No, I don't think it's dead, and if it's dead, it's not because vinyl is not the dominant format anymore. It's just a catalyst for me, for that atmosphere.
> You said you disagreed, but then you described a gimmick.
As I described elsewhere, vinyl has a unique function for me, and friends I have. So it's not a gimmick, in my book.
> There's nothing about a record that makes you more likely to listen to it with your friends. There's nothing about a CD that says you can't fit it into a pocket in a much larger display envelope.
Some people dig the sound dynamics of the former strongly (which is not me, btw), and I have never seen the latter one.
I can argue all day everyday about how CDs can accommodate much better sound but record labels and the strive for reducing studio costs ruin the format by stone-wall normalizing these things in the name of loudness, and how analog sound paths sound warmer, and you don't need resolution to love some audio, but I have no time for that, at least today. Let's only say that I'm an ex-orchestra player who's listening to both vinyls and CDs for more than 30 years, and know some stuff about sound.
> I disagree. Because most vinyl listeners (incl. me) doesn't listen it for the sound quality itself.
> The biggest draw in listening vinyl is the experience itself. Large album covers printed with intricate detail, the manual effort you give to cue in the vinyl and changing sides. Adding coffee, tea, a book or a couple of friends into the music itself. The atmosphere all it creates and the experience revolving around is driving the vinyl.
You said you disagreed, but then you described a gimmick.
The only part of what you described that wouldn't work just as well on a CD is changing sides. In fact, they're all things that people actually did with CDs, because CDs were superior to records in every conceivable way, but people still wanted to spend time with their friends. There's nothing about a record that makes you more likely to listen to it with your friends. There's nothing about a CD that says you can't fit it into a pocket in a much larger display envelope.
If you think the ritual of sitting quietly and listening to music is dead, that's because people stopped wanting to do it, not because they stopped buying their music on records.