This does seem very un-amazon from my outside perspective. In the past I've always had the impression that amazon are very happy to shovel money in to an area if they think it'll improve their margin and/or protect them from reliance on third parties. This seems exactly the opposite of that! Stripe must be spending a shit load of cash with AWS and offering amazon a pretty attractive rate for processing.
I wonder if GCP has been fishing for stripe's business?
That would make a lot of sense: they mention increasing their use of AWS and this is something that neither Google nor Microsoft could really match as the carrot for an exclusive commitment. Stripe is already pretty big but being able to say Amazon trusts them with payments is a pretty strong sales pitch.
Being aggressive in banks is only half the equation. You also need to be aggressive against the e-commerce platform's own greediness.
.. track history proves otherwise.
No seriously, I used to use Amazon Pay for years long ago when it first became available for woocommerce powered stores and I specifically stopped because I had to manually download and go through all my weekly reports and add up the fees I was paying for my business's taxes. As advanced as Amazon can be sometimes they are very dinosaur like when it comes to financial reports or taxes. It took decades for them to collect taxes from sellers. Took years for them to finally catch a couple that were scamming millions of dollars in returns out of sellers. I stopped bothering with any Amazon products because of the years of glitches, gotchas, lack of reports, lack of understanding user intent or use cases. And the thing is, Amazon Pay was great, I had a lot of customers that used it and prefered to pay that way.
Makes sense for Amazon to work with a market leader in this case rather than spend years playing catch up. Perhaps in the long run they'll acquire Stripe instead of simply partnering.
There is some dogma that Amazon is peerless at building platforms and developing APIs, but this is a pretty big failure to capture the market given a huge head start.
This announcement is about these services coexisting, not about them competing.
For example, here is the original press release for FPS: https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2007/08/02/amazon...
I do see the Amazon Pay evolution (especially this expanded partnership with Stripe) as a distinct failure to capture the payment market.
However, I am very surprised that they are abandoning their own first-party payments to Stripe. Don't you all already have the very best rates possible, directly negotiated by every bank? In other countries Amazon has even threatened to stop accepting cards because they couldn't negotiate the fees they wanted, and they are about the only merchant big enough to dare doing that.
I'm sure they won't be paying Stripe the standard 2.9%, but still--what value does Amazon get out of this? Stripe is supposed to make payments easy from both a coding and business perspective for developers. Everything Stripe does, from card acceptance to fraud handling to UX to ACH payouts Amazon already has working at large scale.
These deals are priced on a cost-plus basis. Amazon might pay Stripe the cost of the underlying network fee plus .1% or half of cent.
Stripe negotiates fees with leverage.
note Stripe is publicly commuting to AWS in this announcement. It’s likely that the exchange here is “we use you for payments and you commit to $Xbn in AWS spend.”
Similar to MSFT and OpenAI. We give you billions, you spend it right back on Azure.
Same with Amazon's leverage for vendor negotiation. They will go for stock warrants if it's a big enough deal and they have the right leverage. More upside that way and it creates a competitive moat.
No idea if that's the case here though.
> Stripe will become a strategic payments partner for Amazon in the US, Europe, and Canada, processing a significant portion of Amazon’s total payments volume across its businesses, including Prime, Audible, Kindle, Amazon Pay, Buy With Prime, and more.
That makes it sound like some things (and certainly a significant percentage of the total) will be processed by Stripe, but not all spend. For example it doesn't seem like normal purchases on amazon.com would actually be processed by Stripe at this time.
The real innovation in this space seems to have come from companies replacing more layers in your typical e-commerce stack, like Shopify.
For me, Apple Pay is the only "new" payment processor that actually competes with PayPal because Apple made the user experience a lot faster and more convenient.
Amazon Pay and other payments products from Amazon are customer-facing products that make it easier for customers to make payments. Stripe is the backend software that makes it easier for Amazon to process those payments. They coexist, they don't replace each other.
[0] https://www.insiderintelligence.com/content/amazon-hopes-inc...
Just a quick guess I am pulling out of my ass.
Did somebody high up do a cost analysis/breakdown that said: is this entire business org making the company money or can we just use Stripe for less money?
Does it boil down to that gross oversimplification or not?
I'm sure it isn't easy to quantify the intangibles (if there were any) on what edges Amazon had over Stripe and benefitted from by choosing to do it in house. I'm sure it might not seem like an apples-to-apples comparison, but I guess when you zoom out high enough (company spending $X money in, getting Y out) it's comparable to any other purchasable good/service?
That would definitely be a factor, but also competitive strategy and product placement. Do they really want to try and take on Stripe, Apple Pay, Shopify, etc? What exactly are they offering that's unique? Is it a core competency? How does this work alongside existing business interests?
And more.
Is the answer "they did when the Federal Reserve had interest rates at 0.25%" and now that interest rates are currently are 4.5% headed toward potentially 5%+ and/or just staying in the 4-5% range for at least 6-12 months "no"?
Somebody (multiple people?) obviously signed off on investing resources into this in the first place. How long ago, I'm not sure. Could some clairvoyantly even back then that this would get scraped? No clue, I have no internal leg up/leak/data.
Why was the answer yes then (yes = invest in it) and now, when they have a finished-ish product, no (no = don't try to internally compete with Stripe)?
OK, not technically a hedge fund.
It's easy to forget (looking from the bottom-up) that when you're surveying from the top-down, there are always alternative places to spend $1.
So it isn't enough to make >$1 in return for every $1 invested, you have to offer better return than the other things the company could be doing with that capital.
F.ex. in retail, there's an everpresent alternative of investing in logistics and warehouse automation, which saves the business a LOT of money
And the big thing now (at least I think it is, although I don't have any proof that companies are actually doing this) is...
https://www.investors.com/etfs-and-funds/sectors/sp500-compa...
I don't think every one of these corporations is going to take 100% of their cash on hand and stash it into 10 year bonds overnight...
But I'm lead to believe some variation of this is happening. Corporations can make 3-4% risk free + short term. If you work on a project that doesn't bring the company at least 3-4% ROI after it's all said and done (you, your managers, all expenses, etc.)... why are you owed a job?
Very cruel and mean reality, right?
That was my best educated guess. For long, Amazon invested in payments believing it to be a differentiator and also to spin it off into its own business unit. The payments division at Amazon is huge. But after two decades of not going anywhere with payments business they seem to have thrown in the towel and focus instead on physical logistics side of e-commerce.
To me it's big step up in maturity for Amazon to find the right areas to focus on, and get the right partnerships.
The PR statements are very carefully worded to say, strategic partner that will be "processing a significant portion of Amazon’s total payments volume." If significant portion was going to mean anywhere near 100%, I'm sure Stripe would have shouted that fact from the rooftops even louder (what a huge win that would be!).
For my money, this really just reads like mostly a quid-pro-quo deal, you give me X% of payments volume, I'll give you Y level of commitment to AWS. With no insider knowledge of any kind, I would wildly speculate that "significant portion" could mean a value of X as low as 5-10%.
doesn’t sound like it’s a replacement for the amazon pay button at all
Next to Walmart, Amazon is probably the largest single credit card payment recipient on planet earth right now, at least in volume of transactions. If Amazon went through the work as you mentioned, to build our their own payments solution for several years and eventually abandoned it in favor of using "off-the-shelf" Stripe. Now, I do recognize that I am sure Stripe is somewhat customized for Amazon's use case and they obviously aren't charging Amazon anywhere near 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction. So its a little different than the Stripe we use, but its still a fascinating argument in the "Buy vs Build" debate to favor buying over building.
I find it also interesting coming from Amazon. Since much of the work I am doing right now is moving internally-built technical systems to AWS' managed and built solutions. So I am deep in the transition of moving built technical systems to a buy model from AWS across many different technologies. To see Amazon dishing off their payments to another company instead of maintaining it in house just feels like the ultimate "circle of life" or rather, "circle of specialization".
Tech is getting so complicated now that its becoming harder and harder to justify in-house solutions to problems. It seems like anymore we are moving everything to be managed by a different provider with companies focusing on one or two things they are amazing at and everything else being passed to another company who specializes at that other thing.
However going by this news seems like Amazon has more or less given up on their payments ambitions. Could be also due to recent layoffs. This is a big news. Maybe Amazon wants to focus on being good at few things instead of running hundreds of experiments.
Edit: References.
[1] https://pay.amazon.com
[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ryanmac/2015/10/30/amazon-kills...