Re:The Point of the Banach-Tarski Theorem
by ogogmad on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:52PM
(#34485607)
I don't think your objection is particularly important.
It seems to me that if you work with a vector space, you usually have an explicit basis in mind for it, without needing AC to get it. That basis need not be (and usually isn't) a Hamel basis; it might for instance be an orthonormal basis or Schauder basis whenever such concepts are meaningful.
Another way of putting it: If the
category of vector spaces over R
is different from the category of vector spaces over R admitting bases
then work in the latter category only. I don't think you'll lose anything practically important.
This means if you want to deny the Axiom in some cases, you will also have to allow for the existence of vector spaces without a basis.