News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hbarka on Saturday January 07, 2023 @04:49AM (#34286686)
I don’t understand the disdain here in Hacker News for enterprise software. Every now and then this type of post would show up, decrying how terrible the user interface is or how awful looking the fonts are and how they can program the same functions in 1000 lines of code and support thousands of users.

These companies have revenue in the billions. They have enabled large companies, since before many of us were born. Your payroll and accrued sick leave and benefits deductions and AP/AR doesn’t miss a beat because of these companies. Apple runs on SAP (and Oracle and Workday), mind you. So does Google.

Are they bad or is it the crowd here?

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by themoonisachees on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:09AM (#34286781)
As a sysadmin i often get dealt the worst part of programs. I get thrown for the update stuff but never actually use the programs so i never get to say "well it's a pain tp update but a joy to use". When i was sysadmin in a small firm, updating SAP components was always the single most furstrating experience, and we ran Matlab.

As someone who has a degree in CS who had to go through "enterprise programming" courses, it's honestly appalling how SAP and Sage are. They're like the Teslas of programming, people who don't know better swear they're great but you can _see_ them coming apart at the seams, and you know that you could do better because you have, back in university.

add to that a healthy dose of anti-establisment and you get the hatred at SAP and Sage, bad products that are viable because they were first to market 30 years ago and now have the necessary connections to appear legit to unknowing decision makers. They have revenues in the billions because the sell the same software as 20 years ago at a premium but switching would be too expensive, so the clients stay.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by brianwawok on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:33AM (#34287821)
I greatly enjoy my Tesla every time I drive it.

I have never enjoyed using SAP or Oracle products.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:42AM (#34287879)
What are doing in SAP? Supply Chain, Production, Finance? I pitty you if it is logistics...
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by brianwawok on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:57AM (#34288525)
Right now nothing!!

But have used concur and been parallel to some of the other products…

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by dig1 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:07AM (#34286772)
I think it is a superiority complex. SAP, IBM, Oracle (and many small companies running for ages) are all making "shitty" products, yet, every year, their revenue is in billions.

On the other hand, we have "beautifully hand-crafted products with love" made in the best languages human can invent (your favorite language only HN crowd dicking around), and those companies are barely paying their developers and bills. But hey, their products are auto-scalable, kubernetes managed, disrupting the industry, powered with green, recycled energy, and vegan food with hand-picked ingredients...

I'll leave it to the astute reader to concur with the pattern here.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by neuronic on Saturday January 07, 2023 @07:20AM (#34287398)
Did you really have to add a jab at vegan food and renewable energy in there and somehow make this about politics?

Where is this weird (and frankly suspicious) hostility against either of those even rationally coming from?

No need to act as if "crazy HN hipster developers" (apparently your perspective) are the only ones who don't understand that there is a very good reason why SAP is still used at Apple and Google.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by QuadmasterXLII on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:36AM (#34288302)
The connecting thread through veganism, climate change, and enterprise software is that you can accrue significant personal benefits by causing suffering elsewhere, and you will never have to face consequences for that suffering. In fact, anyone who even shows you that suffering is a hippie bastard
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by dig1 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#34290506)
The funny thing is that people are easily offended these days simply by including trigger words they don't like to see in a negative context. I'd invite you and other downvoters to re-read my prose again. The focus was not on someone's personal choices but how those catchphrases are (ab)used in a context to promote something "healthy", yet the next month that company will be ready to lay off 70% of their workforce without a problem due to their bad business model.

I was fortunate to be in touch with renewable energy companies (professionally and indirectly), and you'd be surprised how unhealthy those things are for the environment on a grand scale. But, YMMV...

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by neuronic on Saturday January 07, 2023 @04:55PM (#34293301)
Sorry, disagree. You put these words in your original comment with intent so do not be surprised when people respond to that. This kind of behavior feels weird and suspicious and in my eyes it's telling that you immediately default to calling others out about being "offended" when offending was your intent to begin with.

Otherwise why inject politics and talk about triggering? You are doing the framing.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:01AM (#34286744)
Thank you! I once had the pleasure (ahem) to work with a "solution architect" who shared the opinion around enterprise software you mentioned. He was in charge of getting the MRP running, but he had no idea how MRP works, e.g. he set thought having one (!) use case without (!) lead times life represents a successful implementation... Almost a year later, I still try to clean that mess up...
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by robertlagrant on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:03AM (#34286754)
I have a similar thing with people who think snow is white. Joseph Stalin also thought that, and he killed 50 million people!
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:10AM (#34286785)
Come again?
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by douglee650 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:41AM (#34288365)
It's an allegory OP is making to express their disdain for anecdotal correlation, illustrated here by the absurdity in which the story of a solution architect making a mistake based on a single case, is itself an anecdotal correlation …

The purpose of which is to paint an entire class of people (solution architects) as reactive (makes decisions based on a single piece of information).

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:54AM (#34289173)
Well, I did talk about one specific solution architect. One that got the fundamental basics of ERP systems wrong. And part of the problem was his superficial, at best, understanding of ERP systems and underlying processes. The last part is ehat said solution architect has in common with the vast majority of commenters under this submission.
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by douglee650 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:41AM (#34289708)
Nice, i was trying to get into the motives of the "snow is white equals Joseph Stalin" commenter. Not a condemnation of your statement.
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:55AM (#34289900)
>> Not a condemnation of your statement.

I didn't take it as such. And you really helped, because was a total loss with OP's comment...

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by robertlagrant on Saturday January 07, 2023 @01:44PM (#34291157)
Sibling comment nailed it. It's just a brief analogous category error.

Someone thought SAP was bad and messed up an implementation, therefore people who think SAP is bad mess up implementations.

Someone thought snow was white and killed 50m people, therefore people who think snow is white are mass murderers.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @04:02PM (#34292751)
Ok, you got me. I am no match to your logic nor your argumentative skills. SAP sucks, because its UI is bad. Doubly so because the UI of an expense solution SAP acquired through a third party is bad. You win.

Now someone has to come up with something that solves all the other challenges industrial enterprises have. And tell them whatever alternative was developed is actually so much better that an ERP system change is warrented.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by robertlagrant on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:08AM (#34297729)
You seem to have needlessly changed the topic. I'm refuting the specific point I was talking about. You seem to be cheering for your team regardless of pros and cons.
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by deadpannini on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:41AM (#34287877)
What you say is true, but these companies aren't successful because their products are usable. They succeeded because of their first-mover advantage, lack of alternatives, and compliance requirements that raise the cost of competition. We don't owe them any respect when it comes to UX.

I can see how it gets tiresome reading repetitive arguments, but a solid theory undergirds all the criticism: that one way to beat SAP, oracle, Microsoft, etc. Is to provide a better user experience.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hef19898 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:51AM (#34287931)
Nefore better UI and UX help you beat SAP and co, you need compliant, and industry specific ERP functions on par with them. And then you need to sway all those existing customers away from them. In market that doesn't value UI half as much as you seem to think.
Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by deadpannini on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:12AM (#34288098)
I agree that the enterprise market does not value usability very much, and I would even agree that the enterprise vendors made the right choice to deliver anything at all, in the early stages of ERP (two decades?).

None of that means the software is good: we can recognize the smart business choices those companies made and also abhor their products.

They provide what Alan Cooper calls "Dancing bearware" - it doesn't matter how badly the bear dances, they're just grateful to have a bear that can do it at all.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by hbarka on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:28PM (#34292389)
User experience is fleeting. I like the user experience of manual transmission cars but >80% of new drivers today would scream user experience if you gave them one. Perhaps the complaint here comes from these types of users who expect novelty to their liking.

There was a comical reference to Tesla. If you’ve only experienced the user experience headache that Tesla forces on you every time they have a major software update (at least 2x a year). The muscle memory has to adapt.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by IceDane on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:04PM (#34290025)
They are bad, and the crowd is dismissive.

I work in this industry, though I work almost exclusively with non SAP related stuff.

On one hand, the problems being solved are complicated and for some products, there are decades of embedded domain knowledge, and they have a lot of products, and can basically do anything any kind of business needs to be able to do, and integrate it somehow with other parts of the system.

On the other hand... large parts of it are absolutely horribly engineered. ABAP is a programming language that makes me recoil in disgust. What it is is the result of polishing the same turd for several decades, seemingly without one person or group ever trying to think about the direction or bigger picture for the whole stack(which is just impossibly large at this point, and like a tentacle monster from another dimension).

It does work, but mostly because people have been hammering out the kinks for thousands of person-years. As for the things said about the consulting industry.. they are definitely true.

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by wlonkly on Saturday January 07, 2023 @06:57PM (#34294431)
I don't understand the disdain here in Woodworking News for Ikea furniture.

(Business success and the craft of software development, or of user interface design, and so forth, are related, but not the same thing.)

Re:Software horror show: SAP Concur by downvoteme1 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:45PM (#34295136)
As an ERP consultant, I love when these discussions come up. It spreads more hatred for Oracle and SAP among the developer community and keeps my jobs safe.