Viral infections sticking around has been known about for a very long time. Chronic infection of Hepatitis C for example occurs in about 80% of those infected and it can be asymptomatic for years while causing liver etc damage.
This includes many viral infections that people don’t realize stick around: “The causative agent for shingles is the varicella zoster virus (VZV) – a double-stranded DNA virus related to the herpes simplex virus. Most individuals are infected with this virus as children which causes an episode of chickenpox. The immune system eventually eliminates the virus from most locations, but it remains dormant (or latent) in the ganglia adjacent to the spinal cord (called the dorsal root ganglion) or the trigeminal ganglion in the base of the skull.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingles
That is, of course, after we did our own GI-MAP and took it to a doctor, not that a doctor would EVER suggest doing that. A naturopath? Yes they do it as a standard.
Standard doctors are operating on 1960's textbooks.
Best doc I ever had was a naturopath. Unfortunately, he tired of dealing with insurance companies and basically retired. Why was he so much better than any other doc I've had? 1) he listened. Appointments were at least 45 minutes. Sometimes over an hour. When I go to an MD I'm lucky to get 10 minutes. 2) He tested. Annual blood tests were extensive (and, yes, could be expensive because of those insurance companies not wanting to cover a lot of stuff) 3) As he listened he was on his laptop pulling up relevant papers ("I was just reading a paper on this topic that came out a couple weeks ago") He'd print out the paper for you and highlight the relevant passages 4) He was interested - by that I mean, I never got the idea he was just going through the motions. He loved this stuff and nerded out on it.
General practitioners refer people to specialists because nobody can keep up with every bit of new research out there. A doctor looking something unusual up isn’t a sign of incompetence but rather best practices.
Based on my extensive experience with doctors and the extensive experience of many others that I know they sure can.
That said you can read up on all the latest research for a condition because you don’t care about all the other research. Doctors can’t get away with such a limited focus.
DirectLabs is a reseller that has a physician on staff that approves your GI Map. So contact direct labs, order the kit, poop and vial it, drop it in the mail, wait 15-20 days. PDF of your results will be in your DirectLabs account online.
Since the process is so mechanical and so stats-driven, I think statistical computer models or even AI would do a much better job of it than your average doctor.
But due to the medical field being slow to utilize new methods, we don't see any of that yet, and the end result is far more people get false diagnoses than would otherwise. We can accept a human making a poor judgement sometimes, but we do not accept a machine doing the same, even if it's right more of the time.
More funding could help, but it’s a harder problem than you might think because training is difficult.
I would suggest that a lot of medical questions are now answered by Dr. Google which implicitly does a lot of behavioral modeling / statistics in their machine learning and is already very successful.
>... Eight independent evaluators with special expertise in the management of meningitis compared MYCIN's choice of antimicrobials with the choices of nine human prescribers for ten test cases of meningitis. MYCIN received an acceptability rating of 65% by the evaluators; the corresponding ratings for acceptability of the regimen prescribed by the five faculty specialists ranged from 42.5% to 62.5%. The system never failed to cover a treatable pathogen while demonstrating efficiency in minimizing the number of antimicrobials prescribed.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/36660...
https://www.jstor.org/stable/3666074
https://aimi.stanford.edu/events/bridging-ais-proof-concept-...
Where did you get your information?
"Long covid" is just propaganda. Decent studies described here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCi9Xpag4FM
Biomarkers by nature can be extremely difficult to track down.
[1]: https://molmed.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s10020-022...
[2]: https://www.webmd.com/covid/news/20230106/researchers-hunt-l...
[3]: https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2022/05/422906/long-covid-blood-ma...
These test are all highly accurate and can easily distinguish between those who have ME/CFS/LongCovid and those who don’t.
Edit: I did forget some; retina capillary test, ACE-2 auto antibodies (though not sure about the accuracy for this one)
https://covid19.nih.gov/covid-19-topics/long-covid
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/long-term-effects/...
You won't though, will you?
Is it this month that the clinical trials end? I will be very curious to see what happens then, as the EUA will end, and thus pharmas liability shield is gone. Will the bullshit be forgotten about? Biden just extended the "emergency", so maybe not.
And to prevent the tiresome "died with Covid, not of it" idiocy, that applies to each and every disease death number. There is no such thing as "dying of a disease" that is separate from "dying with a disease", apart perhaps from cases of violent deaths, such as "shot in the head while infected with Covid" (which are obviously an entirely insignificant minority).
What made covid bad was how transmissible it was, everyone got it more or less.
Once you actually got it though it was about as severe as a flu, in the neighborhood of a bad flu, particularly notable for the age-based outcomes that were very much correlated to age. Plenty of flu variants actually effect young people strongly whereas covid was very much “older is worse”.
In one sense covid was way worse than any old flu after 1918, in the other sense covid is somewhere between an average and bad flu. Your values might determine which is more important to you.
If you were young covid was no big deal, if you were old it was terrifying. This was an odd situation for many diseases.
And you have to be honest covid cases and cause of death are counted differently. There are lots of infections which just aren’t tested which would otherwise have much bigger “cause of death” numbers.
I’m not a denier at all, the problem is facts get distorted to match people’s personal views and often the things you argue against aren’t entirely wrong, if distorted.
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/worlds-deadliest-pandemics-...
To what end?
Have you seen what the WHO are trying to push through? https://jamesroguski.substack.com/p/help-spread-the-word?utm...
I know it's against the guidelines to comment on quality of HN going downhill, so I won't. But if I could...
You did.
I'd suggest just sharing a good paper. Asking somebody where they got their information that something doesn't exist is pointless. You could say the same thing to somebody who doesn't believe unicorns exist; better to just show them a unicorn.
Someone on reddit keeps track of them all:
https://reddit.com/r/LongHaulResearch
also:
Microbiota engraftment from faecal transplants _is_ reliable - it brings along a raft of bacteriophages that clear a niche for the incoming colonies - unlike just slinging some probiotics down your neck and hoping some survive.
Are doctors, as a group, becoming stupider? I’m not trying to troll by asking that question. I legitimately feel, as a patient of a large HMO, that the doctors I interact with aren’t very bright, making frequent mistakes about stuff they could google as quickly as they give out wrong information, but instead confidently insist upon something they’re misremembering or have never learned correctly in the first place. It feels like the profession has been optimizing for the wrong things: quick recall of a breadth of information rather than a scientific orientation towards the work. Perhaps I’m just seeing downstream effects of the reform of health economics in the last decade. Perhaps it’s elite overproduction. In any case reading the featured article, I’m just not at all optimistic about current medical practices experiencing any sort of kuhnian paradigm shift. They can’t even get the basics right, and seem prone to extreme group think bordering on religiosity.
Monday - Friday
- Wake up at 4:30 AM - Get to hospital by 5AM to start rounding on patients - Sometimes work inpatient all day sometimes clinic thrown in, but usually not done working until 7 PM, without even a 15 min break or a chance to eat a meal (15 hour day) - Come home and do about an hour of notes, 16 hour work day - At least once per week, wake up in the middle of the night to deliver a patient who asked for that kind of continuity of care. 24 hour work day
Saturday: - Wake up around 5am to be in by 6am to start the day - Work inpatient, usually without time for a 15min break for food, until 10AM SUNDAY (28-30 hours shift)
Repeat 49 weeks/year (days of 24/hr shift can vary and she usually gets one weekend off/month). Her average time at the hospital last year was 96 hours/week. She is not a resident.
How much confidence do you have that you'd be able to stay up-to-date in your field, or make recommendations that aren't ultra-standard, with this kind of schedule?
Honestly, that makes me agree with the parent comment that the medical profession must be getting stupider to not let a doctor take a break or eat a meal on a 15 hour day.
This leads to higher pay and more work.
A large chunk of their membership is just medical students and residents but thats primarily because they offer good savings to them like study materials.
The AMA does not represent physicians.
That’s in no way bad money, but per hour worked PAs and many nurses make more than that. When I worked IT support I was paid close to that. It doesn’t at all seem worth the pain.
No, it's so the administrative staff can become further bloated as parasites upon the host of the actually productive doctors, and so the shareholders can take whatever breadcrumbs the administrative staff leaves behind.
Speaking for the US, as it has a notorious track record for inefficiencies in its medicinal industry: the USA is getting older (aging population needing more care) with the cost of medical school higher than ever. With this, the production of doctors is unlikely to increase at a pace necessary to maintain levels of care uniformly across the board (for example, rural vs city medicine capabilities vary massively based on region).
Most hospitals attempt to use technology to squeeze more out of their doctors, as getting more doctors isn’t cheap (because there aren’t enough of them). Hospitals can’t do much to solve the doctor production shortage - that involves legislative changes and the American Medical Association (lobbying arm).
The capitalistic effects will compound all of this - but not so much in what you may be describing. If we don’t resolve things, in the medium-term future years we can see a bifurcation in medicine as we see in criminal defense law - the wealthy will have great access to world class healthcare, paid at an extreme premium, and everyone else will be out of luck. (Some would say we are already here there or rapidly approaching this state).
but to your point, studies have shown that handoffs kill patients. if you've got 18 people on a floor, each shift you hand off to has a statistically significant chance of screwing up one of them. So if there are 3 shift changes a day there are potentially 3 might-screw-you-up-bad rolls of the dice.
putting people on 12- or 24-hour sifts is crazy, but the sleep deprivation kills less than the shift change mistakes.
>Are doctors, as a group, becoming stupider?
Worse yet, experienced people in these professions tend to defend the insane schedules, which I take for some sort of hazing ritual / Stockholm syndrome.
In the UK medical professionals are doing the sensible thing, and leaving the profession. I'm sure most of them would much rather stay, but they're making the rational choice as individuals.
That's not the best choice for patients as a group though.
There's a serious under-staffing, under-pay and conditions crisis.
>If you're so smart why are you poor?
Intelligence has nothing to do with power or leverage in a situation
But that’s what I was trying to suggest by saying that it seems the medical field, as a whole, seems to be optimizing for the wrong thing, viz. quantity over quality. As others note, there are clearly economic forces at play, and maybe too much constraint on the supply side. And it’s not clear to me that any reasonable discussion is occurring with respect to that. And so I reiterate my pessimism that we’ll somehow get from where we at currently, to a brighter future brought about by a kuhnian revolution as hinted at in the original article. We need to fix what’s broken before adding new features, to put it in software terms.
Anyway, thank you for taking the time to share this.
Unless the schedule was always like this. Then it wouldn’t explain them getting stupider.
I think this is an area where technology can help. The best primary care providers I've had have been the ones who aren't afraid to look things up as we're talking about them. I think better tools to aggregate the cutting edge of medical knowledge would help greatly.
I don't think they're becoming stupider, but I think the information age is making their errors more accessible and obvious to the general public.
I think this quote really sums up this issue, and it's history:
Knowledge isn’t a commodity, especially not a fungible commodity, as the medical business sees it. Consciousness and culture are part of the life process. It is exactly the commoditization of medical knowledge that makes it dangerous, and generally stupid. Doctors buy their knowledge, and then resell it over and over; it’s valuable as a commodity, so its value has to be protected by the equivalent of a copyright, the system of laws establishing the profession. Without its special status, its worthlessness would be quickly demonstrated. When A.C. Guyton wrote his textbook of medical physiology (the most widely used text in the world) in the 1950s, it was trash; as it was studied and applied by generations of physicians, it was still trash. The most compliant patients who bought their treatment from the most authoritative, Guytonesque, doctors were buying their own disability and death.
Each time you learn something, your consciousness becomes something different, and the questions you ask will be different; you don’t know what the next appropriate question will be when you haven’t assimilated the earlier answers. Until you see something as the answer to an urgent question, you can’t see that it has any value. The unexpected can’t be a commodity. When people buy professional knowledge they get what they pay for, a commodity in a system that sustains ignorance.
-Ray Peat [1]
[1] https://raypeatinsight.wordpress.com/2013/06/06/raypeat-inte...
That said, if I had to do that 20x per day with only 20 minutes allotted per patient, I can’t imagine I’d be very good at diagnosis either.
My feeling is they are hiding behind the "I'm the expert here" thing because they are actually self conscious about how little they know, and are worried it will show if they engage in a discussion.
Scientists/researchers advance the state of our medical knowledge and doctors, over subsequent generations, absorb what they find and practices slowly change. But there’s always a lag. What we need to get past is the notion that doctors are some font of truth when it comes to medical information. They are, largely, a snapshot of what was conventionally believed at the time they graduated med school. We don’t have a system that effectively updates their knowledge or keeps them in the loop for cutting-edge research. They do learn a set of first principles that can help them reason about novel situations better than a lay person, but only if the right answer is one that follows from those principles as opposed to being counterintuitive.
It’s the nature of being a practitioner rather than a researcher.
That's not true... generally, in order to practice doctors must be licensed, and in order to keep their license they must have annual continuing education. Generally accomplished by attending conferences where the latest research results are presented.
The details vary but the system does exist.
I think patients are getting smarter, and conditions for doctors are worse causing some intelligent people to choose different fields. That said, I recently went through a major illness and interacted with many medical professionals. My first hand experience/anecdata is that doctors are just like every other professional. Some are good, some are mediocre. Some are so consumed by hubris they believe the public is always wrong, and Some are willing to talk things through and keep an open mind about everything, even if it is ridiculous.
The best thing we could do for healthcare is to remove the idea that "doctor knows best." While it is important for doctors to feel confident, and to teach the public to avoid snakeoil, it just places unreal expectations on these people. If patients took more accountability for their own health, then we could loosen some of the malpractice laws, and doctors insurance premiums would go down, and that would in turn cause rates to go down. But that was a bit of a tangent from my point that doctors are just people, maybe with an average intelligence that is slightly above the population at large, but still just people.
Sure, but outside of surgeons and the ER, most doctors are not making life or death decisions all too often. Your average family medicine doctor should always be presenting multiple options for care, and be honest with the patient and themselves that they may be wrong about the diagnosis. I know some people dislike so-called weasel words, but doctors should be using them regularly.
One of them, who was the shoulder specialist ironically (he should have nailed the diagnosis as TOS), looked at my hand X-Rays, said there is no arthritis, then did a test on me to that I said hurt, and then diagnosed me with arthritis. I’m 27. It borders on malpractice and at the very least should be considered gross negligence.
And they were all in a big hurry. I had to stop all of them on their way out of the examination room to ask my questions!
I’ll add that all three ortho docs did those “provocative tests” for CTS, like bending my wrists, and NONE made my symptoms worse. This alone should have been an indicator that the nerve impingement was happening closer to the spine. Meanwhile, the provocative tests for TOS almost immediately and drastically worsened my symptoms.
Sort of like how I would be surprised if I interviewed a developer who didn't know what an array was.
None of the surgeons or neurologist did Eden’s or Adson’s or any other TOS test. I didn’t learn about TOS until the third doc, but she immediately dismissed it because “TOS is very rare” and “it would have shown on the nerve conduction study”- though the NCS wasn’t done above my elbow, and anyway studies out there say NCS only shows nerve damage, not so much nerve impingement.
I googled my symptoms for months, and only found TOS after exhausting literally every other nerve impingement disorder from the hand to the spine. Google results are very prejudiced to carpal tunnel syndrome and tendinitis.
I’d heard stories from people who would go to various doctors and say they were all quacks. I always thought “hey, these guys went to MEDICAL SCHOOL, what do you know about any of this stuff?”, but now I’m more in their camp.
Anyway… Good posture is very important fellas! Having ergonomic everything doesn’t matter if your posture is poor.
1. Doctors are not the same are researchers in many or most cases. They are more akin to technicians than scientists. In the same way I wouldn't expect my electrician to meaningfully innovate the way that he hooks up my house to the power grid or I wouldn't expect my plumber to fundamentally shift my city's sewer system to better serve my individual house that simply isn't their job as front line folks administering care.
2. I think we are massively overlooking simply the breadth and depth of the changes in the world and how that affects their profession. We are exposed to a staggering and exponentially increasing amount of chemicals, environmental toxins, pollutants, foods, and their patients come from a variety of different ethnic backgrounds and live in wildly different environments with wildly different lifestyles. I have to imagine 100 years ago if you were a doctor in say Ireland, you mostly knew what your patients did for work, what they ate, they all lived in roughly the same area, etc. The variables of health were simply much less.
3. The same time the amount of diseases / disorders / etc. that we've identified has grown exponentially. When the field of things that it could be even if that was an incomplete list (obviously) it was much easier to give a broad diagnosis than a specific one. This has improved treatment to be sure but also demanded specialization so any one doctor having all the answers gets less likely over time.
4. Lastly it's just financial pressures. Markets and especially insurance is part of this but I think in general as globalization has continued to accelerate and resources are being distributed more and more in some sense (and concentrated in other senses) you have to take a holistic view. You say doctors used to be "better" but better where? If all the doctors are in a handful of countries with most of the resources that sub group of people will yes get better care but what about everyone else?
People do stupid things! I observe and wonder how can call us intelligent species! For example, I see the following scenarios:
- only some people in a family wear masks in a closed space.
- people wear a mask inside but take it off to eat or sometimes talk to others.
- people talk in each other face outside, but wear masks inside.
- people wear surgical masks without any certification (such as ASTM) and wear the same masks for days (you can tell from how dirty their masks are) - not only they are not protected from COVID-19, but they can bring bacteria, fungi, and microplastics straight into their lungs!
I do not participate in circuses - if I do something, I do it properly, and in a meaningful way! XBB.1.5 is as contagious as measles, i.e. it's the most infectious virus known to science! And new variants could go beyond the r0 of measles soon (r0 has only being going up so far)! You cannot act the same way as this is the flu with a much lower basic reproductive number, which is very-well studied, has decent antivirals, yet still kills a lot of people and costs trillion dollars to the global economy each year!
A lot of microbiome research is leading to particular bacteria in or missing from the gut being correlated with various diseases like diabetes and obesity and almost all chronic diseases have a corresponding microbiome adjustment. We don't know yet know if there is a cause here or its just correlated but its a potential diagnostic that shows long before more serious symptoms and could potentially be used diagnostically one day. Or it might be these shifts are causal and we need to find a way to restore gut function that works well and reliably.
The fundamental idea is becoming mainstream in research with significant labs working on this for Long Covid, ME/CFS as well as EDS across the globe. Its not a fringe idea in research looking at long neglected diseases and the more they look the more they find evidence for it. Its not something the vast majority of doctors would have any knowledge on today, most would consider it ridiculous despite thousands of papers on this topic with growing evidence for the fundamental idea of ongoing infections causing increasing problems.