Re:The Point of the Banach-Tarski Theorem
by ogogmad on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:52PM
(#34485607)
I don't think your objection is particularly important.
It seems to me that if you work with a vector space, you usually have an explicit basis in mind for it, without needing AC to get it. That basis need not be (and usually isn't) a Hamel basis; it might for instance be an orthonormal basis or Schauder basis whenever such concepts are meaningful.
Another way of putting it: If the
category of vector spaces over R
is different from the
category of vector spaces over R admitting bases
then work in the latter category only. I don't think you'll lose anything practically important.
It seems to me that if you work with a vector space, you usually have an explicit basis in mind for it, without needing AC to get it. That basis need not be (and usually isn't) a Hamel basis; it might for instance be an orthonormal basis or Schauder basis whenever such concepts are meaningful.
Another way of putting it: If the
is different from the then work in the latter category only. I don't think you'll lose anything practically important.