News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did the Music Business Just Kill the Vinyl Revival? by bayindirh on Monday January 16, 2023 @08:38AM (#34400480)
> If you think the ritual of sitting quietly and listening to music is dead,...

No, I don't think it's dead, and if it's dead, it's not because vinyl is not the dominant format anymore. It's just a catalyst for me, for that atmosphere.

> You said you disagreed, but then you described a gimmick.

As I described elsewhere, vinyl has a unique function for me, and friends I have. So it's not a gimmick, in my book.

> There's nothing about a record that makes you more likely to listen to it with your friends. There's nothing about a CD that says you can't fit it into a pocket in a much larger display envelope.

Some people dig the sound dynamics of the former strongly (which is not me, btw), and I have never seen the latter one.

I can argue all day everyday about how CDs can accommodate much better sound but record labels and the strive for reducing studio costs ruin the format by stone-wall normalizing these things in the name of loudness, and how analog sound paths sound warmer, and you don't need resolution to love some audio, but I have no time for that, at least today. Let's only say that I'm an ex-orchestra player who's listening to both vinyls and CDs for more than 30 years, and know some stuff about sound.

There are no comments on this comment yet.