News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Thursday January 19, 2023 @09:17AM (#34440482)
For the written form, I've always been told to be 100% truthful. During the polygraph though I've had several antagonistic interactions similar to yours. Its all part of the game though at that point. They are trying to get under your skin. My personality does not play well in that scenario. Glad to be out of that line of work now, and I generally say no to anyone asking if I'd be open to having a clearance again.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday January 19, 2023 @10:05AM (#34441047)
Bro, they brought the girl that talked to me on campus to confirm it was me at the polygraph.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by sizzzzlerz on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:04AM (#34441779)
Over my years working for defense contractors, I've held clearences from multiple agencies and have gone through 5 or so polygraph tests. In everyone of them, the examiners were professional in every sense of the word. They clearly explained the procedure, went over what questions were to be asked, and ran the tests calmly and fairly. I never had a reason to complain about any one of them. Now, I didn't like to be tested but it was part of process to get and hold the clearance so I could do my job so I went through it. I never heard of any of my colleagues complain either. Still, every job has its assholes and you were unlucky to encounter one.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:13AM (#34441894)
Thats.... the exact opposite of my experience lol. I was at a 3 letter agency for ~5 years and close to everyone I knew failed the first poly of every round. IMO its a ploy to raise the stakes and get you on edge.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by sizzzzlerz on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:35AM (#34442201)
I wonder if that's because you were working for the agency instead of as a contractor. Since the testing costs the company money, they might get pissed if too many of their employees kept failing and require a retest. For large contractors like LMSC or Raytheon, that can be a sizeable expense. Of course, it goes into the overhead charges when they bill but still, not something they want.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:57PM (#34444064)
Well I was actually military (which is a non full-scope poly) then contractor (full-scope poly) : )
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by Cyberdog on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:06PM (#34444931)
Did they fail the polygraph? Or were they told they failed a sham polygraph in the hopes that they would confess their crimes afterwards? The police do this tactic often; if you are suspected of a crime, never consent to a polygraph not done by a neutral party no matter how not guilty you are, or you will probably "fail."

(Polygraphs are pseudoscientific BS in the first place, but I know there are some cases where you must undergo them for whatever reason.)

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:12AM (#34453368)
Yes, its all part of the game. The failures are real, but the reasons might be BS. In any case, you have to do another poly and now the stakes are higher. Its hard to understand the stress around the process without experiencing it. Passing the poly is a very important step in be able to get/keep your clearance so you can actually work. Otherwise you need a new profession. I miss the work itself but I dont miss the process.

EDIT: I'm not aware of any polys leading to discovering enemies of the state. Its all self-elected information from my understanding, in line with your suggestion.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by sizzzzlerz on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:43AM (#34455693)
You may remember the Aldredge Ames spy case some years back. Supposedly, his CIA polys revealed some strange results but rather call him on it and investigate it further, they shuffled him off to the FBI, still holding his clearances and accesses where he continued to pass classified information to the russians for several more years.

Polys are not the end-all for detecting bad guys but if you choose to ignore it anyway, it certainly becomes useless.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:43PM (#34457714)
I think thats basically an indictment of the system. They are so unreliable that even the practitioners dont believe what it says as a scientific tool.

I hadn't heard of the Ames poly history but I just looked it up and its interesting because apparently he had the same mindset that I do about polys in general [1], and basically when the poly tech said during the interview that they were getting some weird results, he essentially told them the same thing [2] and they were like "yeah youre right" lol.

  [1] - https://sgp.fas.org/othergov/polygraph/ames.html
  [2] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2002/04/16/failure-of-the-polygraph/07c406a5-0aa3-4e20-8dcc-89781162aaa8/
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:13PM (#34458194)
Actually I just found one of the primary sources on this [1]. Its pretty interesting and not what I said above.

In his original 1986 poly, he popped on one question but basically smooth talked his way out of it so it never was something that required followup (i.e. they were sufficiently convinced he was a good guy). In the 1991 poly it gets more interesting because the entire poly was partially a ruse because he was _already under investigation_. Due to timing, the interviewer didn't get coached to dig in on specifics around financial issues, and so they followed a bog-standard interview which Ames passed. The really interesting quote around this is how the postmortum basically says this was a bad poly because they didnt play enough mind games to get him nervous in the first place:

  In its review of the Ames polygraphs, the CIA IG report quotes several current and former polygraph examiners who stated that the Ames case should not be considered to be a polygraph "chart interpretation" problem. Rather, they say, the fundamental problem is that the 1986 and 1991 polygraph charts were invalid because the examiner in each case failed to establish a proper psychological atmosphere in the examination sessions. A former polygrapher noted that without proper preparation, a subject has no fear of detection and, without fear of detection, the subject will not necessarily demonstrate the proper physiological response. Consequently, they surmise, the Ames polygraph tests were invalid because the process was flawed by examiners who had not establish the proper psychological mind set in Ames because they were overly friendly. As a result, Ames's physiological reactions were unreliable.
[1] - https://irp.fas.org/congress/1994_rpt/ssci_ames.htm
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by sizzzzlerz on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:24PM (#34460929)
Interesting because I thought the exam had to follow a script, to the letter. I would have believed that "setting a proper psychological atmosphere" would have showed up at step #1 or #2. Apparently not.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by ActorNightly on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:50AM (#34442461)
I got put in for a poly for one of my older job. Naturally being of a rational mindset, I started googling how to beat a poly.

During the poly, few question in, guy asked me if I ever looked up how to beat a poly. I naturally said yes cause I was startled that this in fact could be one of the questions, which automatically ended the interview.

Thats when I realized that smart people don't work in the government.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by walrus01 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @05:53PM (#34446786)
What if you're being recruited for a counterintelligence job for a 3-letter agency and part of the job definition is being intimately familiar with the details of how persons might attempt to beat a polygraph? That's definitely something a person in that specific field would spend a good deal of time studying.

I guess this is sort of a chicken/egg problem since you can't or won't get hired for the job if you appear too familiar with the workings of the recruitment process. But then if you don't get hired, they might be leaving out one of the better informed candidates.

Anecdotally from the defense contractor industry I've known a number of people who have a whole bookshelf of books on subjects like cold war era espionage, are deeply familiar with some of the most noteworthy moles/spies that were publicly prosecuted and jailed (or north korean, chinese, soviet officers and officials who were just straight out executed with a bullet to the back of the head). It didn't seem to prevent any of them from passing their clearances. Some jobs want to know that you're motivated to learn the subject matter at hand and research its past 60+ years of history.

Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by int_19h on Thursday January 19, 2023 @08:21PM (#34448006)
Polygraphs are very unreliable in general, so this was never anything other than security theater.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by Aeolun on Thursday January 19, 2023 @06:28PM (#34447122)
Hell, I never even had an interview like that (what an insane thing btw), and even I have looked up how to beat a poly at some point. What a silly question.
Re:What not to write on your security clearance form (1988) by JamesSwift on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:21AM (#34453490)
Hehe, plenty of very smart people work in the government. But theres definitely a slice of personalities that dont. You and I both seem to fall in that slice : )

Its so frustrating because from my perspective its like... what do you want me to say/do here? Do you really think a curious person isnt going to look up polys? Am I supposed to deny that I did that? The whole thing is a joke. How many good candidates are we missing that could be working in the public sector just because of this BS filtering?