News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by rob74 on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:24AM (#34339440)
An induction cooker may be more efficient, but if you're burning gas (or coal) to generate electricity to then operate an electric stove, it's more efficient to burn the gas directly in the stove.
Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by unethical_ban on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#34339672)
Literally, with no context, externalities, and in a lab setting, you are correct.

With the broader societal goal of "never burn fossil fuels when an alternative exists" and "never have to build new infrastructure for residential gas again", it becomes clear we should move away from residential fossil fuel consumption. We must work to cutover individual tools from fossil to electric, and in parallel work to cutover electric generations from fossil to renewable.

The same principle applies to vehicles. I don't care that the electricity for a Tesla comes from coal today - it soon won't.

I hear the rebuttal "ICE engines are very inefficient but a gas burner is different". Yes, but the replacement need is the same, and on the timeframe that people buy large appliances, it would be best if people moved to electric ASAP.

---

That all said, from an air quality concern perspective, I agree the focus should be on proper venting. It is disgusting to me that so few houses and almost no apartments have true external venting for bathrooms and kitchens - why this was done in houses 50 years ago but not today should be an embarrassment to every homebuilder outfit.

Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by pitaj on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:33AM (#34339546)
Burning gas on a stovetop burner is nowhere near as capable of extracting energy from the resulting heat as a gas turbine power plant or even a modern furnace.
Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by lmz on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:29AM (#34339490)
Doesn't that depend on the delivery mechanism? City gas would be fine but LPG tubes would probably use up more fuel in transport vs existing power lines.
Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by cmcconomy on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:29AM (#34339496)
I imagine there is also loss involved in gas transport to hundreds of thousands of homes versus a single pipe to a power station
Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by britneybitch on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:35AM (#34339582)
There's also losses when transporting electricity. A pipe can be made perfectly airtight, but a wire cannot be made perfectly efficient*

*Yes I know about superconductors, that doesn't apply here

Re:The CPSC is on a mission that has nothing to do with safety by SamBam on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @03:08PM (#34343896)
That's simply not true, because you aren't accounting for the large losses in energy between the flames and the food. Induction is significant more efficient at getting the heat to the food.