Re:Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says
by ChrisLTD on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:03AM
(#34436896)
What if self-reflection, agency, or abstract thought aren’t required for intelligence?
Re:Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says
by m00x on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:10AM
(#34436919)
It depends on how you define intelligence, but the most common definition of human intelligence is the ability to have abstract thought.
Intelligence, reasoning and AI are all very loosely defined words, and unfortunately neuroscience hasn't gone far enough to explain a lot of these mechanisms.
We could maybe compare AI to a dog's intelligence, but even then there's a goal system in the dog, and the dog wants to optimize for it (getting treats). LLMs are created to be purely tools, and not reflective or goal-oriented.
The truth is that the model has no intelligence, but can do what we attribute to humans intelligence. Alike to how computers were deemed intelligent by the public for doing fast mathematics, computers still cannot think. There is no self-reflection, agency, or abstract thought.
Also, for readers, this person is often regarded as the equivalent of Michael Jordan (the NBA player) of AI. He's a superstar in the field, so it's safe to take his word with considerable weight.