people to hate them for life, and it would take a herculean effort to reverse that. This is why I wondered if there's maybe a family/friend connection, because while I’m not exactly screaming for the abolishment of the Police altogether, I do think it's sort of absurd to come out swinging in defence the police as the exist in many countries

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:12PM (#34508557)
You've still said nothing about why this thread should be about police departments rather than mail scanning.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by smcl on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @04:32PM (#34510748)
Yes I did, in fact you know this because you even quoted me saying why I thought this was acceptable ame on-topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34507130
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by yladiz on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:20PM (#34507652)
Can you provide the evidence you mention at the end of your comment?
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:50PM (#34508154)
No, because my point here is that we shouldn’t be steering this thread into a discussion of police corruption, which has nothing to do with the article.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by yladiz on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @07:04PM (#34512453)
I’m skeptical of you because you do continue to push your point that the police are not corrupt, and that you don’t any provide evidence to prove your aforementioned point. Additionally, because a discussion isn’t completely related to the article doesn’t mean it can’t be discussed here so it doesn’t make sense to try to shut it down because you both disagree with it and disagree that it belongs here.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by woooooo on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#34506689)
Corrections officers are sworn officers in many (all?) states. Typically under an elected sheriff at the county level.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:21PM (#34506725)
There is a pretty huge difference between corrections officers working for the department of corrections and police officers working for the police department.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by ddulaney on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:33PM (#34506963)
Depends on the jurisdiction.

Where I am (Jefferson County, KY), corrections officers are routinely used as additional back-up during protests or other times when the police feel they need more manpower. They are also routinely hired to work as security when they are off duty, where they wear their uniforms and are allowed to make arrests.

In my jurisdiction, they are legally a type of sworn law enforcement officer and regularly appear in public in ways that are more-or-less indistinguishable from police officers.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by Spivak on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:34PM (#34506977)
Yeah, caged vs free range.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by crawfordcomeaux on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:35PM (#34506990)
And a huge similarity: they are given power over people and routinely use this power to harm, rather than help heal. Our 4-yr old has police trauma from police coming to bother us about them playing outside naked because traumatized older people ignorant of other cultures won't stop calling them.

Instead of visiting those people, they harass a child and parents for something that's legal. The child has nightmare of police shooting them.

This isn't because of misunderstanding, but because the nature of these systems and the sick sm cultures involved. Not talking about it persists it.

Trying to keep conversations strictly on-topic is a form of putting on blinders. It's also a neurotypical conversation style.

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by D13Fd on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:50PM (#34507203)
> And a huge similarity: they are given power over people and routinely use this power to harm, rather than help heal. Our 4-yr old has police trauma from police coming to bother us about them playing outside naked

That's horrible and I'm really sorry to hear it. I've let our daughter play outside naked and I'd be absolutely livid if law enforcement bothered us about it.

But that still has nothing to do with jails scanning mail (or even police "corruption").

Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by crawfordcomeaux on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:53PM (#34507258)
It's literally about having power over people, which is coming through the monopoly on violence, which is being exercised by scanning mail.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by bobkazamakis on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:12PM (#34506585)
I dont understand why some people online want to take every opportunity to defend class traitors.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by gnu8 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:16PM (#34506640)
No one on HN understands reality. The name of the site should be False Consciousness.
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by hungryforcodes on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#34506686)
Every online site is an echo chamber. Why are you here?
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by giraffe_lady on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:19PM (#34508672)
Why would participating preclude criticism? Does anything else work like that?
Re:NYC Jails Want to Ban Physical Mail, Then Privatize Scann... by hungryforcodes on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:30AM (#34520336)
True, but useful criticism. The OP's point was just patently obvious -- for any social media site.