Re:MSI's (In)Secure Boot
by gruez on Monday January 16, 2023 @07:50PM
(#34407736)
In theory it would make bootkits (ie. malware that installs themselves as the bootloader, thereby being able to compromise/remain undetected for every subsequent step) harder to pull off. It's not part of my threat model though, because if malware made it onto my machine I'd be doing a full wipe. Also, this xkcd is pertinent: https://xkcd.com/1200/
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> Also, this xkcd is pertinent: https://xkcd.com/1200/
Pretty much. The mainframe security model used by desktop OSes is fundamentally broken.
The type of malware secure boot protects against can be made completely undetectable by the running OS and can be made to persist a full wipe.
>and can be made to persist a full wipe.
Are you confusing a bootkit (ie. malware that's in the boot loader) with malware that's in the firmware itself? If it's just in the boot loader, that's still stored on the hdd/ssd itself, and therefore can be wiped.
I said "can be made to persist" and I meant, yes, that the malware could be compromising the firmware. And by "can" I implied that not all of it does, but the possibility of it doing it does exist.
Secure boot is indeed designed to protect against bootkits too.