News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by mschuster91 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:49PM (#34359325)
Surprise, surprise. And yet, Big Oil continued to launch campaigns designed to deflect responsibility from companies and governments away to individual consumers, like BP's "carbon footprint" [1].

When will those responsible be held accountable for helping to advance the destruction of climate and the immense loss of life and property that climate change has brought?

How can we explain to our children and grandchildren why we did nothing to hold them accountable?

[1] https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sh...

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by nickersonm on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:02PM (#34359498)
Yet these companies aren't the ones actually burning the oil, are they? They merely sell the product which others then burn. How can you hold only them responsible but excuse the parties further downstream?
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by acdha on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:31PM (#34359861)
Because those aren't unrelated: it'd be one thing if they just sold oil, but they're behind campaigns deceiving the public about the true cost of using it and encouraging additional consumption. People today are buying new trucks and SUVs which get worse mileage than the 1980s did in part because there's been this well-funded anti-science propaganda campaign and many efforts to hide the true costs.

Put more succinctly, they deserve blame because they chose lies when confronted with an inconvenient truth.

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by nickersonm on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:44PM (#34359994)
If oil companies have been campaigning specifically to deceive customers about the potential harms those customers may cause, then that should be what they are "held responsible" for. Trying to make them responsible for harms others caused using their products is rather orthogonal to that, and doesn't bolster arguments criticizing them.

Tangentially, while some vehicles presumably have worse mileage than a comparably-sized vehicle from the 1980s, fuel efficiency has significantly increased since 2005 (after a small decrease from 1985-2005) while supporting continuously increasing power and weight [0]:

In the two decades prior to 2004, technology innovation and market trends generally resulted in increased vehicle power and weight (due to increasing vehicle size and content) while average new vehicle fuel economy steadily decreased and CO2 emissions correspondingly increased. Since model year 2004, the combination of technology innovation and market trends have resulted in average new vehicle fuel economy increasing 32%, horsepower increasing 20%, and weight increasing 4%.

[0] https://www.epa.gov/automotive-trends/highlights-automotive-...

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by acdha on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:52PM (#34360074)
> Tangentially, while some vehicles presumably have worse mileage than a comparably-sized vehicle from the 1980s,

There's a challenge here: people have been encouraged to buy larger vehicles. A small car will have better mileage now but the kind of vehicle the average person is commuting to work in now is much larger than it was three decades ago. I would argue that this is in part due to the successful campaign which fossil fuel companies funded to reverse conservation wins of the late 70s & early 80s. It wasn't just them but they had a significant role in shaping the political and social discourse (e.g. promoting gas guzzling as a macho thing).

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by nickersonm on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:16PM (#34360345)
Thanks for your civil engagement on what is often a contentious topic.

While not a perfect representation of purchases, I believe the EPA chart (Fig. ES-3) I referred to shows the average of all for-sale models for a given year, so this should capture the increasing preference for larger vehicles. Indeed, the horsepower and curb weight are shown as significant increases, even while fuel efficiency is improving (≥2005). It looks to me like the average fuel efficiency passed the 1985 peak (presumably driven by the 1970s oil crises) around 2007.

Clearly two decades of decreasing efficiency was not ideal, but I posit it may be the 1985-2005 period which you are mostly remembering. Going by the chart there was a fast shift to smaller and 'weaker' cars for highly increased efficiency 1970-1975, after which there was a slow continuous increase of power and weight - first occasioning a slow but relatively small decline in efficiency (compared to the 1970-1975 increase), but then changing to increasing efficiency as that became a more important factor for consumers.

Relatedly, while I am certainly not the target audience for the kind of advertisements that may encourage people to purchase more oil-based products, I cannot recall seeing any automotive advertising that wasn't clearly produced by a specific vehicle manufacturer. It sounds like you are suggesting 2nd and 3rd tier advertising by fuel companies for reversing the 1970-1975 reduction in consumption, but I'm not familiar with that space - I would appreciate it if you could direct me to any resources you have about that.

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by acdha on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:34PM (#34361826)
> I cannot recall seeing any automotive advertising that wasn't clearly produced by a specific vehicle manufacturer.

You're right — what I was thinking about wasn't that the Exxon was running ads saying you should buy an F-350 for your grocery shopping but the more subtle long-term stuff: pouring millions of dollars into funding the people who say climate change is a hoax (meaning fewer people feel guilty about 10mpg), turning that into a litmus test for politicians so the same people in office are also receptive to continuing exemptions from pollution laws, etc. The blame is wider than them I think it's important to separate out unknowing mistakes from deliberate attempts to delay action after you know there's a problem.

There's also an interesting split here: until about a decade ago, the interests of the oil and car companies were perfectly aligned. Now that EVs are popular, however, that's diverging and I'm curious what the political realignment will look like — Ford won't be backing transit or high-density housing but they'd be totally cool running ads about how their latest Mustang can be powered by American wind farms.

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by sli on Friday January 13, 2023 @12:47AM (#34364384)
You would be right if they didn't lobby against e.g. public transit. As it is right now, especially in the US, many people are forced by circumstance and lobbying to own and maintain a car, and usually it's an ICE car. Acting like they are blameless because millions and millions of people have no choice in the matter is just wildly disingenuous.
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by iamsaitam on Friday January 13, 2023 @05:07AM (#34365867)
You're missing the point. Their impact on the subject is much greater than simply making oil products available. They pushed a narrative that aligned with their self interests at the same time it was detrimental to the world. They did this through various means, including press/media and lobbying. The world of energy production could be very different from what it is today if they didn't act only on their self interest. Actions were taken much later due to their misinformation. In my view, the decision makers should pay heavily for what they did.
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by TinyRick on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:55PM (#34359405)
> When will those responsible be held accountable for helping to advance the destruction of climate and the immense loss of life and property that climate change has brought?

When it is no longer profitable to destroy the climate.

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:55PM (#34359395)
>When will those responsible be held accountable

You have sown the revolving door and now you reap its harvest.

Nobody will be held to account so long as the institutions that would be doing the holding have a massive overlap in relevant skills, subject matter and therefore, personnel (especially at the management levels where these sorts of decisions get made).

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by mschuster91 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:57PM (#34359420)
"You"? I was born in 1991, my generation certainly didn't invent that crap, that was all during the reign of the Boomers - who, to add insult to injury, keep occupying positions of power instead of resigning and retiring to let those rise who will actually have to live on this wreck of a planet the next fifty to seventy years (assuming no major war gets us all killed).
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:01PM (#34359482)
> I was born in 1991, my generation certainly didn’t invent that crap, that was all during the reign of the Boomers

The described problem is much older than the Boomers period of political dominance. For some reason, Millenials seem to think that “Boomers” are “everyone who existed before the Millenials”.

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by layer8 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:18PM (#34360371)
I’m pretty sure a similar subset within the younger generations will end up doing the same.
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:47PM (#34361979)
"The people of the past were stupid, this time we have modern knowledge, modern ideology, modern science, there is no way we will make the same mistakes as prior generations."

-what people about to repeat history say

Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by anigbrowl on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:53PM (#34363421)
Who are you addressing here with 'you'?
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by maeil on Friday January 13, 2023 @03:48AM (#34365375)
They never will be held responsible because the public does not support doing so. It only supports working inside the existing system of law, which has not and will not hold them accountable. Anything outside of this system is deemed morally unacceptable.
Re:Revealed: Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate pr... by Beltalowda on Friday January 13, 2023 @05:26AM (#34365988)
Everyone deflects responsibility to everyone else.

Consumers say government should do something or that businesses should change their ways. Businesses say what they're doing is legal and merely catering to consumer demand. Government says businesses should "self-regulate" or consumers should choose different.

You see this pretty much everywhere, from climate change to those ridiculous SUVs that are a danger to everyone to basic animal welfare in food production, etc.