News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by dark-star on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:50PM (#34362009)
My favorite theory is that the universe is finite, some sort of (hyper)sphere or -torus. If we could just look far enough out there we would see our own galaxy

What would be even cooler is if it was warped like a moebius strip in a higher dimension, so that when we look out there, everything is mirrored from "our" reality :-D

Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by delecti on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:16PM (#34362255)
That first theory would be interesting, but wouldn't it be basically impossible to prove unless the finite repeating universe were also pretty small? We see distant objects as they were in the past, and I'm not sure we'd recognize our own galaxy a billion years ago and a billion light years away.

It's actually an interesting thought experiment. If that theory were true, and assuming we could see ourselves face-on (rather than edge-on), then I wonder how far away and far back could we recognize ourselves.

Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by dark-star on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:26PM (#34362333)
Yeah, I realize we're looking in the past and can't "see" ourselves (probably not even our own galaxy, depending how far out we have to look). But I guess the theory in itself is not any more "weird" or "outlandish" as the idea of an infinite universe.

And maybe if we actually look both ways, we could find another galaxy that could be proven to be the same (because of some particularly remarkable stars/quasars/supernovae etc. in them). Who knows, maybe the universe is smaller than we think and we just don't recognize the "same" galaxies on different images because they are billions of years apart?

Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by heisenzombie on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:17PM (#34363159)
from:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe

If space were infinite (flat, simply connected), perturbations in the temperature of the CMB radiation would exist on all scales. If, however, space is finite, then there are those wavelengths missing that are larger than the size of the space. Maps of the CMB perturbation spectrum made with satellites like NASA's WMAP and the ESA's Planck have shown a striking amount of missing perturbations at large scales. The properties of the observed fluctuations of the CMB show a 'missing power' on scales beyond the size of the universe. That would imply that our universe is multiply-connected and finite. The spectrum of the CMB fits much better with the universe as a gigantic three-torus, a cosmos connected to itself in all three dimensions.[11]

Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by satvikpendem on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:35PM (#34363290)
You should read the short story The Tower of Babylon by Ted Chiang who also wrote Stories of Your Life, the inspiration for the movie Arrival.
Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by jadbox on Friday January 13, 2023 @02:28AM (#34364896)
That was one of my favorite stories and certainly relevant to the theories here.
Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by deepsun on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:37PM (#34363668)
That assumes that we can somehow see through time, which leads to a whole bunch of inconsistencies (aka time travel paradoxes). There's no way to look through large distances without looking back in time, unfortunately.
Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by nine_k on Friday January 13, 2023 @06:27AM (#34366388)
I don't see how seeing one's past may lead to paradoxes. Meddling withthe past would still be impossible, due to the,distance and the speed of light limit. What am I missing?
Re:The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early ... by Cthulhu_ on Friday January 13, 2023 @03:49AM (#34365386)
For all we know it might be - or it might actually be infinite - but the trouble is that we're limited by what we can see / detect, which is in turn limited by the speed of light.

Another commenter asked something like, what if the universe is much bigger than the observable universe, because everything beyond that 'border' has redshifted out of reach - or hasn't reached us yet / never will, because it's moving away faster than the speed of light.