Why are you waiting for someone else to do this? Do it yourself!
Something that bothers me more than most things is when people demand others act to solve a growing problem. Sure, you're not the most qualified person to do it, but actual execution trumps qualifications every time.
Get out there! Get in touch with some excellent game designers, ask them what it would take to get their help. Come up with a plan based on their feedback and execute it!
Or at least if you're not going to do it, recognize that your reasons for not doing it are probably exceedingly similar to everyone else's reasons for not doing it, and stop asking the question.
I would agree with this, however most people can't organise and maintain the most mundane aspects of their lives, let alone gather a large group of people together to combat some big goal like this.
I agreed up until this part. Even if you aren't going to do it, stoking the fire with otherwise idle conversation might get more motivated individuals interested.
I've approached two of my favorites, back possibly too long ago before Kickstarter was more of a known quantity, and they both said "hard pass" at the time.
Do it yourself, or at least examine why you won't, and then recognize that the people involved are also humans, and many of those reasons you and others here have listed apply to these "special" people too.
Discussion is nearly worthless; so many people can generate so much of it for so little cost, it must be worth basically nothing. There's far too much of it, and far too little action.
This site is literally the social media arm of a startup accelerator, go start something up!
"Can anyone shoot holes through this idea of mine? Has anyone else already done this? Is anyone else interested in helping me do this?"
Or would that still warrant discouragement from you? Because, honestly, that's the tone I intended. And if you can't read that tone, maybe that's on you?
> In addition to Paizo, Kobold Press, Chaosium, Legendary Games, and a growing list of publishers have already agreed to participate in the Open RPG Creative License, and in the coming days we hope and expect to add substantially to this group.
This would be roughly akin to Google, Microsoft, Meta, and Rackspace announcing they would work together to fight some awful cloud computing initiative from Amazon. But thanks for angrily telling one dude on HN that he should be the one to lead the charge. Really great advice, thanks.
https://paizo.com/community/blog/v5748dyo6si7v?Paizo-Announc...
I don't know if there are others or not.
Similarly, I was coming in to post Sufficiently Advances, which is (I think) Creative Commons.
As always, the issue isn't so much content, is selling people on it so they use it, get excited, get involved. Like everything open, when you don't have a budget to make that happen, it gets a lot harder.
The big problem is that there's not a single one that everybody agrees to use as the new standard. D&D is the standard. Like Windows. Everybody knows it sucks, but nobody can agree on a single alternative, and the market stays with what people know.
https://www.fudgerpg.com/about/about-fudge/fudge-ogl-require...
PF 2.0 also uses OGL:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Pathfinder2e/comments/104wjuo/why_d...
I don't understand why there needs to be "a standard". in the 80's, 90's people played Runequest, Warhammer, GURPS, AD&D, Dark Eye... there was no need for a "standard". No, people are lazy and just want to play what is popular, this isn't a standard. Games rules are half the table top RPG, the stories are as important if not more...
Furthermore, back in the days, people were interested in innovative rules or universes, D&D is none of that, it's the most bland and boring game system...
There’s a huge network effect at work here. It’s easier to find D&D players than players of any other game — not that you can’t find them, but D&D is easier. WotC runs organized play programs such that I can walk into almost any brick and mortar tabletop gaming store in the country and immediately find a regular game.
Look at https://startplaying.games/search and count the number of D&D games compared to anything else.
And this has happened before. D&D 4e got rid of the OGL, which made people have these same conversations. This did create Pathfinder, but even cloning the earlier version of D&D didn’t prevent WotC from dominating except during the year or two between 4e and the current edition. Plus 4e played really differently, which won’t be the case for this new edition.
People still are. There's been tons of innovation over the past 20 years, and some of it even seeped into D&D and Warhammer.
But despite everything, D&D is still the big name everybody recognises. Maybe there doesn't need to be a standard, but there is, and it's D&D. Just like with Windows.
TTRPG rules are not tabletop game rules: they don't say what happens, GM does. TTRPG rules are a language that abstracts away trivia in a somewhat objective manner.
This is similar to having many programming languages: ideally you would want to have a single language for everything, but they all suck in different small ways.
Just because you bottled lightning once, doesn’t mean you can do it ever again.
And I think the nature of open content is still relatively new, so that's the best explanation I have for why it hasn't been done yet.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Fantasy_RPG
[1]: https://www.basicfantasy.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=4596...
No need to even do that, there is plenty of alternative RPG and game systems out there already. It's not about money. It's about principles. But people wants to play "D&D", Hasbro's IP, Hasbro rules and business practices...
But also let's not forget how some conferences managed to shut down and shun the competition by forbidding them to attend the conferences to promote their alternative creations, insuring Hasbro/WotC prominent market shares... There is a lot to say about that "community", a lot of corrupt individuals...
GUMSHOE, FATE, Forged in the Dark, Dungeon World, Quest, and Trophy are all available under CC BY licenses. Many of those are fairly popular (if you don’t compare them to D&D) — six figure Kickstarter revenue, for example. Creative Commons has been a reasonably common choice for game designers who want open content for a decade or so.
> GUMSHOE - Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution Unported License
> FATE - Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) / OGL
> Forged in the Dark (Blades in the Dark) - Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) license.
> Dungeon World - Creative Commons Attribution
> Quest - Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Public License
> Trophy - custom, permissive-looking license
Yours was by far the most helpful response I got.
There's also this list:
https://wiki.rpg.net/index.php/Open_Game_Systems
Which I found from another thread you were in:
> In addition to Paizo, Kobold Press, Chaosium, Legendary Games, and a growing list of publishers have already agreed to participate in the Open RPG Creative License, and in the coming days we hope and expect to add substantially to this group.
https://paizo.com/community/blog/v5748dyo6si7v?Paizo-Announc...
Why do we not crowdfund some excellent game designers to make a truly open set of RPGs?
Some that would be amenable to making into Computer RPGs.
Some that maybe that would be nearly impossible to automate. (That's fine, too.)
Under some licenses like CC BY / CC BY-SA / CC BY-NC?
I _like_ buying RPG books. I would continue to do so, even if the license was CC BY. I also like getting searchable PDFs, and turning dungeons into a Wiki for the DM to make it easy to find content.
I mean... Come on...