Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:39AM
(#34449896)
> This microcontroller-focused operating system is the continuation of RetroBSD, a 2.11BSD-based OS targeting only the MIPS-based PIC32MX7. DiscoBSD is multi-platform, as it also supports Arm Cortex-M4 STM32F4 devices.
So is RetroBSD inactive, or is this an extension/fork to add more hardware targets?
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by caned on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:17AM
(#34452713)
Seems like a bit of both. Serge Vakulenko of RetroBSD has responded recently to issues filed on RetroBSD, but has stated that he has limited time to work on adding ports for other architectures.
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by dbuder on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:12AM
(#34450353)
This is great - I like RTEMS but I was looking for something like DiscoBSD when I found it
Any comments on developing with either would be most appreciated
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by somat on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:44AM
(#34450494)
For them that are confused 2bsd is best thought of as 16 bit bsd, and as such it's development carried on for far longer than would be thought.
I have to admit I am not sure why you need a 16 bit os for a 32 bit processer like the pic32. Best I can come up with is that because 16 bit is such a constrained memory space it runs well on small microcontrollers.
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by actionfromafar on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:38AM
(#34451172)
It's not 16-bit as such. But since it's small enough to fit in 16-bit, it's small enough to fit on the small memory available on pic32.
It's like what if you have an 80386. It can run Linux (which is 32 bit). But your 80386 only has 1 megabyte of RAM. Then you can run Minix! Minix is available both in 32 bit and 16 bit versions. You could run the 16 bit, but then you get all the 16-bit limitations, so you can run the 32 bit version of Minix. Still small, but you get the added benefits of larger integers and larger address space.
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by caned on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:25AM
(#34452789)
The latter, but also 2.11bsd does not have virtual memory, and thus does not require an MMU. It was written with the segmentation features of a PDP-11 in mind, which so happen to adapt to PIC32 as it has kernel/user separation and memory protection via a kseg/useg segmentation (as opposed to a TLB with individual page protections).
Re:DiscoBSD: 2.11BSD-Based OS for STM32 and PIC32 Microcontr...
by pjmlp on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:52AM
(#34451305)
To make it even more explictly how much it took for UNIX world to catch up with ANSI/ISO C89, while coding on HP-UX 11 back in 1999 - 2001, I still had to write K&R C as the aC compiler installed on the system wasn't fully compliant.
So is RetroBSD inactive, or is this an extension/fork to add more hardware targets?
https://github.com/RetroBSD/retrobsd/issues/87
Samesame ;)
I have to admit I am not sure why you need a 16 bit os for a 32 bit processer like the pic32. Best I can come up with is that because 16 bit is such a constrained memory space it runs well on small microcontrollers.
It's like what if you have an 80386. It can run Linux (which is 32 bit). But your 80386 only has 1 megabyte of RAM. Then you can run Minix! Minix is available both in 32 bit and 16 bit versions. You could run the 16 bit, but then you get all the 16-bit limitations, so you can run the 32 bit version of Minix. Still small, but you get the added benefits of larger integers and larger address space.
But iiih it's K&R C:
Is this expected given the heritage? I know nothing about BSDs basically.Edit: code formatting.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkeley_Software_Distribution...