Re:Ask HN: Name for the dynamic when new hires outperform th...
by parpfish on Monday January 23, 2023 @04:50PM
(#34495584)
The "A's hire A's" observation is interesting, but would result in the opposite effect -- it would lead to Bs managing Cs, whereas I'm talking about a situation where a B is managing a bunch of As.
Having done some more digging after posting this, I think I've found a related concept that I can use to do some more keyword digging. It sounds like "layering" is a strategy that can be used to specfically fight against this problem (https://forge.medium.com/what-to-do-when-you-get-layered-at-...), however this specific problem still doesn't have a name...
Re:Ask HN: Name for the dynamic when new hires outperform th...
by dredmorbius on Monday January 23, 2023 @04:58PM
(#34495696)
A truly incompetent B might accidentally hire some As. Accurate quality assessment is difficult, after all...
Mostly I was suggesting that as a related talent/recruitment dynamic, though arising from different causes.
That Medium piece gives a few interesting points. Good luck hunting!
Re:Ask HN: Name for the dynamic when new hires outperform th...
by klyrs on Monday January 23, 2023 @06:46PM
(#34496815)
If a B is managing a bunch of A's, that's good, right? Otherwise you're wasting your A talent on meetings. Your entrenched B probably holds a ton of institutional knowledge that the A's below will able to effectively put to use.
Re:Ask HN: Name for the dynamic when new hires outperform th...
by etempleton on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:34PM
(#34499315)
If a B hires a bunch of As maybe they are in fact an A at hiring, which is an incredibly valuable talent to have.
There's also the "A's hire A's, B's hire C's" -- mediocre managers tend to avoid putting potential competitors underneath them. This was observed by Cyril Northcote Parkinson in the 1950s, and arguably goes back much, much further in time. The "A's hire A's..." variant seems to trace to Hire the Best-- and Avoid the Rest, by Michael W. Mercer (~1993) (using Google Books search).
And if the best talent is consistently leaving when it realises that 1) it's being undercompensated 2) advancement and skills development opportunities are limited where it is and 3) both opportunities are greater elsewhere, then yes, you'll see short-lived new hires who may outperform longstanding employees (who lack those mobility options).
Factors such as restricted work visas or other exigent circumstances may give rise to specific employees who lack that mobility, and may also be more talented, but that's statistically rarer and less reliable. The fact still likely explains to some extent why such tools exist.
That said, I'm not aware of any specific widely-recognised name for the situation you describe. There's a considerable literature on talent retention which may turn that up, though much of that literature itself ... reflects limited talent. For numerous reasons. Looking for academic / sociology / organisational behaviour citations might be more useful than a general/trade search.