News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Revisiting KDE by ruph123 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:26PM (#34395682)
I know it is a very unpopular opinion on HN but I don't get KDE. Sure, all applications are super feature-packed, which is mostly a good thing (Konsole, Dolphin, Okular are chef's kiss) but also has its downsides: e.g. that, last time I checked, you cannot have a simple dedicated calendar app like gnome-calendar (or macOS Calendar) but must open the outlook-heavy KOrganizer which comes with mail, contacts, etc. Not really what I want when I just quickly want to check my calendar. But this is just a small annoyance.

What really bothered me though was the UI. All these lines! Everything has an outline. Every UI element has a heavily highlighted outline. It feels super dated and cluttered. But the last time I daily-drove it, I thought "Hey I embrace the KDE life style. I am finally on the right side of the Linux Desktop according to HN and Reddit. Whenever people sh*t on Gnome, one of the big arguments is that you cannot customize it. So I just customize it, make it mine, lets go!"

Well surprisingly the other themes were almost all equally bad or caused inconsistencies. So I went further down the rabbit hole and installed Kvantum. I found a theme that I liked and happily used it for some time. Until I noticed that the theme altered the functionality of KMail. Namely, when tabbing away from KMail, it would select another Email. Super annoying when you want to keep an Email open in the background as a reference while e.g. doing something in your browser. I raised the issue with the Kvantum dev who redirected me to an issue with KDE. I don't remember all the details but it is an issue in KDE and for them it is a wontfix.

So, for me I basically had a similar experience to others here with Gnome. I try to make it work for me until I hit a wall where the maintainers tell me that my use case is not supported by the desktop. So I went back to Gnome. And you know what. I like Gnome. It works for me. It looks nice and is functional. However I don't want or need to convert other happy KDE'ers which is also not the point of my little comment. I don't want to dunk on KDE. It does a lot of cool things, but I just cannot stand the UI. Isn't it great to have choice?

Re:Revisiting KDE by jcelerier on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:30PM (#34395714)
> e.g. that, last time I checked, you cannot have a simple dedicated calendar app like gnome-calendar (or macOS Calendar) but must open the outlook-heavy KOrganizer which comes with mail, contacts, etc. Not really what I want when I just quickly want to check my calendar. But this is just a small annoyance.

Kalendar doesn't cut it? https://apps.kde.org/kalendar/

Re:Revisiting KDE by ruph123 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:39PM (#34396526)
That looks pretty nice. As far as I remember, the last time I used KDE, Kalendar would just open the Calendar view of KOrganizer.
Re:Revisiting KDE by RubyRidgeRandy on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:58PM (#34396623)
I feel the same. The UI to me since plasma has seemed large and awkward whenever I tried it. The default theme is a bit outdated as well. Something with gnome or cinnamon just really does it for me, cinnamon especially.
Re:Revisiting KDE by kombine on Monday January 16, 2023 @04:03AM (#34398518)
I usually shit on GNOME because KDE is technologically better. Qt is undoubtedly superior UI framework which is used far more outside KDE community unlike GTK. I feel that little issues KDE has here and there are mostly the result of it being a second choice in the most popular distros such as Ubuntu or Fedora, and that's another reason I like to shit on GNOME - I think it doesn't deserve to be the face of Linux.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @05:48PM (#34406551)
"Shitting on GNOME" isn't going to solve anything. The people who made it the default in their distros already disagree with you and trash talking isn't going to change their mind. Everyone who's been around has heard all the common complaints before. Just saying "it's technologically better" doesn't even mean anything either. Technologically better at what? There's this myth that you seem to be bought into about how Qt and GTK are fighting against each other or are competing against each other when that's not true. They happily work together and borrow ideas from each other when it makes sense.
Re:Revisiting KDE by tjrDL6MjB2Zwwa on Monday January 16, 2023 @06:52PM (#34407208)
They have a right to express their opinion without needing said expression to have the goal of solving world hunger.

ie, I can complain about the potholes in the street without being the one filling them in.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @07:10PM (#34407359)
That goes both ways my friend. Open source maintainers have a right to dismiss substance-free complaints without needing to prove P = NP.

Complaining about potholes is a great analogy. Repeatedly bringing up the pothole problem at the local swing dancing meetup isn't going to solve anything. You need to actually send your complaints to the transportation office. If they've heard about a particular pothole before then you don't need to bring it up again and keep sending them the same complaints. They already know about it. When they can't fix everything in time then the problem is either bad planning or lack of budget, and louder complaining definitely won't do anything about that.

Re:Revisiting KDE by tjrDL6MjB2Zwwa on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:20AM (#34410277)
shall I repeat myself?

> They have a right to express their opinion without needing said expression to have the goal of solving world hunger.

Just avoid calling someone to task for expressing an opinion that many others hold. They absolutely have the right to express what they don't like about Gnome.

Re:Revisiting KDE by asdajksah2123 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @08:16AM (#34412010)
And the person responding to them also has the right to express their opinion, that the person's opinion they're responding to is a shit opinion, whether or not it solves world hunger.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:02AM (#34414139)
No, I'll continue calling people to task for expressing their opinions poorly or falling back on these bad justifications. Cut that out please, you're doing it now. The guidelines of this forum say you should post "anything that good hackers would find interesting" and it's not interesting to just complain and rant. Even moreso when it's the same boring things we've all heard before like "XYZ sucks" or "I shit on XYZ" like the parent comment was doing. The guidelines also say "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work" and that's what the parent comment was doing too. Please make your comments better than that or don't post here. Make a commitment to be better every day of your life and you won't have to worry about this. No one's asking anyone to solve world hunger, you're falling back on the usual HN hyperbole and snark. So you can just avoid saying that. This is a series of very simple personal steps you can realistically take to improve yourself and improve this forum at the same time.

And maybe I wasn't fully clear the first time. Sure, you have a right to do whatever you want. But that isn't useful way to communicate in a lot of cases. Just put a little bit of thought into it please? Imagine you have a new open source project. Some person comes and makes a complex feature request that will take you years to implement. You ask "why do you need this" so you can try to get to a simpler solution and they respond with "because I have a right to express my opinion." Ok? That's not really answering the question, is it? Now imagine looking at it as an outsider and you can tell how the person refusing to give explanations is the one being stubborn and evasive and stonewalling the discussion. You can't even blame the developer for that at all. This is a public forum, you're not having a casual bullshit conversation with your friends when you comment here.

I'm not trying to be negative here though. I've also seen lots of times here when people expressed their opinions in an engaging way, giving justifications and honest reasoning and useful suggestions. You can do it too, you just have to put in a little bit of effort and listen to the person you're talking to instead of just blindly saying "I have a right to express my opinion" at any opportunity.

Re:Revisiting KDE by tjrDL6MjB2Zwwa on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @04:33PM (#34419577)
I'm ending the conversation here.

You were being unfair, I pointed it out and asked you to try and avoid it in the future, and your response is a multi-paragraph rant about who knows what because it would require that I take the time to read it.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:29PM (#34421604)
No, I wasn't being unfair. If you change your mind, please be honest with yourself and admit you were being unfair by dismissing my whole comment as a "rant about who knows what" without even reading it.
Re:Revisiting KDE by tjrDL6MjB2Zwwa on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#34425981)
The ranting description didn't come into play until you decided to make a post that was 5-6x as large as anything else in the conversation.

your "immediately accuses me of ranting" didn't happen anywhere near immediately and I suggest you do some introspection to better understand why that was your reaction.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:16AM (#34426808)
It's still not a rant. You didn't actually read my comment so you can stop with the characterizations and asking me to introspect, because you've already admitted nothing you say has any relation to what I actually typed.

And yes, it did happen near immediately compared to other comments on this site. Please respond to my actual words next time instead of continuing with these rude, low-effort comments. I try to make my comments more informational and have more depth each time, you're not giving me the same courtesy. If I give a short response people complain they don't understand what I'm talking about. If I give a long response people complain it's too long. If I give a medium response people complain I wasn't convincing enough. So there's just no winning with you folks. This is another case where what you call "complaining" and "expressing opinions" is actually just "trolling" and "making excuses to avoid listening to anyone else's opinion." It's another accusation in a mirror, you need to be doing some introspection and figure out why you're being so evasive.