Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by h0l0cube on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:33PM
(#34463249)
How tragic would it be if someone’s deep empathic nature made them feel personally responsible for a death beyond their control – to the point of suicidal ideation - and was then imprisoned for it?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by eyelidlessness on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:00PM
(#34463417)
Too common and too tragic.
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by WeylandYutani on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:26PM
(#34463565)
There was a case in the Netherlands in which they got a nurse to confess to a killing spree.
Unfortunately it is impossible to explain to people that a confession is meaningless.
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by api on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:30PM
(#34463587)
Good investigators withhold details about a crime from the public mostly to filter out false confessions. This speaks to the fact that false confessions are common enough to make filtering techniques common practice.
[dead]
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by smolder on Sunday January 22, 2023 @04:00AM
(#34475612)
Can you stop writing these garbage GPT comments, please? No one wants to waste time reading this shit.
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by ArnoVW on Saturday January 21, 2023 @05:38AM
(#34465432)
I think you're talking about Lucia de B. The first sentence of the article :
When a Dutch nurse named Lucia de Berk...
In fact, she never confessed. As per her Wikipedia page: Important evidence at the appeal was to be the statement of a detainee in the Pieter Baan Center, a criminal psychological observation unit, where de Berk had said during outdoor exercise, "I released these 13 people from their suffering". However, during the appeal, the man withdrew his statement and stated that he had made it up.
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by roxgib on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:40PM
(#34463951)
The Australian case mentioned in the article had a similar theme. Kathleen Folbigg wrote diary entries blaming herself for her kids' deaths, and these were interpreted as admissions of guilt (in fairness they could definitely be read that way). She had four of her own children die of undetermined causes and was basically convicted on the diary entries and the improbability of them all dying. Has been a long and ongoing public debate here (she's still in jail).
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by jonny_eh on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:40AM
(#34464674)
Apparently there's new evidence that a gene mutation may have been to blame, and she could be released soon: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/nov/13/australian-m...
The evidence in her case does seem too circumstantial to convict, a real injustice.
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by lelanthran on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:40AM
(#34464673)
> How tragic would it be if someone’s deep empathic nature made them feel personally responsible for a death beyond their control – to the point of suicidal ideation - and was then imprisoned for it?
Haven't you ever read The Green Mile?
Re:Unlucky numbers (shoddy statistics that put nurses in pri...
by h0l0cube on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:55PM
(#34473740)
I haven't, but I think, outside of fiction, history is littered with examples of these kinds of witch hunts happening. What bothers me is that now, more than ever, we know about these outcomes – and as you point out there's even neo-folklore about them – and yet we haven't progressed enough as a species to stop them happening.