Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star...
by grishka on Sunday January 15, 2023 @01:16PM
(#34391565)
Everyone used to run unsigned binaries all the time for the entire previous history of computing and somehow the hell didn't break loose. What changed?
> Consumers with the slightest bit of savvy will not run unsigned or self-signed binaries
I'm a "consumer with the slightest bit of savvy" and I despise code signing schemes that care about the signing identity, so you're already wrong. I absolutely will run unsigned and self-signed binaries. I trust myself and my own judgement more than I do anyone else in the entire universe.
Self signing is open to too much abuse. The whole point of signing is that the provenance can be verified (yes, checksums are a thing) and that the signing can be revoked should something bad happen. Notarising code is the process of a third party verifying your identity. So rather than saying, “hey, you can trust me”, you are asking a third party to vet and prove that you are trustworthy. If you can’t see the value in that for all parties - including the most important party, your customers - then that’s up to you. No sane SOC will allow unsigned or self-signed binaries. Consumers with the slightest bit of savvy will not run unsigned or self-signed binaries, and OS vendors need to take care of the rest. Thinking of the Confidentiality, Integrity and Availability triad, your solution is unworkable.