It’s also not an accident electric cars are so heavy—gasoline or diesel fuel are fantastically energy-dense compared to almost anything else you might want to use, even taking the intricate engine you need to haul around to take advantage of them. Not to say that you shouldn’t try and use something else, just that it’s a very real problem.
I’m not a chemist/someone else can offer a more detailed explanation (just love the excuse to post that song), but with most of these kinds of things the energy and advanced equipment required to go in a theoretically plausible direction for a minuscule amount of yield is usually absurd. Including turning iron into gold. (I think it might theoretically be possible to do that at this point as well, but if it is possible I’m sure it’d be astronomically energy intensive and wasteful to manipulate matter to that degree)
How does that work?
For the stuff that doesn't end up as gold you can just keep hitting it with neutrons until it's heavy enough to try again.
So therefore, it would take more energy to free that hydrogen from water than the recovered output would give you - which is fine, as oil is a dense storage of energy, and current technology is geared towards using it. However, it makes more sense to directly utilize the electricity that is expended freeing hydrogen in the first place.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2019.0002...)
https://cen.acs.org/environment/recycling/Amid-controversy-i...
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01652...
The second link is a news article that is very critical about the motivations, projected success, and sneaky language used by companies to justify pyrolisys. And this is coming from what is ostensibly a pro-chemical news source.
The third article is paywalled and I'm guessing 99% of us can't read it. However, the `Opportunities and Challenges` is again academic talk for "we looked into it and it's really really hard".
I found this link while searching the DOI of the third article. Sci-Hub seems to be a site that lets you access all sorts of scientific papers, because they believe everyone rich or poor should have free access to science. It was created by Alexandra Elbakyan, a modern day Robin Hood.
Or so they say, I'd never endorse you reading the paper without giving more money to the multi-billion dollar private publisher Elsevier.
I dont know anything about this so I appreciate the opportunity to learn.
https://youtu.be/njIYHtFmcSs https://youtu.be/TFuTCpCVSbM https://youtu.be/1STaZYZ-P1w etc
So even polyethylene is short about .25 H per C.
Which plastics? The most common ones, polyethylene and polypropylene, which this method is designed to process, are entirely hydrogen and carbon, with no double bonds. I don't dispute that additional hydrogen is necessary to crack the polymers into shorter ones, but your description of plastics does not seem to be completely correct.
polyethelelene -> cycloalkanes doesn't require any additional hydrogen.
This sort of "chrust me, I have kwalifikashuns" is rather fitting the overall poor quality of your comment.
There are a thousand things wrong with this application. Viability of the process is NOT one of them, as already attested in the literature. Refer for example to
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016523701...
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09213...
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31917892/
The reaction boils down to R'-CH₂-CH₂-R" → R'-CH=CH₂ + H-R". It's practically the reversal of the polymerisation that created the plastic on first place. It's specially obvious by the third paper that I've listed as example, since they're generating butadiene and olefins from polyethylene.
It is by no means on the same level as "selling you a way to change Iron into Gold".
>Plastics have very LONG carbon chains, usually with many double bonds, and very little hydrogen
General purpose polymers like polyethylene and polypropylene do not usually have double bonds. Specially not in the main chain (that you need to cleave to get smaller molecules). You'll only get double bonds in the main chain if your monomers had a triple bond in its place, as one of the bonds is broken in the polymerisation. Most monomers however start with a double bond and the resulting polymers have single bonds. Here, let me show it to you:
(...) + R'=R" + R'=R" + (...) → (...) + [·R'-R"·] + [·R'-R"·] + (...) → (...)-R'-R"-R'-R"-(...)
This is common knowledge among chemists.
>That is why, when you heat plastic it decomposes into char -- as in charcoal.
Yeah, because the hydrogens magically disappear. The presence of nearby oxidants (specially one that you, QuackOfAllTrades, should stop consuming, for a better humankind) is totally unrelated.
_____________________
For actual criticism of the application:
You'll get nasty junk oil as output. That oil will have ONE purpose: to be burned down. If you're burning down the oil might as well burn the plastic directly.
This could be solved by fractional distillation... yeah good luck doing it at home.
What happens if some clueless individual tries to recycle PAN? Or even PVC, given how nasty organochlorines are. So there is both health and environmental concerns.
What's the catalyst being used? Plenty catalysts are environmentally nasty.
1KWh/kg is a lot of energy, and it will have an environmental footprint.
It is not trying to sell you a magical device that transforms iron into gold. Instead it is trying to sell you a device that converts good iron into crappy iron, and marketing the crappy iron as if it was more useful than it is.
The carbon without hydrogen produced CO, and it is burned to produce CO2, and that is used to actually heat the mixture.
I'm a PhD chemist. Please consider this: While plastics and oil are both hydrocarbons they have this important difference. Liquid hydrocarbons have short carbon chains and lots of hydrogen. Plastics have very LONG carbon chains, usually with many double bonds, and very little hydrogen.
That is why, when you heat plastic it decomposes into char -- as in charcoal. It is IMPOSSIBLE to produce oil, even theoretically, without adding a source of hydrogen.
A few centuries ago these same fraudsters would be selling you a way to change Iron into Gold.