News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by ahelwer on Saturday January 21, 2023 @05:54PM (#34471585)
This is true of basically all literary journalism. How do so many interesting things happen to these people that they can write about it? Easy, they make it up. David Foster Wallace is another example, said as someone who enjoys his essays. And David Sedaris, not that he really styles himself as a journalist.
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by EamonnMR on Saturday January 21, 2023 @06:39PM (#34472126)
The article digging into Sedaris was especially silly since it's clear that he's a comic (and a great one at that) and the fact that he may have taken NPR for a ride just makes him funnier.
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by iamthepieman on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:48PM (#34474400)
Which article is this?
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by EamonnMR on Monday January 23, 2023 @03:15AM (#34486609)
Embarrassingly I can't find it now. It was styled as am expose that proved that elements of Santaland diaries were untrue.
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by shellothere on Monday January 23, 2023 @03:54AM (#34486788)
His wild and delightful caricatures are often so absurd it’s comical to imagine someone reviewing each under a microscope seeking evidence of exaggeration or falsehood… that’s sort of the point!
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by jackstraw14 on Saturday January 21, 2023 @06:17PM (#34471841)
Which stuff in DFW's essays did he make up?
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by woodruffw on Saturday January 21, 2023 @07:23PM (#34472573)
This is from memory, but ISTR people claiming that Wallace's characterizations in essays like "Shipping Out" are mostly fictionalized for (successful!) literary value.

Edit: Found it: Franzen thinks that his dialogues were implausible[1].

[1]: https://www.theawl.com/2011/10/a-supposedly-true-thing-jonat...

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by giardia on Saturday January 21, 2023 @07:10PM (#34472460)
Steinbeck too (Travels With Charley).
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by rcme on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:49PM (#34473696)
DFW’s essays are more about his personal insights into the subject rather than the subject itself. I’m sure not everything written is 100% word-for-word accurate, but I don’t get the impression he embellishes too much because he doesn’t have to. The subjects of his essays are quite mundane: a mediocre cruse, a middling tennis player, 4H, etc.
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by moioci on Saturday January 21, 2023 @10:42PM (#34474008)
> a middling tennis player...

If you're referring to the 2006 NYT piece on Roger Federer, I think you're not supporting the "quite mundane" characterization

https://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/20/sports/playmagazine/20fed...

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by rcme on Saturday January 21, 2023 @10:44PM (#34474020)
I was talking about the essay "Tennis Player Michael Joyce's Professional Artistry as a Paradigm of Certain Stuff about Choice, Freedom, Discipline, Joy, Grotesquerie, and Human Completeness"

Michael Joyce's highest ranking was 64.

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by Beldin on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:17AM (#34475155)
64 in what? 64th worldwide is obviously not a middling player; 64th of his local club probably falls shy of that lofty moniker.

Perhaps you meant "middling professional player"? Because I don't think there's enough money to be made to pay for expenses and support you year-round if you do not crack the top-100.

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by rcme on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:20AM (#34478170)
You should read the essay, I think you’d like it. Your comment strikes the heart of the matter.

Yes, Michael Joyce was the 64th best in the world. He’s reached a level of tennis that almost every other player in the world can only dream of. Joyce’s ability to play tennis was rivaled only by a small handful of people in the entire world. And yet… not many will ever hear of Michael Joyce. He won’t be able to earn a sustainable wage playing the game. Ultimately, he might be even worse off than the 64th best player at a local club. So what’s the point? Why does Joyce do it?

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by giraffe_lady on Sunday January 22, 2023 @07:29PM (#34483952)
It's not so much that he embellishes what happens but seems to have fabricated context to write about at all. In the essay where he visits a midwestern state fair with a long-time local acquaintance, for example, a lot of the interest of the story is in the observations and "folk witticisms" of his companion. That companion doesn't seem to have existed at all, which drastically changes the character of the piece and is not merely an embellishment.

Similarly the cruise essay has a memorable scene where he plays a game of chess against a child. His biographer and close friend, who rarely challenges the DFW mythology directly, specifically calls that one out and explains why he believes it didn't happen and that child didn't exist. Again this isn't embellishing a detail for the sake of a good story, this is much closer to fiction writing, which in contemporary literature is also often closed tied to direct personal experience in this way.

I don't think writing in this way is dishonest, fwiw, or that this indicates anything bad per se. I think characterizing it as journalism, or even nonfictions essays is a mistake though. It's easy to see why it would have been sold that way at the time, but we don't have to stay with that classification now. I don't think it's likely that DFW published anything that could be considered strictly nonfiction. Ambitious as he was, this is almost certainly the reason he never agreed to publish anything in the new yorker which would have been such an obviously ideal publication for his "nonfiction," if it weren't for their sophisticated and ruthless fact checkers.

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by geepound on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:20PM (#34474231)
>This is true of basically all literary journalism. How do so many interesting things happen to these people that they can write about it? Easy, they make it up.

It is not all made up.

>“There is just a very shallow truth in facts,” he told me. “Otherwise, the phone directory would be the Book of Books.”

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/04/24/the-ecstatic-t...

Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by everybodyknows on Sunday January 22, 2023 @12:07AM (#34474501)
Hunter S. Thompson, Fear And Loathing On The Campaign Trail. As he put it in a later television interview: "There was a rumor in Philadelphia about Ed Muskie being addicted to ibogaine. I know, I started it."
Re:When Truman Capote’s Lies Caught Up with Him by boppo1 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @07:03AM (#34476541)
Yeah, that book is 75% fiction, at least. But it's a fun read.