I wonder what's the future of power generation in the region, because the planned replacement nuclear power plant still exists purely on paper after at least a decade of talks.
Whereas if the US consumer stop buying oversize trucks and stop flying cross country for social events, they will actually save money!
It's simply not equatable to expect a poor country like South Africa to make sacrifices while the US (a rich country) refuse to levy a carbon tax.
I’m not sure why everyone talks about flying. It’s a rounding error.
I never realized South Africa was such a big emitter of CO2.
It only has 15 coal power plants?
https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/south-africa-taken-cour...
And we certainly don’t want people driving 1000 miles instead of flying
If the electricity comes from coal or nuclear, no one would know the difference, except for the cleaner air
> And we certainly don’t want people driving 1000 miles instead of flying
Not necessarily true. A single person in a gasoline car, yes, flying is probably slightly less dirty. More than one person in the car? Driving wins.
Isn’t that the way it’s usually done?
“Let’s get everyone in the world to ride a bicycle”
What sort of solution is this?
The best way to solve this "tragedy of the commons" problem is through a tax where a market system can determine what should be changed.
Yes, the article is not a realistic solution, but neither is closing coal plants (without replacing them with something else).
Taxation is also a grand top down view of the economy.
You've got to figure out the details of an equitable amount. Do different countries pay different amounts? Are there subsidizes for the poor? Are other greenhouse gases, like nitrous oxide, also included, and at what rate? If someone doesn't pay, how is the tax enforced?
All those are part of a grand vision.
Just like the grand top down view wherein "nationalists and communists" decided to ban most CFC emissions. And the "nationalists and communists" who decided to ban commercial whaling, outside of a few nations.
How would the superior capitalistic system have solved those problems? It's not like the capitalistic system is doing that great a job of preserving commercial fishing.
The "Tragedy of the Commons" was based on a fairy-tale interpretation of history. The far greater tragedy occurred due to the commons owners enclosing the land and breaking commoner's rights of use.
A.k.a. "capitalism".
There are many reasonable answers and proposals to these questions.
Here's one: https://citizensclimatelobby.org/carbon-pricing-studies/
The EU has already placed a price on some emissions: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Emissions_Tra...
Wikipedia says "In economics and in an ecological context, the tragedy of the commons is a situation in which individual users, who have open access to a resource unhampered by shared social structures or formal rules that govern access and use,[1][2] act independently according to their own self-interest and, contrary to the common good of all users, cause depletion of the resource through their uncoordinated action in case there are too many users related to the available resources". That is not a fairy tale.
Read more of that Wikipedia article, including "heavily criticized, particularly by anthropologists and historians":
> Critical scholars note that although taken as a hypothetical example by Lloyd, the historical demise of the commons of Britain and Europe resulted not from misuse of long-held rights of usage by the commoners, but from the commons' owners enclosing and appropriating the land, abrogating the commoners' rights.
as well as the criticism section at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Critici... with:
> Radical environmentalist Derrick Jensen claims the tragedy of the commons is used as propaganda for private ownership.[189][190] He says it has been used by the political right wing to hasten the final enclosure of the "common resources" of third world and indigenous people worldwide, as a part of the Washington Consensus
and
> Tragedy of the commons has served as a pretext for powerful private companies and/or governments to introduce regulatory agents or outsourcing on less powerful entities or governments, for the exploitation of their natural resources.
The tragedy of the commons is a parable that advocates neither capitalism nor socialism. It advocates the existence of a _responsible manager_ for any resource subject to exhaustion. Whether that manager should be a capitalist owner or a public entity is a separate question that comes in later.
And of course, it is entirely irrelevant whether the events described really happened. The broken window fallacy doesn't refer to one particular window-breaking incident.
Anyway, the concretization of the parable to the subject at hand is actually very straightforward: the atmosphere is the commons, and the carbon emitters are the commoners. Enclosures are an impossible solution this time, because we need to let the air to circulate freely. But the parable still teaches us the need for a single entity to be on charge of the atmosphere. National-level solutions - much less individual action - can only be a delaying tactic at best: the ozone layer was only saved by the Montreal Protocol. I'm old enough to remember public service messages encouraging the population to refrain from using unnecessary spray bottles, and that would have helped about as much as Dutch bikers help against global warming.
Another decade of R&D…
Wouldn’t it be better to be talking about 2060 instead of 2050?
The longer we do “nothing”, the more miracles we need.
The idea here is infrastructure change — behavioural change will follow (and has more benefits than just reduced emissions).
Proof that it's not crazy and silly is that this has actually been done in the Netherlands.
Edit: which of course is not to say that other sources of emissions also need to be addressed.
If something has been done in a country that's particularly compact, flat, and has mild winters, it may yet be crazy to think you can get the rest of the world to quickly follow suit.
I would also point out (as a general remark, not specifically aimed at you) that many of the arguments that have been made against better cycling infrastructure, could also have applied to the Netherlands a couple of decades ago. I think the idea is dismissed far more often than warranted, given how it was successful here anyway, which might indicate that gut instincts might need some calibration.
> And all we had to do was stop using coal a couple decades ago.
You realize this is a sunk cost, right? Imagine if we'd just started using nuclear in the 60's. And we all were hippies and there was no war. Imagine if we all held hands and sang kum-ba-ya. Pretty fun living in a fantasy world.
We were always going to develop to a point where behavioral change was necessary. Whether it was us today, or our children tomorrow.
Something the pandemic taught us is possible.
We absolutely need behaviour change, excluding that would be a mega (giga?) death scale error in judgement.
And we also need to move on all fronts, and can't afford to attack the biggest emission sources one by one serially (such as addressing coal plants first and transport after that). I think that's just obvious and this argument often seems like whataboutist rhetorical tactic.
Did you know there are only 8500 coal power plants in the entire world, and they produce 20% of CO2 emissions?
In fact it’s only a subset of those that are really bad.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/five-percent-power...
Decades and decades of “don’t eat meat”, “don’t fly”, …
And all we had to do was stop using coal a couple decades ago.