News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:48AM (#34449935)
A great deal of government positions involve carrying a gun. Having a gun and being a pot user is a felony with 10+ years in jail. It's one of the most serious non-violent offenses for mere personal use possession on the books.

It's also very easy to detect because pot stays in your system longer than about any other drug and the penalty for pot use by non-firearm owners is so weak and unenforced that people often forget it is a very severe crime for the ~40% of US that owns arms. People mistakenly get nonchalant about it.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by simonjgreen on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:40AM (#34450183)
This doesn't really answer the question though. "Why" is it looked on in this way?
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:46AM (#34450228)
I haven't been in a federal interview, but I would say it gets more focus merely because it is the most popular of the illegal drugs by a landslide.

The government has to remind you it's illegal because well "everybody" does it and it really doesn't seem like it actually is and it sure as hell doesn't feel like you're doing something wrong or harmful. So somebody has to tell you that this drug is really bad because you'll go to jail for it for a long time.

The main reason pot is bad is because it will get you a jail sentence. The main reason you'll get a jail sentence is because it's bad. Hope that clears it up.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by henrikschroder on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:33AM (#34450459)
This smells like a "war on drugs" thing where it's illegal because it's extremely convenient for law enforcement that this combo is illegal.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by refurb on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:54AM (#34451830)
Security screening criteria doesn’t get updated often.

It wasn’t that long ago that marijuana was an illegal drug in every state. And as a schedule 1 drug marijuana gets lumped in with crack and PCP.

I have no doubt updating security clearance requirements is a massive bureaucratic mess nobody is interested in doing.

So the requirements remain, but everyone just “massages” the answers to fit current norms.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by carlmr on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:38AM (#34450170)
>it is a very severe crime for the ~40% of US that owns arms.

Only if you carry them with you, right?

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:50AM (#34450241)
No. A single speck of pot + just being someone that owns guns at all is 10 years in jail. Look up "constructive possession."

AFAIK it's the feds position that even merely having a medical marijuana card (which doesn't mean you actually have ever even bought/consumed weed) and owning a gun makes you a felon.

Note: not a lawyer, not legal advice.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:23AM (#34451064)
A medical marijuana card is a much stronger indicator of "I am currently a user of marijuana" than even current possession, let alone some past purchase. The whole point of such a card is to be prescribed marijuana, and the whole point of a prescription is for you to follow it.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:28AM (#34451099)
Why? I've read a number of accounts of people who got the card just to buy/grow for their cancer stricken grandma or whatever. Sure maybe it's a lie but then again it's pretty believable and reasonable.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:13AM (#34451508)
Usually it'd be the grandma getting the card, then, no?
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:19PM (#34457323)
Even assuming grandma is going to buy it herself, which probably isnt always practical, there's probably some people out there not thrilled about going to jail because grandma put pot in the console of the car or left it on the kitchen table and suddenly they have constructive possession without a card.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:53PM (#34457879)
Right, but that's the thing: possession (even in the actual sense, let alone constructive possession) doesn't mean use. A card declaring (in effect) "I have been prescribed cannabis to use it as medicine" does mean use.

If anything, Grandma being the card-carrying pot user and not you would likely be evidence in your favor - to be presented and argued by a competent defense attorney in court, of course, not by you to some power-tripping cops interrogating you (the only correct response to a cop asking you anything for any reason at any time under any circumstance is for you to invoke your rights to silence and an attorney - and such a "shut the fuck up" strategy has indeed gotten people out of pot-related convictions, at least if these lawyers are to be believed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgWHrkDX35o).

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:17PM (#34458273)
When I had my wisdom teeth removed I received a legal prescription for opiates and had the prescription filled and took possession of them. Thankfully I was able to tough it out with just NSAIDS and never took them.

Was I an opiate user? If I just keep the script but never fill it am I more an opiate user than the guy on the street with a little baggy of white powder? People seek out and obtain scripts for stuff they never use, all the time.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:57PM (#34460559)
> Was I an opiate user?

Given that they were prescribed to you, "yes" would be a reasonable assumption, barring you able to provide evidence introducing reasonable doubt (e.g. "I still have every pill I was ever prescribed").

In any case, "was" is the key word. You were given a prescription for a finite number of doses, whereas usually a medical marijuana card is more indefinite.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by uneoneuno on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:41AM (#34451730)
Whhhhaaat how do I not know this??? Thank you sir. I'm gonna be asking my lawyer some questions.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by dragonwriter on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:38AM (#34450796)
No, any illegal use or addiction to a wide array of drugs makes it a crime for you to own, possess, buy, sell, transport, etc., a firearm, and separately a crime for anyone to knowingly sell or transfer one to you. Marijuana is included, and because it is a Federal Schedule I narcotic, all use is, by definition, illegal use, even state-permitted medical use (and even though there is a federal policy against direct enforcement of the federal prohibition of marijuana against state legal use, this policy does not extend to the criminal firearms exclusion tied to it.)

The quasi-legality of state-permitted and federally-prohibited-without-direct-enforcement is kind of an awful trap, and that’s even before you consider the risks if the federal enforcement pause – which doesn’t change the criminal law and thus would not raise ex post facto concerns for enforcement against acts that occurred during (or before, if the statute of limitations allows) the pause – were to be lifted.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by no-s on Saturday January 21, 2023 @03:21PM (#34470029)
> The quasi-legality of state-permitted and federally-prohibited-without-direct-enforcement is kind of an awful trap

Perhaps a trap that rises to the level of (HHOS) conspiracy to commit a crime: TITLE 18, U.S.C., SECTION 242

disclaimer: The answers I give on form 4473 are absolutely truthful.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by dragonwriter on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:36AM (#34450468)
> A great deal of government positions involve carrying a gun.

The vast majority do not; there are 137,000 that are authorized to carry a gun and/or make arrests, out of 2.85 million non-military federal employees.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:44AM (#34450496)
By my reckoning the majority of clearances are DOD active or reserve/guard [0]. That alone pushing it to 50+% of the people need to be allowed to have guns even if they only shoot a rifle once during basic and then are supposed to be able to figure it out if shit hits the fan. Now consider 3 letter agencies etc.

I feel very confident saying being qualified to use a gun is essential to the majority of those with an active clearance, and thus highly relevant to the drugs question part of the clearance.

[0] https://news.clearancejobs.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Se...

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:17AM (#34451025)
The flip side is that someone hoping to prosecute a "pot user" for being such while obtaining a firearm would have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the suspect was indeed a "pot user" at the time one answered the question.

I've submitted to no less than five background checks for purchasing firearms. My ID has also been scanned at multiple dispensaries in the same state as those background checks. Not once has the latter caused any issue with the former - in all likelihood because "I at one point set foot in a dispensary" != "I actually purchased something in that dispensary" != "I actually consumed something purchased from that dispensary" != "I was a user of something purchased from that dispensary at the time that I answered a question about whether or not I use federally-controlled substances".

Maybe if background checks included drug tests this would be a practical concern, but as it stands, unless you show up to the gun store stoned out of your gourd (hell, even then), there is little opportunity to demonstrate "the defendant lied about not being a user of illicit substances at the time one purchased the firearm".

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:27AM (#34451092)
I can not give you legal advice but only tell you my personal understanding for entertainment purposes. And my personal understanding is that the same prohibition applies even for possessing it, not just when you acquire it. My non-lawyer mind it's pretty clear under 18 USC 922.

At the end of the day the feds got a warrant to drag me to the hospital and internally search my body for drugs because third party hearsay that an anonymous cop said an anonymous dog supposedly said I had drugs. If third party hearsay is good enough for a warrant why wouldn't video evidence or ID scan of you at the gun store and the pot shop? Sure you can claim "well the test at the hospital shows metabolites and the video shows buying weed and guns but hey you can't prove I actually used weed" but good luck with that.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:07AM (#34451463)
The relevant bit(s) would be "It shall be unlawful for any person [...] who is an unlawful user of or addicted to any controlled substance (as defined in section 102 of the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. 802)) [...] to ship or transport in interstate or foreign commerce, or possess in or affecting commerce, any firearm or ammunition; or to receive any firearm or ammunition which has been shipped or transported in interstate or foreign commerce."

So a prosecutor would need to prove that I was "an unlawful user of or addicted to any controlled substance" at the time that I received a firearm or ammunition that has crossed my state's borders (which would presumably be nearly all the firearms and ammunition I own, but still). There's also the parallel prohibition on the seller's end (and another one involving the actual background check questions), with the same present-tense language of "is an unlawful user of or addicted to any controlled substance".

> If third party hearsay is good enough for a warrant why wouldn't video evidence of you at the gun store and the pot shop?

A warrant != a conviction. The video evidence of me at both stores would not establish that I was "an unlawful user of or addicted to any controlled substance" at the time that I took possession of the firearm.

Now, if there was video evidence of me smoking a phat blunt right outside the gun store before walking in and walking back out with a firearm, then yeah, that'd be a slam dunk case (assuming the prosecutor could convince a jury that it was indeed cannabis I was smoking). Likewise, if I was actually tested for cannabis in my system and the tests indicated that it was indeed in my system at the time I took possession of the firearm, then that would similarly be a slam dunk case.

(I guess even in the latter case I could maybe argue "yeah, I was an unlawful user, but I quit before buying the gun", but that defense is pretty weak if it's still in my system; I reckon it'd be stronger if I was sober for an actually-significant amount of time.)

Barring those? I ain't a lawyer, either, but my personal understanding is that the present-tense wording leaves a loophole big enough to drive a truck through it. Obviously the safest bet is to not rely on that being the case, but it's pretty easy to answer "No" to "Are you an illegal user of or addicted to any controlled substance?" without it being a felonious lie.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by GTP on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:55AM (#34453139)
> or possess in or affecting commerce

Doesn't this mean that the prohibition of using such substances doesn't apply just to the moment of purchase, but to the whole period of time that you posses a firearm? I'm not a lawyer either and I'm not even American, but this is how I would interpret it. Also it would make little sense to have a law saying that you can't be a user of illegal drugs at the moment of purchase of a firearm, but you can start using such substances afterwards.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:33PM (#34457555)
It would apply as it pertains to being "in or affecting commerce"; it'd be quite the stretch to apply that to possession outside the immediate context of a purchase/sale/transfer, though I suppose it wouldn't be the first time the Feds abused the ever-loving hell out of the Commerce Clause. Maybe taking a gun across state lines while high would qualify?

> Also it would make little sense to have a law saying that you can't be a user of illegal drugs at the moment of purchase of a firearm, but you can start using such substances afterwards.

The law in question derives from the federal government's Constitutional authority to regulate interstate and international commerce, which is (I would guess) why the language fixates on that aspect. The federal government doesn't otherwise have the power to infringe on the Second, Fourth, and (possibly) Tenth Amendments - as would likely be necessary to federally require gun owners to submit to random drug tests over something that one's state has made legal.

Meanwhile, my state (last I checked) has laws on the books separately prohibiting intoxication (be it via cannabis, alcohol, or whatever) while in possession of a firearm; to my knowledge, most (all?) states do.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:40PM (#34457665)
Read up on Jeremy Kettler's attempt to avoid interstate commerce and also Wickard v Filburn. You probably know about the latter but not the former.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:28PM (#34458442)
Those are what I was alluding to when I said "it wouldn't be the first time the Feds abused the ever-loving hell out of the Commerce Clause" :)

Both those cases entailed the defendants manufacturing something, which would be where the Feds would claim jurisdiction via their jurisdiction over interstate commerce. It's harder to make that argument w.r.t. something after a retail sale has already concluded (i.e. after the interstate commerce has happened). I wouldn't doubt the Feds would try to assert that literally everything that ever happens is or pertains to "interstate commerce", but that'd be sufficiently broad as to invalidate all sorts of other judicial precedents if actually held up in court.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:44PM (#34458673)
Wait until you read the gun free school zone act, which seemingly makes it interstate commerce merely to be on a public property proximal but not on school property, no matter you have no intent to interact with the school or the school property in any way.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by GTP on Saturday January 21, 2023 @04:59AM (#34465272)
So in the end using drugs while possesing a firearm makes it worse, it's just that those aren't federal laws but still apply.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:40PM (#34456678)
I recommend you consult a lawyer. Always understand the difference between "the law can be flouted and probably safely gotten away with so long as I don't piss off anyone powerful" and "this is legal."
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by yellowapple on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:58PM (#34457954)
That's the thing: as written, the law puts everything short of "I was literally high at the time I took possession of the firearm" in the "this is legal" category.

This of course only pertains to federal law; states have their own laws, and said laws usually prohibit being armed while intoxicated - regardless of the legality of the intoxicating substance.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:06PM (#34458098)
Once again, because I am not a lawyer I cannot give you specific legal advice for your situation.

I strongly, strongly believe you are overconfident in your interpretation, particular when I read the provisions regarding possession which may be a seperate crime from say what was written on the 4473 at the FFL.

But I'm not the one you have to convince. I pray you are never in a position you must do the convincing.

I do not believe I am an authoritative enough of a professional to convince you, even were it that I had time to type a more complete explanation. Again I recommend you consult a lawyer, and preferably one that has worked in this area. My opinion as a rando on HN has no legal bearing on the justice system.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by WirelessGigabit on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:51PM (#34474418)
The scan of your license does not leave the computer of the dispensary.

That is until they get ransomwared.

In that case I need to report that my identity has been stolen.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by varispeed on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:24AM (#34452130)
Even if you are a (legal) medical user?
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:14PM (#34456298)
There's no such thing as a legal pot user.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by wkat4242 on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:41AM (#34452979)
Thanks, that explains a lot.

I still wonder why the law is that way though. As drugs go, marijuana is probably the least worrying when it comes to gun possession. As it makes people docile and relaxed, it will help de-escalate conflicts.

As opposed to coke which makes people pumped up or even the fully legal alcohol...

It sounds like federal law should catch up to reality. Though as a European I am not in favor of widespread gun use anyway but that's another discussion.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notch656c on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:33PM (#34456558)
Cocaine is schedule II. A doc can write a federally valid script for it. So someone could be using it and hypothetically not be breaking the law regarding illegal user with guns.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by notadev on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:43AM (#34454574)
Asking for a friend: what should you do if you were a legal firearm owner before moving to an area with medicinal cannabis and then got your card? Sure don’t do it in the first place, but what options should so recommend to my friend in order to keep them out of trouble? Also, does the ATF trawl through state cannabis records to cross-reference gun owners?