Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by SamBam on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:46AM
(#34368393)
I actually find the graph confusing because they don't label what the other gray and dashed lines are. Are they just multiple estimates that Exxon made, and dashed lines are simply another shade of gray?
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:56AM
(#34368548)
That's an interesting example of what could be a social media dark pattern, to initially link to a less informative (since no graph) article on the [timely thing], and dismiss a later post linking to more informative (with striking graph) coverage, as a duplicate.
Or maybe we are being 'led down the garden path' here, since the graph varies subtly from Supran's.
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:14AM
(#34367996)
I just saw a new dark pattern. After viewing this 'Exxon' article on phys.org, I clicked to read another phys.org piece, which came up with a google ad blocking view of it, where the only 'close the ad' option was to "give feedback to Google" about it, so I punched "not interested" and it went away. The catch: it was an ad for something in a category that I am quite interested in.
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:31AM
(#34368201)
(It looks like the better choice, "ad covered content", was present, but I'd overlooked it because it was leftmost in the options, which were presented horizontally, which seems to be harder for my eyes to parse.)
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:41AM
(#34368321)
Another misleading UI display, here in the comments: viewed on Android in desktop view, if I want to upvote a comment I'm tempted to click the "upvote" icon closest to the comment, but that one is actually for the next comment.
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @12:17PM
(#34370736)
And an observation: if an urge to fix broken stuff is part of your character, someone malicious can do a denial-of-service attack by throwing broken stuff in your path. This is unfortunate. I'd like to know how to fix it.
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by thimkerbell on Friday January 13, 2023 @12:13PM
(#34370676)
(this 'dark pattern' stuff is an aside that I felt ok about putting in a comment here since the substantive discussion about the newly published 'exxon knew' paper was not here, it was happening on another HN post (or perhaps more than one).)
Re:New study puts a number on what 'Exxon knew' decades ago ...
by mjburgess on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:54AM
(#34368519)
Is blaming Exxon anything more than scapegoating?
I'm not exactly sure what counter-factual history Exxon is supposed to have enabled, if it had taken a stand against its own interests: are we to believe that the last 50 years of fossil fuel use would have been different?
All people are partisan to their own interests; there is nothing wrong with this, and much good about it.
Non-partisan institutions require independent funding, and are therefore largely to be provided by the state.
Unless I'm missing something, I find all this finger-pointing largely scapegoating theatrics.
the other ones is about if Exxon knew. this one is about the impact of their actions.
And [1] is from this post.
From the other HN post:
> The study published [this] Thursday in the journal Science looked at research that
> Study lead author Geoffrey Supran ...
> The Exxon-funded science was "actually astonishing" in its precision and accuracy, said study co-author Naomi Oreskes ...
[1] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abk0063 | Assessing ExxonMobil’s global warming projections G. Supran https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3846-1633 , S. Rahmstorf https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6786-7723, and N. Oreskes
(I spent most of my time oogling at the graph.)
Or maybe we are being 'led down the garden path' here, since the graph varies subtly from Supran's.
I'm not exactly sure what counter-factual history Exxon is supposed to have enabled, if it had taken a stand against its own interests: are we to believe that the last 50 years of fossil fuel use would have been different?
All people are partisan to their own interests; there is nothing wrong with this, and much good about it.
Non-partisan institutions require independent funding, and are therefore largely to be provided by the state.
Unless I'm missing something, I find all this finger-pointing largely scapegoating theatrics.