News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by AmericanChopper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:21AM (#34350261)
Most of the fault in this video seems attributable to the other motorists. I was always taught that it was my responsibility to ensure that I have enough following distance, and am paying close enough attention, to stop if the car in front of you abruptly stops. Is this not the case in California? Because the first car seems at least partially at fault in this respect, and every other contributor to the pile up is significantly at fault.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by prmoustache on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:45AM (#34350404)
This is mostly applicable if there is no sudden lane change. True you should always keep a safe enough distance for you to react and brake in any case with the car in front of you. If that car was too close on another lane, switch to yours and brake simultaneously this is a bit different.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mtsr on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:16AM (#34350616)
The whole scenario would look very similar if the Tesla was a car suffering from a breakdown and moving to the safest lane it can reach safely. In such a case we would also expect other drivers to pay enough attention to prevent an accident like this...
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by throwaheyy on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:36AM (#34356205)
No, it wouldn’t in a breakdown situation in any other car, the driver would try to pull over to the right.

Most drivers gain an instinct to passing slower/stopped objects on the left, and a natural aversion to passing them on the right.

The Tesla pulled over and stopped in the far left lane. No “space” was left to pass it.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mtsr on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:10PM (#34356923)
It's either changing 3 lanes to the right or 1 to the left. In case of loss of control, in this case with the car coming to a stop very quickly, it might be better heading for the left lane, instead of getting stuck in the middle or second lane from the right.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by AmericanChopper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:49AM (#34350429)
The first car to collide with the Tesla is least at fault, but obviously still partially at fault. None of the other cars in the pileup have that excuse though.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by ht85 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:06AM (#34350551)
Was the first car speeding? If not, how were they at fault?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by AmericanChopper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:18AM (#34350625)
It’s almost impossible to rear-end another car without being at least partially at fault. The lane change from the Tesla was obviously dangerous, but the first car to collide with it had sufficient warning and time to react. You can see that they did react, but they obviously didn’t expect the Tesla to come to a full stop, which is why the first collision took place. I believe the legal term for this is contributory negligence.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by dmitriid on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:31AM (#34350716)
It takes humans up to 5 seconds to even start breaking in the presence of danger.

Even at 40 miles per hour your speed is 58 feet per second (or, at 60kmh you speed is 16 meters per second).

So it's either "the driver had sufficient warning" or "the lane change from Tesla was dangerous". As you don't expect cars that are dangerously changing to suddenly slow down.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jiriro on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:56AM (#34350869)
5 seconds is nonsense.

The average driver’s reaction time is 0.2 to 0.3 seconds. This is before the driver’s foot moves.

Then there is approx 1 second before the brakes take effect (foot movement, applying the force, brakes responding)

So 1.5 second before the car starts breaking.

There is a rule of “be at least 2 seconds behind the car in front” which gives a safe distance to handle any emergency braking.

Of course everything depends on driver’s and car’s conditions.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by dmitriid on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:00AM (#34350905)
Sweden has the rule of "at least 3 seconds". Because you keep ignoring the speed, and the braking distance as well. Edit: and assuming perfect conditions when the driver is perfectly alert and looking ahead. And is young and healthy. And...

However you count, if Tesla did a dangerous lane change and started braking, how is this the fault if the driver behind?

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by AmericanChopper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:48AM (#34351292)
You seem to be missing a couple of point here.

1. Fault in an accident can be spread across every party that was involved, and no matter how negligent one part was, that has no influence over how negligent every other party also potentially was.

2. A driver is typically responsible for being aware of all potential hazards on the road, not just the ones immediately ahead in the same lane. For instance a car that has started indicating to move into their lane from another lane (as this Tesla did ~7 seconds before the collision), and a car in their lane that is coming to a stop (this Tesla had completed the lane change pretty much 3 seconds before the collision).

Obviously the Tesla is really pushing the limits of what would be considered a safe gap, and coming to a stop in that location without a proper reason is obviously negligently dangerous. But the negligence of both parties contributed to this accident, regardless of who was most at fault.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smaudet on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:11AM (#34353706)
It's absolutely not nonsense, I suggest taking some basic high-school physics. Reaction time is the time for the vehicle to come to a stop, not for the driver to first notice an issue.

At 60 mph it will take many meters and seconds to deaccelerate, assuming the driver can take exactly the correct action:

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=time+to+brake+at+70+met...

Estimate here is about 4 seconds, under perfect conditions. 5 seconds is more than reasonable, considering you also need to realize the other driver is acting erroneously.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by frumper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:45AM (#34355214)
he said 5 seconds to START braking
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smaudet on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:16PM (#34358005)
I did not interpret their comment that way. That would be unreasonable, however their comment included mention of physical break distance, so I'm pretty certain they didn't mean actual human response time and instead how long it takes for a human to respond and slow the car, which is the metric of interest here. Even for a robot with millisecond response times, you will be breaking in the multiples of seconds, not instantaneously. Observation "reaction time" really is completely irrelevant here.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by frumper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:36PM (#34358315)
> It takes humans up to 5 seconds to even start breaking in the presence of danger.

That seems pretty clear. 5 total seconds is really reasonable. 5 seconds before you start is silly.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mikestew on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:51AM (#34355320)
Reaction time is the time for the vehicle to come to a stop

You seem to have your terminology confused. Reaction time doesn’t even necessarily have anything to do with driving. I suggest a quick web search next time before assigning people remedial physics.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smaudet on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#34358082)
And I suggest you look into the concept of contextual terminology
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jjav on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:09AM (#34355650)
> Reaction time is the time for the vehicle to come to a stop, not for the driver to first notice an issue.

No, reaction time means the time from noticing the need to brake to the time brake pressue is getting applied.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smaudet on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#34358068)
I disagree - reaction time is commonly referring to the reaction time of the vehicle in these events, the propensity of software devs to treat everything like a video game non-withstanding.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by meindnoch on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:39AM (#34351222)
5 seconds?? Lol. Maybe if the driver is 86 years old.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by misnome on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:11AM (#34350989)
I overtake you, the instant my car is 1m in front of yours I switch into your lane and hard break.

Who is at fault for you crashing into the back of me?

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by progman32 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:53AM (#34351341)
Key word is "almost". Perhaps this is a situation where the fault is primarily with the overtaking car. However, an attentive driver should have started braking as soon as the illegal lane change was started.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by numpad0 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:18AM (#34351529)
You, UNLESS THERE ARE CLEAR EVIDENCES THAT PROVE YOUR INNOCENCE, like there are in this case and there will be in such cases(like skid marks).

The fact that the trailing driver is USUALLY found at fault it is just philosophical razors applied to situations without enough evidences. Generalizing that into "trailing drivers are always at fault" is disingenuous, partisan and malicious.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by matwood on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:28AM (#34352494)
You're describing the exception situation that has led to many drivers to install dashcams.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by davidcbc on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:40AM (#34353296)
Changing lanes and then slamming on the brakes means you are 100% at fault (assuming there is evidence). It's the most common car insurance scam and it is completely indistinguishable from what the Tesla did in this case
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by AmericanChopper on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:57AM (#34353506)
Breaking down is also completely indistinguishable from what the Tesla did in this case. The breaks weren’t slammed on either, 7 seconds elapsed between the Tesla indicating for the turn and the collision. It’s very obvious that every participant in the pile up was at least partially at fault. The only confounding factor in this case seems to be that many HN commenters lose a handful of IQ points when any topic relating to Elon Musk comes up.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by ryanwaggoner on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:43AM (#34355185)
I applaud your self awareness
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by davidcbc on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:15PM (#34357993)
The video of the accident[1] clearly shows the Tesla start hitting its brakes 4 seconds in, the car that eventually rearends it is a few car lengths behind and in the left lane and hits its own brakes less than a second later and the accident occurs less than 4 seconds later.

Taking into account reaction times, it takes approximately 5-6 seconds to bring a car going 60mph to a complete stop[2][3] The accident was completely unavoidable for the car that rearends the Tesla because the Tesla made an extremely dangerous maneuver

[1] https://theintercept.com/2023/01/10/tesla-crash-footage-auto... [2] https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/vehicle_stopping_distance_and_ti... [3] https://www.edmunds.com/driving-tips/keep-your-braking-dista...

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by b4je7d7wb on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:29AM (#34350703)
>Is this not the case in California?

I don't think it is. I've never felt so unsafe in traffic as driving on highways in california. People keep an order of magnitude too little distance to the car in front. That density of cars would make any european highway slow down to a crawl but there they just practically touch eachother while driving 60kmph while doing crazy lane shifts left and right.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jjav on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:01AM (#34355515)
> I was always taught that it was my responsibility to ensure that I have enough following distance, and am paying close enough attention, to stop if the car in front of you abruptly stops.

Brake testing (suddenly braking hard for no reason, what the Tesla did here) has always been a cause for the leading car to be the guilty party when they get rear ended.

In times prior to dashcams, it was difficult to prove the car ahead did brake to cause the accident, so the rule of thumb was the rear car is probably guilty. But if there was a way to show the lead car did brake, they're guilty.

Nowadays with dashcams, it's a lot easier to prove, so brake testers don't get away with it as much.